Easily the strongest effort to date in 1985 from James Ivory and his producer Ishmail Merchant—it was a box office hit of sorts- and the Oscars loved it as well- 8 noms, 3 wins (screenplay, art direction costumer) and other noms for picture, Ivory, the DP, Denholm Elliot, and Maggie Smith
Adapted screenplay was won by Ruth Prawer Jhabvala—she’s really the third part of Merchant Ivory as she wrote many of their works and almost all of their best ones
Helena Bonham Carter’s film debut at 19- a revelation
Many critics at the time noticed that new-comer Daniel Day-Lewis had two films released on the same day—this (he’s part of the ensemble here) and My Beautiful Launderette from Stephen Frears—the range on display in those two films is pretty staggering
EM Forster adaptation and one of, if not the best one
The opening credits with the beautiful crests is inspired—especially when combine it with the Puccini music
Shooting on location in Tuscany
Much of the opening is a comedy of manners- what is proper, what is rude, there are chaperones, tact and delicacy discussion
The outspoken author (Dench) who is spontaneous vs the reserved (Maggie Smith) and uptight
The free young man (Julian Sands) vs. the very kept and proper Bonham Carter—all of this amongst a beautiful backdrop
Sculpture montage like Shakespeare-Wallah from Ivory in 1965
Location and players involved in white titles throughout
Denholm Elliot is so good at playing the likeable boob—just like Marcus in the Indiana Jones series
In 2018 now I see the connection to Call Me By Your Name (Ivory won screenplay Oscar for writing)—the story and the landscapes and travelogue
The unspoken poppies/barley field kiss scene is wonderful filmmaking. Opera music
Julien Sands doesn’t have to talk much which is good for him- he’s often an uneven performer but very solid here
Bonham Carter’s hair should get a credit in the film- haha- gorgeous
DDL is good here- it’s a bold performance- very “go for it” as Cecil. It’s closer to being so over the top it belongs in a different film but I still think it’s a success—it makes for another comic juxtaposition like Dench/Smith and Sands/Bonham-Carter– DDL’s Cecil is so different from Sands and they compete for Bonham-Carter—the scene where DDL asks to kiss her is directly contrasted with Sands’ scene where he doesn’t ask- it’s great writing—DDL’s Cecil’s kiss here is an abject comic disaster
Well-manicured English lawns,
Like almost all Merchant Ivory there’s nudity here with the pond scene- male frontal
There’s more to Smith’s character than meets the eye at first- a very well-rounded character and I love the arch
The kiss at the end looking out the window with Puccini again is a big success- legit passion and earned romance
[…] A Room with a View – Ivory […]
Things aren’t boding well for Julian Sands sadly
@Harry- Saw this, sad, hope for the best of course. Sands has always been an adventurous actor with some of the roles and films he’s chosen