Kar-Wai Wong. For the purposes of this list his strengths are his two giant masterpieces and the fact that he is certainly a “style-plus” director. It’s hard to think of an auteur that is more of a “style-plus” director actually which would support the argument that Kar-Wai Wong belongs in the top 5 or 10 on this list and not 22nd . On the other hand, his filmography doesn’t warrant top 5-10 ranking and frankly doesn’t quite match even some of those behind him on this list. Almost nobody though has a film to touch In the mood for Love. It’s my highest rated movie from 1983- to now—hard to account for that on this list. His weakness is the back end of that overall filmography though I’m really excited to revisit The Grandmaster and a few others.
Best film: In the Mood for Love. Scroll down to the stylistic innovation/traits section- this film has got it all and it haunts me for weeks if not months after every time I see it because of the formal magnificence. It continues to move up my all-time list. The film’s form is as good or better than any film in cinema history—it may be my go-to example now when discussing film form—along with Dreyer’s Passion of Joan of Arc, Ozu and Toyko Story, and the combined oeuvre of Jim Jarmusch—a combination of Greenaway’s stylistic maximums (and form), Jarmusch’s strict repetition. The violins in the score by as Mike Galasso and Shigeru Umebayashi – reiteration. Formal genius- slow-motion sequences, triggered by the same violin musical score as they have chance encounters in the hallway, alley—smoke and rain—always at night. It’s elliptical—a feat of editing—we’re getting glimpses between the two like Pawlikowski’s Cold War. Half-open doorways giving beauty and depth to the focus in mise-en-scene(Ozu), passing each other on stairs.
total archiveable films: 8
top 100 films: 1 (In the Mood For Love)
top 500 films: 4 (In the Mood For Love, Chungking Express, 2046, Days of Being Wild)
top 100 films of the decade: 4 (In the Mood For Love, Chungking Express, 2046, Days of Being Wild)
most overrated: Happy Together– #362 all-time on TSPDT. I’ve only seen it once and I know Kar-Wai Wong’s films need more room to breathe than that. However, after one pass I think lofty consensus TSPDT (it’s not in my top 500) ranking has as much to do with the groundbreaking-ness of the story/narrative as it does with Kar-Wai Wong direction and that’s just not something I put a lot of stock in.
most underrated : 2046 at #875 all-time on TSPDT and I’m at #338. The visuals are closer to In the Mood for Love than the consensus ranking would allude.
gem I want to spotlight: Days of Being Wild. If you haven’t seen it check it out. It’s really the beginning all of the stylistic traits used in Chungking and In the Mood for Love. The color pattern is different (there’s a gorgeous yellow/green neon hue to it all) but it’s still all about bold formal and aesthetic choices for Kar-Wai Wong.
stylistic innovations/traits: In a word: lyrical. This is where you can go crazy with Kar-Wai Wong and have fun. His films’ themes and narratives are invocations of memory and regret. He’s known for his virtuoso camerawork with director of photography Christopher Doyle, split storylines, and elliptical editing. He’s avant-garde with his mise-en-scene framing, slow motion, jump cuts, fragmented images, formal repetition of music, drenched color tones and use of neon. He’s a wonderful auteur. He repeats the use of symbols (clocks), back of heads (not unlike Lynch). He uses the same song over and over like “California Dreamin” in Chungking and Nat King Cole in In the Mood for Love. I’ve mentioned many other directors from Dreyer to Greenaway—I could see it being a combination of Jarmusch and Malick as well—the formal rigor and genius-level photography—Malick isn’t perfect because he shoots nature and WKW shoots cities—but I’m having a hard time finding another auteur who shot films as handsome as the two of them—Michael Mann maybe- I mean Mann makes beautiful urban films but again never quite like Kar-Wai Wong.
top 10
- In the Mood for Love
- Chungking Express
- 2046
- Days of Being Wild
- Happy Together
- Ashes of Time
- The Grandmaster
- Fallen Angels
By year and grades
| 1990- Days of Being Wild | MS |
| 1994- Ashes of Time | R |
| 1994- Chungking Express | MP |
| 1995- Fallen Angels | R |
| 1997- Happy Together | R |
| 2000- In the Mood For Love | MP |
| 2004- 2046 | MS |
| 2013- The Grandmaster | R |
*MP is Masterpiece- top 1-3 quality of the year film
MS is Must-see- top 5-6 quality of the year film
HR is Highly Recommend- top 10 quality of the year film
R is Recommend- outside the top 10 of the year quality film but still in the archives
@Drake – Have you caught Blossoms Shanghai?
@Drake: Have you checked out Blossoms Shanghai? How is it?
@AP- I have not yet
Blossoms Shanghai getting Criterion Channel release
https://thefilmstage.com/wong-kar-wais-blossoms-shanghai-sets-criterion-channel-release-beginning-this-month/
Study Summary: Wong Kar Wai
I actually did a Wong Kar Wai Study a few years ago, it was only my 2nd study. However, my first few studies were just me watching the films of directors in chronological order and giving grades, so I wanted to do a proper Study with my Notes and Thoughts Sections
Similar to auteurs such as Terence Malick, David Lynch, and David Fincher amongst others, Wong Kar Wai has a visual style that is so singularly recognizable that it can be detected within a matter of seconds. Chungking Express (1994) is the first Wong Kar Wai film that I watched, and I was absolutely floored, especially by the use of step-printing in the opening sequence; I had never seen anything quite like it
While he has a unique visual style, WKW examines universal themes related to the human condition: love, regret, nostalgia, loneliness, longing, etc. Many of his characters are hopeless romantics or involved in an unrequited love in some way. In Chungking Express (1994) Cop 223 is particularly memorable in his romantic failures due to his zany personality, he humorously becomes obsessed with eating cans of pineapples over the course of a month as a test to see if his romance is truly over or in other words if his romance will expire before the pineapples
Almost all of WKW top level work can be described as mood pieces. This is part of what makes WKW expressionist use of color so critical beyond the incredible aesthetic value. Days of Being Wild (1990) uses various shades of greens and some blue hues in order to reflect the characters internal emotions. Happy Together (1997) makes great use of juxtaposing Montone and color in capturing the volatility of film’s central relationship. In the Mood for Love (2000) and 2046 (2004) use vibrant reds to capture the repressed passions of the characters
The characters in WKW films often ponder their purpose in life. He is one of the best at examining ennui along with auteurs like Michaelangelo Antonioni and Sofia Coppola. He uses a substantial amount of voice over narration in Chungking Express, Fallen Angels, Happy Together, and 2046. Characters are often fixated on past relationships or even brief flings
Wong Kar Wai has style in spades; he has step-printing, meticulous use of color in décor and mise en scene, extensive use of saturated colors, fragmented framing, shallow focus close ups, frames in frames, low canted angle shots, splitting frames, voice over narration, use of slow motion followed by rapid cuts with a variety of camera angles, pairing characters with particular pop songs such as California Dreamin’ with Faye Wong’s character in Chungking Express , among others stylistic elements
WKW and Tony Leung are an all-time great director/actor duo. Tony Leung has considerable range as he can play an intellectual, a playboy, an everyman, a hopeless romantic, and a master of martial arts amongst other roles
I had a tough time picking between Chungking Express (1994) and In the Mood For Love (2000) for the top spot and I don’t think there is really a wrong answer, but I am going to go with Chungking Express by the narrowest of margins. I have both films as top 30 films of all time. I know In the Mood For Love (2000) is the consensus and I certainly do not have any problem with that
For Chungking I’ll reiterate what I wrote previously:
“This is an all-timer for me. It is truly original and feels just as fresh today as it did when I saw it for the first time 5 years ago. It is humorous with zany characters who have endearing qualities, in particular Cop 223 and Faye Wong’s character who is named Faye in the film. The performances are excellent all the way around with contrasting characters in Takeshi Kaneshiro as Cop 223 and Tony Leung as Cop 663. The film is specular visually with the step printing technique which as noted above is not only visually appealing but fits thematically into WKW’s focus on time and memory. Other visually highlights include the use of neon color in the lighting, unusual camera angles, use of frames in frames, and mix of night and daytime shots. The 2 act structure and pacing are ideal as well; this works better at 100 minutes than it would have at 120-140 minutes”
Days of Being Wild and 2046 are both clear cut MP as well and Fallen Angels is borderline MP
I could see Happy Together move to higher grade with rewatches but for the most part I am quite confident with these grades
While I have three films above it, I do think it could be argued that 2046 is WKW most ambitious film. While all of his films have common themes, It does feel like a grand finale of sorts. It is in a category similar to The Tree of Life (2011) as you have an artist creating something that they had been building towards for a long time. 2046 has all the WKW traits taken to the extreme
Final Ranking and Grades:
# 1 Chungking Express (1994) – MP
# 2 In the Mood For Love (2000) – MP
# 3 Days of Being Wild (1990) – MP
# 4 2046 (2004) – MP
# 5 Fallen Angels (1995) – MP/MS
# 6 Happy Together (1997) – MS/HR
# 7 The Grandmaster (2013) – MS/HR
# 8 Ashes of Time (1994) – HR
# 9 As Tears Go By (1988) – HR
Blossoms Shanghai is getting US release by the end of 2025 via Criterion Channel
https://variety.com/2025/tv/news/wong-kar-wai-blossoms-shanghai-criterion-channel-1236436020/
The Grandmaster (2013)
Notes:
Cast:
Tony Leung Chiu-Wai as Ip Man (Ye Wen),
Zhang Ziyi as Gong Ruo Mei (aka Gong Er)
Wu Yixuan as young Gong Er
Zhang Jin as Ma San
Starts with gorgeous blue tinted frame with raindrops falling in slow motion
3:25 all out brawl with a mix of rapid movements and slow motion
5:17 close up profile of LP Man before one on one battle in the heavy rain
6:36 nice use of silhouette and blocking
10:58 camera panning over room with medium and medium close up shots, lack of establishing shot is notable in film so far
12:42 shots of characters captured in unusual frames
13:40 Zhang Jin as Ma San enters room in dramatic fashion, close up shot on his face
15:19 returns to blue lit rainy streets
18:36 orange and yellow hues used for shots of interiors
20:13 slow motion shot of Sister San jumping from staircase followed by alternating shots of her and LP Man who start hand to hand combat shortly after
22:21 rapid cuts continues with various camera positions and angles with occasion shallow focus
27:57 shot held after slow motion with both LP Man and Gong extending their arms while touching a flat cake which is explained as a metaphor for Chinese Unity between the North and South during this time of turmoil caused by Japanese invasion
30:56 off center framing
32:10 inverted image in puddle
33:38 voice over narration with slow motion pans up
34:06 Kurosawa level of blocking
36:28 overhead shot of LP Man with hand to hand combat vs Gong Er
41:32 profile shot of LP Man with soft focus in the negative space
42:45 portrait of LP Man with his family, the color is drained from the image which becomes a photograph
46:46 change to Hong Kong in 1950
51:13 slow motion juxtaposed by rapid cuts during another combat sequence
53:24 extreme close up on fire from match
57:17 green hazy streets at night
58:21 beautiful, inverted image in puddle with blue tined frame
1:00:15 another shot of LP Man shot in the dark with only his face visible
1:05:08 10 years earlier in Northern China, there is tension as Japan is using Manchuria as a puppet state to control their interests
1:06:00 beautiful frame with blocking and symmetrical frame
1:08:36 a rare wide angle shot capturing the frozen winter landscape
1:12:24 blurry image moving through doorway with nice use of frame in frame
1:14:47 gorgeous imagery with silhouette figures in blue/green tinted part of frame
1:17:33 shot reverse shot with off center characters shown in isolation in frame
1:18:45 after montage build up and slow motion near train station platform, great sequence of hand to hand combat
1:29:17 alternating between close ups on character’s face in shot reverse shot with only the head visible with the rest of the frame surrounded by black
1:32:42 stunner in shot of city streets with green and blue hazy fog substance
1:35:06 green/blue tinted screen with close up on snow fall
1:41:41 ends with great blocking in shot with the color fading to monotone
Thoughts:
Wong Kar Wai takes on a martial arts film mixed with elements of a historical drama. Like all other WKW films the genre is more or less a canvass for him to create his own distinct film style
This film is gorgeous; I particularly love the use of blue hues in depicting the rainy streets at night that starts the film and is used several times throughout the film. While WKW incorporates weather into some of his previous films, it is not to the same degree as this film which features extreme close ups of rain drops and snowflakes. The heavy use of rain even gives the film a noir-like visual style at times, especially when considering the use of silhouette, a number of times
WKW uses incredible blocking that you could mistake for Kurosawa or Visconti. There are several times throughout the film where a group is captured in a frame only for the color to drain as if transformed into a photograph
Another film without many establishing shots. Instead, there are numerous medium and medium close ups which serves to mystify the spatial components of the film’s location, resulting in a more chaotic experience. The combat sequences are particularly impressive in the way that they are choreographed. This if further accomplished by the use of slow motion and rapid cuts with changes in camera angles
Tony Leung is great as always. This is the most physically challenging role I have seen. He has the physical abilities, and the intelligence required a role like this
The narrative does feel a little unfocused at times. Wong Kar Wai’s films are known for their focus on mood, atmosphere, and character over traditional narrative or plot, this is part of the magic of his work. However, I do think this is one film of his that would have benefited from something resembling a more traditional narrative, at least to some extent
Verdict: MS/HR
2046 (2004)
Notes:
Cast:
Tony Leung as Chow Mo-wan, a journalist and writer
Maggie Cheung as Su Li-zhen
Gong Li as a second Su Li-zhen. Presented as a professional gambler nicknamed “Black Spider”
Faye Wong as Wang Jing-wen
Carina Lau as Mimi/Lulu, a former cabaret dancer and Mo-wan’s ex-lover who is still mourning the death of her boyfriend Yuddy. Lau reprises her role from Days of Being Wild
Starts with shot of a dark orb and a fade out, gold and black imagery
2:33 multi-color imagery of a network that looks like something out of Blade Runner or Metropolis or maybe even 2001 A Space Odyssey
4:56 gold and brown orb that is a visual representation of the hole in the tree that Chow speaks into at the end of In the Mood For Love, confessing a secret he can’t share with anyone
5:44 Tony Leung as Chow passes Carina Lau’s character Lulu in the staircase
8:24 another shot of multi-color global network
9:26 slow motion with red lighting throughout the frame with Chow narrating how he has become a ladies-man who has frequent one night stands
10:30 off-center framing of Lulu with red curtain taking up 2/3 of the frame
10:56 profile shot with splitting of frame
12:50 slow pan across the hotel room
14:18 close up profile shot of Chow
14:51 fragmented framing in series of two-shots
17:07 the score used near the end of Days of Being Wild (1990) followed by slow motion sequence set to score and red décor
18:01 green tint
19:16 cutaway shot to hotel lights
19:23 green décor
20:57 frame split into thirds
23:13 shot of perforated glass
23:46 another cutaway shot featuring standing next to a blue neon lit sign while standing near the end of the frame, beautiful use of silhouette in this sequence which follows a breakup, blue as melancholy or isolation
24:44 slow motion with smoking cigarette
27:48 stunning image with use of red lighting and décor
37:48 frame in frame with shallow focus
38:35 another cutaway shot to neon lit hotel sign
39:03 shot of Christmas tree followed by slow pan set to Nat Cole’s Christmas song
42:45 a single tear down cheek of Gong li character
45:52 monotone used for the first time in the film
53:53 extreme close up on Chow’s face in profile
54:25 another sex scene which uses overhead shots
57:21 another use of jade green in the décor
1:05:06 frame in frame with shallow focus
1:07:25 nice blocking in this two-shot of Chow and Faye Wong’s character Wang Jing-wen
1:10:54 characters speaking off screen with shot of green wall
1:14:31 after another cutaway shot of the hotel sign there is a cut to a red infused frame
1:16:02 split frame with Chow standing in rain at night with a yellow light illuminating him
1:16:37 cinematic painting of the skyline over the hotel sign
1:18:58 saturated red lighting in shot featuring android
1:20:40 the Cambodian folktale about the tree that stores secrets is referenced by a character
1:24:00 saturated red used in shot of hallway, the next scene is transitioned via flash of bright light
1:25:14 reds, yellows, and oranges in shots of Androids
1:27:38 stunning use of red and green lighting
1:34:28 frames in frames with this shot of the hallway in saturated red
1:36:21 Chow standing over shot of hotel that has been repeated throughout the film
1:44:30 split frame with solid green wall, Gong Li’s sad character after being turned down
1:45:27 slow motion/blurry image of motion in the background of the frame while Chow sits still in the foreground of the frame, there is a similar shot in Chungking Express
1:47:55 back and forth dialogue with camera alternating in shots of two characters
1:51:39 Chow loses at high card against mysterious woman gambler
1:54:54 Su Li-zhen breaks down crying, similar to a scene from In the Mood For Love
2:01:10 Su Li-zhen wants Chow to stay with her in emotional sequence
2:03:27 narration from earlier is repeated in monotone followed by camera moving toward an orb which ends the film
Thoughts:
I was especially looking forward to revisiting this film as I had not seen it nearly as many times as Chungking Express or In the Mood for Love
Many of the WKW thematic elements are present here; the search for meaning/happiness, love, missed opportunities, nostalgia, regrets, etc. While there is a science fiction element present, it is actually quite minimal in its impact on the film. Really Wong Kar Wai ‘s films are their own genre and 2046 is no exception to this
Tony Leung is of course amazing; this is to be expected but it is remarkable just how consistently great he is. I am yet to see a Tony Leung performance that is anything less than spectacular. Apparently, it was Leung’s idea for his character to have a mustache even though Wong Kar Wai initially did not approve but Leung insisted he needed some type of physical change for the sake of his character transforming since In the Mood for Love. The cast is loaded with many of the biggest Hong Kong superstars of the time, especially the actresses
A visual marvel, there are no cinematically quiet stretches. The use of color is crucial on several levels, starting with the most obvious which is the undeniable aesthetic value. There are numerous stunning images which use saturated colors. WKW use of color in each frame is so meticulous, and impactful in the way color is often juxtaposed frame by frame. The formal importance of color cannot be overstated. Like most other WKW films, the flow of time is depicted via association. In 2046 the various love interests of Tony Leung’s Chow are associated with particular colors; Faye Wong’s character is associated with jade green, Gong Li’s character is associated with black, and Carina Lau’s character is associated with red. Color is used like the film version of a stanza; there is a rhythm in the way it defines each frame
Red is associated with passion and love. Black is often associated with mystery making it the perfect color for Gong Li’s mysterious character who is nicknamed “Black Spider” and is a professional gambler. Green and yellow are often associated with nostalgia. Gold is used along with bright colors in the shots that represent the futuristic world including the train that takes people to “2046”. The imagery of the futuristic world resembles a combination of Blade Runner, Metropolis, and Minority Report. Gold in this setting represents the allure of a romanticized past
Perhaps the most notable cinematic element along with the use of color is the fragmented framing. There are almost no standard shot/reverse shot sequences. There is frequent use off-center framing with the characters on the edge of the frame. There are a great number of profile shots used when characters are shown in isolation. These unusual spatial components further the emphasis on the loneliness of the characters who rarely see each other eye to eye in the same frame. There are notable similarities to Antonioni both visually and thematically. The fragmented framing is a great marriage of visual style and content/theme as the film is largely about memory, loss, and nostalgia. Human memory doesn’t work like a DVR, it is fragmented. Throughout the film there are shots where a character is only partially visible or shot through unusual, shaped frames. Other WKW films have this, but this is the most extreme use of this particular visual style
The costume design and production design are both top notch, both done by William Chang who did this for In a Mood For Love. The use of color in the décor is incredibly intricate, in particular the film is dominated with red and green with occasional yellow. I like the use of Christmas in the film as it works both visually given that green and red are the two most important colors in the film and thematically as being alone during Holidays really accentuates loneliness
This is a tremendous film though I would never recommend it to someone unfamiliar with Wong Kar Wai’s style, it would probably be the worst WKW film to start with
The line about people whispering a secret into a hold in a tree and covering up the hole, is repeated from In a Mood For Love (2000) and it is a very WKW thing to say. It is referenced multiple times throughout the film, even by one of the androids
While I do think this is his single best film, it might be his most ambitious. In many ways it feels like he was trying to make his magnum opus. It is also his longest film and the one that most resembles an epic. It feels operatic in many ways and even uses opera music as part of the score. The use of slow motion adds to the melancholy that comes and goes throughout the film
Verdict: MP
In The Mood For Love (2000)
Notes:
Cast:
Maggie Cheung as Su Li-zhen or Mrs. Chan
Tony Leung as Chow Mo-wan
Siu Ping Lam as Ah Ping, Chow’s co-worker
Rebecca Pan as Mrs. Suen, the Chans’ landlady
Kelly Lai Chen as Mr. Ho, Su’s employer
The film begins in 1962 with Maggie Cheung’s character named Su Li-zhen. She happens to be renting an apartment the same day as Tony Leung’s character named Chow Mo-wan
2:10 Mrs. Chan and Chow appear in the same frame
4:10 Chow meets Su Li in the hallways of the apartment followed by a fade to black edit
5:05 slow motion showing Su Li shot in frame in frame via doorway with violin score playing
5:28 Mrs. Chan and Chow walk past each other in confined hallway
6:08 Su Li speaks to her husband who is offscreen
11:57 Ah Ping is Chow’s co-worker; he has much different personality than Chow
13:03 the lead characters share the frame discovering a shared interest in martial art novels
13:34 profile shot of Mrs. Chan in a beautiful bright green dress
13:51 blurred visual shot through glass windowpane
14:01 semicircle frame in frame as both Su Li and Chow learn spouses are not around
15:01 slow motion with violin score as Mrs. Chang walks through crowded spaces followed by Chow walking in slow motion and finally Chow and Mrs. Chan passing each other on staircase
16:48 shot of Chow eating alone with shallow focus
20:25 another cutaway to the shot of a large white clock followed by use of soft focus
21:40 oval shaped frame, followed by a revelation that Mrs. Chan’s husband is having an affair
22:00 soft focus
24:04 Mrs. Chan at work, the office seems confined just like the apartment with little privacy, multiple frames in frames via windows and doorways
24:38 slow motion with violins playing as the leads pass each other in hallways
28:15 alternating profile shots of Mrs. Chan and Chow eating at the noodle bar as they realize their spouses are sleeping with one another
32:04 Mrs. Chan and Chow walking on the street at night with a fence resembling prison bars in the foreground of the frame, they theorize how their spouses might have met in the first place
36:21 frame in frame using doorway and deep focus
37:17 shot of hallways followed by an incredible two-shot with character blocking as Mrs. Chan is shot in profile in foreground with Chow in background of the frame slightly out of focus with red and shades of purple filling the frame
43:19 slow motion showing smoke with Chow writing while smoking a cigarette, it is implied that he is writing a martial arts novel
45:31 unusual and partially obstructed frame, frame is dominated with red décor
52:20 deep focus work and brilliant décor in this shot of hallway from red curtains
53:43 another unusual frame in frame when Mrs. Chan is at work
57:03 frame in frame with lead characters in close proximity in a shot with a voyeuristic feel
58:37 they continue to imagine the behavior of their cheating spouses with consistent camera movement with slow pans
1:01:03 red increasingly prominent in décor
1:02:18 pan over shade of green
1:03:03 frame in frame via doorway as Mrs. Chan watches tenants playing cards similar to opening
1:06:18 Chow and Mrs. Chan standing outside during rainstorm with Mrs. Chan wearing bright multi-color dress
1:09:50 two-shot of Chow and Mrs. Chan standing in the rain talking about their mutual attraction
1:12:40 another shot with bars in foreground while Mrs. Chan breaks down crying in the background with Chow comforting her
1:14:38 slow pan back and forth showing the two characters sitting back to back in separate rooms
1:17:11 slow motion shot of Chow walking down apartment hallway with red décor
1:18:00 Mrs. Chan in green dress crying while sitting in hotel room with 3 images of her
1:18:55 the film moves to Singapore 1963
1:20:15 Chow talks about whispering secrets into a tree and covering the hole in the tree with mud to cement the secret within the tree
1:23:27 soft focus shot of Mrs. Chan sitting inside hotel room by herself
1:24:16 slow motion profile shot of Mrs. Chan on phone
1:24:50 Hong Kong 1966
1:25:08 Mrs. Chan returns to old apartment
1:27:11 frame in frame using window, yellow mise en scene
1:28:54 brown and yellows in mise en scene
1:29:15 Cambodia 1966
1:29:57 Chow speaks into hole in a tree outside of Buddhist Temple, a flash of yellow light illuminates the frame
Thoughts:
Many consider this to be one of the greatest films of all time and it is difficult to argue otherwise. In the Mood for Love (2000) excels in numerous ways; there is the impeccable formal structuring, gorgeous costume design, vibrant use of color, and a simple but emotionally resonant narrative with two magnificent performances
The film forgoes establishing shots entirely and instead films the characters in confined spaces including the interior of apartment units, apartment hallways, hotels, noodle bars, offices, etc. The film uses frames in frames via windows, doorways, and other interior spaces. There are frequent medium shots and medium close ups. The characters are often positioned with their backs near the walls of interior spaces to further accentuate the claustrophobic atmosphere. The film also uses a fair amount of off-center framing which contributes to the loneliness of the characters; there is a particularly great shot at the 78 minute mark when Su Li-zhen sits alone in a hotel room with tears visible on her cheek
The use of slow motion, which is usually accompanied by a violin creates a powerful association effect that builds the mutual longing and connection of the two main characters. WKW uses this to create a particular rhythm. Many of these early sequences take place when they pass each other in the apartment hallways and share brief glances to build the mutual attraction
Similar to his other works, WKW prioritizes atmosphere, mood, visuals, and character over the narrative as there is little in the way of a discernable plot. The lack of traditional narrative is consistent with this being a memory film. The use of soft focus, slow motion, shallow focus, saturated colors in the décor, and close ups add to the dreamlike atmosphere. There are repeated cutaway shots of clocks, this is a common motif that WKW uses to emphasize time passing
Unlike many other great romances, the story is told in a way that is very understated. The great emotional sequences are powerful but far more restrained. Part of this is likely due to the setting of 1960s Hong Kong which is presented in a way that seems to imply a socially conservative culture. You also do not have a happy ever after ending that would probably be contractually obligated if made in Hollywood. It is a romantic film that does not contain a sex scene or even a single kiss. And the lack of a Hollywood happy ever after is especially powerful because the two lead characters are so likable and you want them to be happy. The scenes where Su Li-zhen cries are particularly devastating
The physical attractiveness of the lead characters is impossible to deny. Maggie Cheung’s beauty combined with her character’s immaculate dresses and their complementing hairstyles, gives her character Su Li-zhen a level of class and elegance that is nearly unattainable. Apparently, there were 46 dresses made by the art director and costume designer, William Chang although only 20-25 were actually used according to one source. Tony Leung’s character has a dapper appearance as he is sharply dressed at all times
WKW uses red to visual the suppressed emotions of the lead characters who do not consummate their repressed passions for one another. It is especially noticeable in the décor, for example the red curtains in the hallways where their interest in one another subtlety grows. The red in the décor becomes increasingly prominent in the 2nd act when they begin acting out the ways their spouses started an affair. Yellow, which is often associated with nostalgia and memory is used more in the last act including a shot when Tony Leung’s character speaks into the tree
There are no shots of the spouses of the two main characters although there are a few scenes where they are implied to be in close proximity just off camera. This further accentuates the loneliness the lead characters are feeling throughout the film outside of when they are together. Shallow focus is also effective in demonstrating how the characters feel alone even when there are people around them
Siu Ping Lam plays Chow’s co-worker who provides a modest amount of comic relief, he is a deadbeat who is always asking Chow for money so he can either gamble or go to a whorehouse. He is essentially the exact opposite of the classy Tony Leung character, yet he seems content. He is very direct in how he expresses his desires while Chow internalizes everything
This film is endlessly fascinating on a visual and formal level. The use of color in the décor is stunning as well as emotionally resonant in its simple but emotionally powerful narrative which is complete with two incredible acting performances
Verdict: MP (top 30 all time)
Happy Together (1997)
Notes:
Cast:
Leslie Cheung as Ho Po-Wing
Tony Leung Chiu-Wai as Lai Yiu-Fai
Chen Chang as Chang
Opens with a shot of passports
1:14 cut from color to a shot of the two men in bed together shot in monotone
2:32 close up or medium close ups used to shoot sex scene
4:18 great use composition to establish state of relationship as there is a shot of Wing inside the car and Fai in the deep background of the frame via car mirror
5:48 static long shot along highway
9:54 slow motion used to capture Fai’s mindset as heh watches Wing enter another man’s car
13:33 cutaway to a shot of billboard with fleeting use of color before returning to monotone
16:15 blurry image of depicting Fair running off
23:23 slow motion shot of the men riding in the back of a taxi with Wing putting his head on Fai’s shoulder and the men are both calm for the first time, the film has returned to color
25:55 aerial shot of Buenos Aires at night with fast motion of cars driving through the city
27:00 green light from car spreading throughout the frame
34:32 aerial shot of cloudy day at racetrack
37:30 Fai drinking in street corner by himself under red lighting
40:18 close up of Fai’s face with shallow focus background, Fai working in kitchen
44:15 high angle shot with Fai standing over Wing as they start a fight
48:48 picturesque shot of the men on a rooftop under a beautiful blue sky
53:57 orange sun light shining throughout the frame
57:44 shallow focus as Wing stands in front of mirror
58:14 series of quick cuts inside apartment with Wing walking out
59:24 physical fight starts with handheld camera capturing the chaos
1:00:01 desaturated color throughout the frame
1:04:42 vibrant red lighting during sequence at night
1:06:55 slow motion in background of frame with Fai shown in medium close up in foreground
1:07:54 colorful neon lights with Fai drinking beers outside bar/club
1:11:36 aerial shot of Buenos Aires at night with fast motion of cars driving through the city
1:12:36 print stepping effect
1:14:50 saturated red and yellow phone booth contrasts with duller nighttime shot
1:19:27 inverted image of city
1:21:10 return to monotone during series of jump cuts of car driving through highway and then a return to color with Fai driving
1:25:20 canted angle shot with camera rotating and then showing Wing crying inside apartment
1:26:18 blurry shot of Fai standing alone near waterfall while narrating that he had hoped he would have been with someone else during this moment
1:28:46 cinematic painting with bright blue sky
1:31:08 series of jump cuts are used while Fai walks through outside market in Taipei
1:33:06 fast motion of city at night
Thoughts:
This was only my 2nd viewing with the first coming 4 or 5 years ago
The film has many of the WKW staples but there are several key differences as well. For starters, the film is set in Argentina instead of Hong Kong. And it is of course notable for being a film about a gay relationship
Like most WKW films, it is more interested in characters and mood than it is with plot. The film tracks the volatile relationship of two Hong Kong men living in Buenos Aires. It starts with a sex scene followed by numerous fights whether physical fights or verbal arguments, in some cases both. Much of the film includes the characters doing mundane tasks, working, taking public transportation, eating meals, working menial jobs etc.
There is both slow motion and fast motion used during the film. There is a great shot aerial shot of the City with fast motion of the traffic passing through and a neon lit billboard. This shot is repeated again later in the film
The film alternates between monotone and color and even between desaturated color with a more vibrant use of color. This is meant to show the volatile nature of their relationship and to capture the internal state of the characters. The use of handheld cameras also captures the chaotic nature of the relationship, including a few scenes where the verbal arguments turn into physical fights
Great performances from Leslie Cheung and Tony Leung. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a performance from Tony Leung that I would describe as anything other than magnificent, or at least any of his lead performances
Similar to his last couple of films, there is actually not all that much dialogue. It is not as extreme as the work of Terence Malick in that respect but there are definitely some similarities as WKW at times capturing the characters in physical spaces with other characters, but it feels like they are isolated at all times. Another way this is accomplished is with the use of shallow focus
Verdict: HR
Fallen Angels (1995)
Notes:
Cast:
Leon Lai as Wong Chi-ming, the hitman
Michelle Reis as the hitman’s “partner”
Takeshi Kaneshiro as Ho Chi-mo
Charlie Yeung as Charlie, a mysterious girl
Karen Mok as Situ Hui-Ling, known as “Blondie”
Starts with stylish two-shot of man and woman at different depths of field with desaturated colors before a cut to a low angle shot of the woman walking through empty building with neon lighting
2:09 green and yellow with neon lighting
3:24 low canted angle shots of man moving through dark streets
4:34 canted angles with wide angle lens
5:15 wide angle lens used with Michelle Reis character in close up in the foreground
7:31 amusing voice over from hitman who confesses that part of why he loves his profession is that he is lazy and does not want to have to make decisions and thus prefers to just follow orders
8:10 POV of car driver traveling through the city’s neon lit streets
9:23 step printing effect as hitman shoots up room full of presumed criminals
12 min a humorous exchange when the hitman takes bus and runs into someone he knew from
High School. It is revealed that the Hitman carries around a photography of a random woman and kid that he tells people is his wife and kid for the sake of appearing to be a regular functioning member of respectable society
13:00 Fincher style green/yellow lighting
15 min change to orange and red neon lighting in barroom
17:10 woman at bar shown in a series of extreme close ups on various parts of her body and head, this is accompanied by psychedelic music playing in the background
21:40 shortly after being released from prison, Takeshi Kaneshiro’s character travels on a motorcycle through the tunnel with green neon lighting
21:53 Takeshi Kaneshiro’s oddball character in meat shop with orange and red lighting throughout frame, he invades random businesses late at night when they are closed
28:54 nice use of background/foreground with close up in scene with Takeshi Kaneshiro’s character bring ice cream to his father
30:23 traffic moving in fast motion on right side of frame
32 min shootout sequence using handheld camera with mixture of slow motion and rapid cuts
35:27 shot inside bar with parts of frame having red/orange lighting while other parts of frame nearly pitch black frame as Hitman narrates about missing meeting with his female partner
37:48 shot of female partner at bar with part of frame desaturated, reflecting her internal emotions
39:27 Canted angle shot of Hitman and working girl runs across neon lit city street
46:00 canted angle of city streets with green neon lighting
52:26 bizarre relationship develops between Takeshi Kaneshiro character and a strange woman named Charlie
54:30 another wild fight breaks out with the usual WKW aesthetic with quick edits, slow motion
55:57 shot in monotone with psychedelic atmosphere as characters in background of frame move around in a blur while two characters sit emotionless in foreground
58:40 another shot of motorcycle riding through green lit tunnel
1:00:27 shot with character in background of frame in tunnel
1:11:54 rapid dolly in when woman in blonde and partner cross paths
1:13:07 change to monotone for several seconds, again it is reflection of partner’s internal state
1:15:45 expressionistic red lighting throughout sequence
1:18:04 return to the opening shot with the partner asking the hitman if they are still partners
1:18:54 hitman asks to end their partnership but agrees to do lone last job
1:19:35 driver POV shot moving through neon lit city street using jump cuts
1:20:20 great low angle shot of ominous dark sky in city street
1:24:58 Takeshi Kaneshiro’s character narrates about his father passing away
1:29:02 character from Chungking Express, flight attendant
1:32:26 monotone shot with close up of character in foreground with chaos in background of frame
Thoughts:
This storyline was supposed to be the third act in Chungking Express (1994) which was released the previous year in 1994. As I noted in the review of Chungking Express, I think this was for the best as it would not only deprive us of this excellent film, but it also would have sapped some of the energy from Chungking Express. This is darker than Chungking Express but still has some of the zaniness, especially in regard to the Takeshi Kaneshiro character who provides most of the comedy
It is also a continuation of the themes of Chungking Express such as urban isolation in modern day Hong Kong. Isolation and ennui are present in film where characters ponder the meaning of their existence. Characters are often shot in isolation, and not just isolated in a single frame but scenes where they are in a location with no one else around
Christopher Doyle’s impact is immense with the single most important visual choice revolving around the use of an ultra-wide angle lens. This is a significant visual element as it not only produces spectacular images but also matches the film’s themes. In a number of scenes one of the main characters are shown in a close up in the foreground of the frame with other characters in the deep background of the frame showing the isolated nature of characters even when they are in places surrounded by other people. The use of wide angle lens manipulates the viewer’s perception by exaggerating the distance between characters in the foreground and background
WKW uses canted angles and low angle shots to perfection, adding to the disorienting nature of the film which uses this along with rapid edits, alteration of camera angles, and a lack of establishing shots which produces the effect of placing the viewer in the world of the film. Additionally, there is the use of both slow motion and fast motion sequences, including a sequence where two characters remain stationary in foreground with chaotic movements in the background of the frame. The handheld shaky camera movements bring the viewer into the film’s world and are particularly effective in leading up to the murder sequences
Whereas Chungking Express contains both daytime and night sequences, Fallen Angels is entirely nocturnal. The night setting adds to the film’s themes of loneliness and alienation
The use of neon lighting and green-tinted fluorescent lights creates an appealing aesthetic, particularly the green lit tunnels in several of the motorcycle shots. The use of color is phenomenal throughout the film. There is also red lit barroom, or the city’s neon lit nightscape. Another benefit of the saturated neon lighting is the opportunity to create a strong contrast; there are several scenes which the partner is shown in a monotone or desaturated frame to reflect her internal state which is usually a state of depression caused by loneliness and an unrequited love interest
The film uses a combination of psychedelic music, pop music, and even ambient music which adds to the atmosphere. There is actually fairly little dialogue between the characters. The majority of the film consists of voiceover narration or music playing in background
Similar to Chungking and really WKW in general, the focus is primarily on characters and mood rather than any type of conventional plot. There are numerous wild shootouts that we witness without any context and just like the ones in Chungking it doesn’t really matter exactly who these criminals are or who they work. Instead, it is all about creating an atmosphere and even a sort of rhythm in the back and forth between the violent sequences and the non-violent ones
If you think Takeshi Kaneshiro’s character Cop 223 in Chungking express is a bit eccentric, his character in this film is that times 50. He sneaks into other people’s businesses at night when they are closed and pretends it’s his business. In one scene he basically holds the real business owner hostage unless he eats an ice cream cone that he prepares for him. In another scene he spontaneously makes a video of his father cooking a steak. There are a few humorous callbacks to his Chungking Express character like when his character in this film states that he became mute as a kid after eating a can of expired pineapples, hilarious
WKW and Christopher Doyle create one of the most visually striking films of the 1990s
Verdict: MP/MS
The Grandmaster (2013)
Loved this so much more on a rewatch. WKW was still going crazy in the 2010s even without Christopher Doyle.
Watched the “American” or “Weinstein” cut. It’s good in a way that it easily and obviously spells out the historical context and plot beats, but feels untrue to WKW’s style in that vein. Good for a first watch to help grasp the watch but on future revisits I’ll go back to the Chinese cut confident I can follow the whole film now.
One of 2013’s most beautiful films. Close-up’s of action impacts, colour usage, costumes, mise-en scene and set-pieces all brilliant. The use of photos is also creative with the fades to black and white.
Tony Leung brings his starpower to this, I really like the voice over too. Chang Chen gets little screentime, at least in the cut I caught which is a shame.
An excellent ending and I really like the films message of how regional battles dilute down and weaken art forms (a hip-hop film?).
A must-see film.
Chungking Express (1994)
Notes:
Cast:
Brigitte Lin as woman in blonde wig
Takeshi Kaneshiro as Cop 223
Faye Wong as Faye
Tony Leung as Cop 663
Opens with WKW trademark step printing (more on this below) which produces a distorted image resembling a combination of slow motion, shaky camera movements, and a blurry image with vibrant expressionistic use of color
Cop 223
1:33 voice over narration from Cop 223
3:40 Cop 223 at Midnight Express fast food restaurant, using the local payphone to call his ex-girlfriend who is named May
5:18 frame in frame with Cop 223 looking trapped
6:00 vibrant colors in bar with jukebox as woman with blonde wig drinks at the bar
8:25 handheld camera moving through
8:45 high angle shot similar to one from Days of Being Wild, and similar to that film there is a cutaway shot to a clock
10:04 series of quick tips creating underworld montage including frame in frame using curtains to frame illegal activity
13:10 McDonalds logo present in background as Cop 223 eats his McDonalds
17:05 frame in frame in front of store with bright white lighting
17:27 Cop 223 makes arrest, the scene uses step printing
18:04 close up on pineapple cans
19:10 shot of convivence store with frame in frame
19:48 woman in blonde wig shown in silhouette in empty storage facility
21:10 shootout shot using step printing
23:45 pan over empty pineapple containers with green tinted frame
22:35 Cop 223 eating pineapple cans in green lit apartment
23:45 pan over to stack of empty pineapple cans which are in foreground of the frame
25:47 canted angle with Cop 223 on phone while sitting on the ground
28:04 Cop 223 talks to woman in blonde wig at red lit bar
30:30 two-shot with Cop 223 trying to talk to woman in blonde wig
31:09 overhead shot of woman in blonde wig at bar with Cop 223
32:23 great two-shot with Cop 223 and woman in blonde wig at the bar leaning on each other, the shot bathed in red and green neon lighting
36:51 Cop 223 running around track during early morning hours on rainy day
38:44 freeze frame on Cop 223
40:10 step printing with the woman in the blonde wig shooting to death an obnoxious American man shown a few times
40:17 frame in frame in canted angle shot with the woman in the blonde wig in silhouette in the background of the frame and the dead American in the foreground
40:45 camera moves over pineapple can and zooms in
40:36 Cop 223 bumps into Faye Wong’s character who is referred to as “Faye” so easy enough to remember, right after California Dreamin’ is blasting from the boombox
Cop 663
41:48 Tony Leung as Cop 663
42:16 Faye Wong working at Midnight Express
47:28 What A Diff’rence A Day Made by Dinah Washington, this plays while Cop 663 moves a toy airplane during a scene with his girlfriend. She is a flight attendant played by Valerie Chow
49:49 intimate scene with Cop 663 moving the plane up her bare back in bed
53:06 Faye secretly reading the letter given by Valerie which turns out to be a breakup note intended for Cop 663 to read, it includes a key to his apartment
54:00 California Dreamin’ by The Mamas & The Papas
56:13 one of the best sequences of the film with characters in foreground moving at an accelerated motion/speed while the characters in the background of the frame, Cop 663 and Faye, move in slow motion; this scene is accompanied by the song “Dreams” by Faye Wong
59:41 reverse tracking shot through market during daytime
1:02:24 slow motion as Faye daydreams with airplane sounds
1:08:24 Faye inside Cop 663 apartment, since she took the key, showing off her zany side
1:10:36 another sequence where Faye goes into Cop 663 Apartment with music blasting in background
1:15:43 shaky camera tracking Cop 663 as he walks home
1:18:18 canted angle in shot including reflection
1:18:48 California Dreamin’ played again
1:20:10 shot through fishbowl with Cop 663 in background of the frame sleeping on his couch
1:20:54 bright orange/red lighting via candles for birthday celebration
1:23:30 Cop 663 talking to large stuffed animal in his apartment with fishbowl on right side of frame
1:24:32 low angle shot of airplane in the sky
1:25:15 Cop 663 returns home only to find Faye in his apartment
1:25:58 Faye shot in frame in frame
1:26:30 Cop 223 asks Faye out on a date
1:29:19 similar to shot earlier than different speeds for different depts of field
1:32:10 Cop 663 runs into ex-girlfriend at convenience store
1:33:38 dark blue nighttime shot followed by frame in frame as Cop 663 reads letter behind window during heavy rain with melancholy music playing
1:35:20 shot of Faye with pink/red tint
1:38:42 Faye is now working flight attendant
Thoughts:
I can vividly remember the first time I watched this film, it was about 5 years ago, shortly after I discovered the Criterion Channel. It was labeled as an essential film of the 1990s and looked intriguing so I decided to check it out
The opening two minutes are an exhilarating all-out assault on your senses; this is both exhilarating and highly intriguing, as it is clear that you are watching something different. In this opening, Wong Kar Wai uses a technique called step printing. Aside from the aesthetic value, the technique relates to WKW themes of time and memory as the technique alters our perception of time by speeding up and slowing down the action on the screen in an unusual way
The film is split into 2 acts with the 2nd act slightly longer than the 1st act. It was actually supposed to be a 3 act film, but WKW decided to save the 3rd storyline for another film which ended up being released the following year as Fallen Angel (1995). This was the right move in my opinion as WKW films work best around 90 to 100 minutes
The above mentioned step-printing is used in a few other scenes including some of the crime sequences involving the woman in the blonde wig. Like other WKW films, the focus is on characters and mood more than plot. We never learn if the woman in blonde is connected to higher level criminals or more detail on her criminal associates. She essentially is a character who represents the criminal underworld present in the film and that is all we really need to know
The film’s zany characters and playfulness give it the feel of a French New Wave film; I definitely see some similarities to some of Godard’s work in the 1960s. In particular I love Cop 223 as a hilariously hopeless romantic who is obsessed with eating cans of pineapples as a symbolic gesture to his recent breakup, he also uses the password “undying love” for his pager (very 1990s). Despite his silliness, there is something refreshing about a character in his 20s who is more interested in falling in love than just getting some action from a one night stand
Tony Leung as Cop 663 is more of an introvert and far less eccentric than Cop 223. Tony Leung is excellent as always. In fact, the performance are excellent all the way around and each of the main characters feel authentic as opposed to stock characters
WKW captures the loneliness the two main characters are feeling. He visually conveys this feeling of solitude in a number of ways including shots of the lead characters isolated in the frame in their apartments. And even when they are surrounded by people in crowded areas, they still seem alone due to shallow focus and of course the aforementioned step-printing. Additionally, the film uses shades of blue to express melancholy in a number of scenes. There are a number of canted angle shots. And of course, the voiceover, although this is more prevalent in the 1st act
Globalization is another theme as you have Cop 223 eating McDonalds with the golden arches in the background. You have Hong Kong natives listening to American music, most notably California Dreamin’ by The Mamas & The Papas. While the film is not explicitly and not even really implicitly political there are some levels of political undertones due to the impending 1997 Handover of Hong Kong from the UK to China
The film features a great soundtrack in which some of the songs are used multiply times throughout the film. These songs include the following
Things in Life by Dennis Brown
California Dreamin’ by The Mamas & The Papas
What A Diff’rence A Day Made by Dinah Washington
Dreams by Faye Wong
I actually ended up buying the Faye Wong album that has the track “Dreams” despite not knowing any Mandarin or Cantonese, what Paul McCartney calls “the power of music”
The use of color is excellent in capturing the internal moods of the characters with blue and to a lesser extent green, serving as a way to capture loneliness and isolation. Reds and oranges are used to capture a nostalgic mood. This juxtaposing of color creates a dynamic of the film moving back and forth between hope and despair
Amazingly Chungking Express was shot during a 2 month break from editing Ashes of Time and WKW wrote the 2nd story in a single day. The way WKW talks about shooting Chungking Express, you would think it was a student talking about a film school project instead of an all-time Masterpiece
This is an all-timer for me. It is truly original and feels just as fresh today as it did when I saw it for the first time 5 years ago. It is humorous with zany characters who have endearing qualities, in particular Cop 223 and Faye Wong’s character who is named Faye in the film. The performances are excellent all the way around with contrasting characters in Takeshi Kaneshiro as Cop 223 and Tony Leung as Cop 663. The film is specular visually with the step printing technique which as noted above is not only visually appealing but fits thematically into WKW’s focus on time and memory. Other visually highlights include the use of neon color in the lighting, unusual camera angles, use of frames in frames, and mix of night and daytime shots. The 2 act structure and pacing are ideal as well; this works better at 100 minutes than it would have at 120-140 minutes
Verdict: MP (top 30 all time)
Ashes of Time (1994)
Notes:
Cast:
Leslie Cheung as Ouyang Feng, the Western Venom
Tony Leung Ka-fai as Huang Yaoshi, the Eastern Heretic
Brigitte Lin as Murong Yang / Murong Yin / Dugu Qiubai
Tony Leung Chiu-Wai as Blind Swordsman
Carina Lau as Peach Blossom, Blind Swordsman’s wife
Maggie Cheung as Ouyang Feng’s sister-in-law
Opening credits are artfully done, orange background with black puddles expanding
a yellow/gold tint with slow motion waves and use of dissolves and cuts to close ups of faces
1:50 voice over narration
3:28 gorgeous cinematic painting with skyline taking up most of the frame as silhouette figure rides off on a horse in the desert
3:48 beautiful painterly image with camera sweeping over the landscape
4:32 very WKW concept “Without a past every day would be a new beginning, wouldn’t that be great?” Memory so important with WKW
5:40 profile shot of face with shallow focus
5:58 slightly canted angle in this shot
6:29 frame in frame of silhouette imaging walking up steps before fleeing on a horse
9:56 close up profile shot of head taking up half the frame
11:17 silhouette imagery with slightly canted angle
12:11 gorgeous shot of ripples in pond with inverted reflection of structure
16:48 wide angle shot of desert landscape followed by a cut to a medium close up
18:50 close up profile shot of head taking up half the frame
23:17 camera set close to characters who are shown near walls in dark and secluded locations
25:18 nice background/foreground work here with use of silhouette and profile shot
27:03 camera slowly revolving around lake with muted color palette
31:05 yellow sands with water and tree in background of frame in this shot of the desert
31:14 “It’s said she practiced her swordplay on her own reflection, because she could not no worthier opponent”
31:47 brilliant frame in frame with woman rising levitating water around her
32:08 another painterly image of landscape along water with flute based music playing
34:16 beautiful low canted angle shot on hill with of silhouette image of man next to a mule
35:33 painterly imagery and colors in shot of pond with waves moving outward
37:00 low canted angle shot of silhouette image
37:53 close up with face taking up entire frame
40:23 blue skyline in this shot atop a mountain range
44:44 slow motion with shallow focus as Huang walks along
45:33 frame in frame with beautiful use of pastel colors
46:32 start of battle sequence heavily using slow motion and quick cuts
49:58 Huang poetic even in death
55:37 slow motion shot of men on horses approaching from the background of the frame leading to a battle sequence
58:47 cinematic painting with low wide angle shot of desert including camels
1:01:47 desaturated colors used for the first time
1:02:00 another stunningly shot battle sequence with blurred images and rapid cuts
1:08:35 shots of desert with blue and white sky taking up most of frame, saturated use of gold/yellow for sand
1:11:15 shot of dark blue/purple sky with bolt of electricity
1:12:42 multiple frames in frames including circular frame
1:14:28 beautiful shot with mixture of green fog with blue in background of frame
1:23:35 another quote about the destructive force that memory can be
1:24:08 brief collage of beautiful images of the desert
1:24:36 soft focus wide angle shot of the desert
1:25:56 dark cloud and light sky split diagonally
1:26:44 inverted reflection of horse riding near bottom of the frame
1:28:12 dark blue skyline taking up most of frame with silhouette image riding a horse at night
1:29:14 intense fire burning with brilliant use of orange on screen
1:29:48 silhouette imagery of man on horse riding through the desert
The films ends with slow motion imagery similar to the opening
Thoughts:
I am a relative novice regarding the Wuxia Genre. I have only seen a small handful including Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, Last Hurrah for Chivalry, Red Cliff, The Assassin, and probably a few others but that is it. This film actually has little swordplay compared to the few other films I have seen of this genre which is fine as it allows WKW to imprint his own style and thematic interests making it auteur cinema
This was only my second viewing with the 1st being a few years ago Similar to other Wong Kar Wai films it does not really have a conventional plot even though on the surface it is a Genre Film. Admittingly this film is quite difficult to follow at times. Of course, WKW is known for loose narratives, so this mitigates the weakness of the screenplay to a certain extent
This is a gorgeous film with numerous visual highlights, vibrant use of color, silhouette, inverted reflections via ponds, and various cinematic paintings. Many of the shots contain the horizon near the bottom of the frame
Similar to Antonioni, the characters positioning in the frame speaks to their alienation, many scenes are shot in dark and secluded interiors with characters seeming trapped. There are a few shots where the frame in split with half of it being a wall or some other structure. There are also wide angle shots of open landscapes such as deserts. WKW juxtaposes images of trapped secluded locations with the open landscapes
The surreal elements of the film are established with a combination of dissolves, slow motion, silhouette imagery, and psychedelic score
It is not the film’s strength but some great lines “It’s said she practiced her swordplay on her own reflection, because she could not no worthier opponent”
Overall, a strong film that you really have to experience more than follow along if that makes any sense. His character’s emotions drive the story more than a conventional plot. The film runs about 90 minutes, which I think is perfect for the pacing.
Verdict: MS/HR
@James – have you never seen Hero (2002)?
@Harry -not yet, I bought it for $5 when it was on sale at Amazon Prime so I have been meaning to watch it but not gotten around to it yet
@James – I’m excited for you, I agree with Drake that it’s a top 100 film and as you will be blown away by Christopher Doyle by this study, the film will only deepen your admiration
@Harry – I look forward to it
Days of Being Wild (1990)
Notes:
Cast:
Leslie Cheung as Yuddy
Andy Lau as Tide
Maggie Cheung as Su Lizhen
Carina Lau as Leung Fung-ying
Rebecca Pan as Rebecca
Opens with an over the shoulder shot from Yuddy’s perspective with green tinted frame
1:42 cutaway shot to a clock
2:34 Yuddy’s confidence is almost comical “you’ll see me in your dreams tonight”
2:58 opening credits with tracking shot of jungle
3:40 frame in frame
3:50 repeat of Yuddy buying a coke and
4:55 Yuddy repeats walk to get a coke
5:49 cutaway to clock followed by “one minute friend” speak
7:03 great blocking of faces using close ups
9:24 shallow focus with Yuddy in silhouette
9:58 framing captures disconnect even when Yuddy is in same room
10:50 tracking shot with shaky camera as Yuddy walks to see his adopted mother
13:31 low angle canted angle shot
16:10 green tint throughout frame
18:13 close up two-shot
23:05 fade out with shot of clock on wall
26:37 Yuddy’s and his adopted mother have co-dependent relationship
28:26 close up profile shot
29:47 shallow focus with Yuddy in foreground
31:37 close up two-shot
34:57 nice splitting of frame with two characters sharing frame but separated and in different depths of field
42:24 low angle shot with clock in background of frame
43:58 frame in frame
44:22 Su behind bars in foreground
45:21 tracking shot of Su and Andy Lau’s character who is named Tide walking through empty street with green/yellow lighting
48:04 great high angle shot of Andy Lau’s Tide standing next to phone booth with score playing
49:13 green/yellow more saturated in this frame than anything before
58:01 blurry image with green lighting on face of Yuddy’s friend
52:34 Yuddy and his adopted mother Rebecca argue about their lives
1:01:21 Leung Fung-ying behind fence in foreground, similar to a shot of Su earlier in the film
1:03:54 nice use of frame in frames via curtains and doorways
1:04:57 shallow focus with close up profile shot
1:07:13 low angle shot during rainstorm at night
1:10:48 long high angle shot of Yuddy walking onto the large property of his biological mother who refuses to see him
1:11:11 shaky camera tracks Yuddy as he walks away from estate of biological mother, Yuddy’s walk eventually is shown in slow motion
1:14:04 Yuddy sleeping outside building on the ground
1:18:08 surveillance camera angle of Yuddy drinking in hotel room with Andy Lau character
1:19:20 incredible camera moves as camera practically floating through the open space into bar room which is dimly lit
1:21:54 a wild fight breaks out with fast cuts, shaky camera, and rapid change of angles
1:22:36 overhead shot on train
1:23:23 Yuddy carefree lifestyle compares himself to a bird with no legs
1:24:36 Yuddy shot on train
1:25:23 Yuddy contemplating his impending death
1:26:24 tracking shot of jungle, same as the one earlier in the film
1:28:42 flash of light on and off
1:29:32 fade out to a shot of train passing through Jungle
1:30:20 frame in frame of Su with bars in background
1:30:32 high angle shot of phone booth, similar to shot from earlier in the film
1:31:28 film ends with beautiful low angle shot inside shallow apartment which is probably 6 feet high at most, the score playing in background
Thoughts:
An existential Masterpiece capturing various elements of the human condition, especially the need for love and companionship. Like most of WKW work, the film is not driven by traditional plot. Instead, it tracks the lives of several young adults who are unhappy with their lives. An argument can be made for the main character Yuddy, played by Leslie Cheung, as exhibiting a degree of nihilism although I would argue more toward pessimism
Leslie Cheung as Yuddy gives a great performance. Yuddy is a complex role as he initially comes off as an immature playboy with a level of confidence that borders on comical. However, it is slowly revealed that he’s a deeply wounded character due to rejection from his biological mother and a co-dependent love/hate relationship with his adopted mother
After a Jarmusch Study I can’t help but admire the repetition in the first several minutes as three times the camera tracks Yuddy using over the shoulder shots of him walking up to the concession stand and buying a coke in a glass bottle while making moves on the girl at the concession
There are repeated shots of clocks. The first time I watched this film I assumed it was set when it came out which would be 1990 but it is actually set in the 1960s. Similar to future WKW films, there is a focus on longing, nostalgia, etc.
The blue and green color palette is used consistently throughout the film; this gives the film a distinct look. Green is often associated with nature and youthfulness and blue isolation and melancholy. The color palette is effective in maintaining the mood
The blocking is excellent in many of the film’s two-shots, there is a particular great one early in the film featuring Yuddy and Maggie Cheung’s character Su Lizhen; they are in bed together with extreme close ups on their faces. The film juxtaposes some of these intimate scenes with shots featuring Yuddy and his girlfriends in the same room but emotionally distant. The framing is crucial with some of the early sequences in the film that actually remind me somewhat of The Last Tango in Paris (1972) where the Brando character and the Maria Schneider character are in physically in the same room but emotionally disconnected. The Maggie Cheung character is framed behind bars in a couple scenes as her character is desperate to find meaning in her life as she realizes Yuddy is never going to be a long term relationship
Shallow focus is used several times to further emphasize the isolation of characters even when in close physical proximity to other characters. Many of the shots capture characters inside buildings, cramped rooms, and other enclosed spaces via frame in frames and with cameras placed close to the characters; these visuals match the narrative which features characters who seem trapped and limited for various reasons. When Yuddy travels to the Philippines there are shots in open areas that seem to suggest new possibilities for Yuddy, but he is sadly rejected by his biological mother who refuses to speak with him, this is followed by a return to characters in enclosed spaces
As Tears Go By and Days of Being Wild should have switched titles. They are basically perfect for each other. With the constant fighting and recklessness of the young characters in “As Tears Go By” which is WKW Mean Streets what better name could there be than Days of Being Wild? This would have been the perfect title. The melancholy vibe of Days of Being Wild, which features Yuddy breaking the hearts of multiple young ladies, would make “As Tears Go By” the perfect title
Verdict: MP
@James Trapp- Love that last paragraph- well-written
@Drake – Curious as to your most up to date Grades for WKW. I just started a Study on him
I know you have Chungking, In the Mood, and 2046 as MP
Wanted to know most up to date grades for:
As Tears Go By
Days of Being Wild
Ashes of Time
Fallen Angels
Happy Together
The Grandmaster
@James Trapp
Haven’t had a chance to vette the list:
1988- As Tears Go By R/HR
1990- Days of Being Wild MP
1994- Ashes of Time MS
1994- Chunking Express MP
1995- Fallen Angels HR/MS
1997- Happy Together MS
2000- In the Mood For Love MP
2004- 2046 MP
2013- The Grandmaster HR/MS
@James – you should see Blueberry Nights as well
@Drake – thanks, pretty much what I figured, I love seeing Days of Being Wild a MP
@Harry – Have you seen it? And if so, what grade would you give it?
@James – I’ve seen it once and gave it an R grade but would like to revisit. @Zane and @Pedro who used to post here more both gave it a HR grade
As Tears Go By (1988)
Notes:
Cast:
Andy Lau as Wah
Maggie Cheung as Ngor
Jacky Cheung as Fly (Wu Ying)
Starts with shot of City lit up at night with neon colored lights during opening credits, the reflection on the right side of the frame shows downtown section
2:15 overhead shot of Andy Lau as Wah answering his ringing phone, he is low level mob enforcer
3:36 Maggie Cheung as Ngor, she arrives at Wah’s as they are cousins
6:00 extreme low angle shot Wah
8:28 Jacky Cheung as Fly (Wu Ying)
9:42 low angle shot of Wah standing over the man he broke a bottle over showing his dominance
10:08 cut to neon lit sign outside club
16:16 Wah and Ngor eat a meal together
17:47 nice splitting of frame with characters in slightly different depths of field
18:30 slightly shaky camera as Fly enters dimly lit pool hall
20:01 snooker game for money
21:33 great chase scene with shaky camera and rapid movements capturing the chaos
24:32 beautiful use of slow motion blue tinted dissolve with solid red in background
25:37 slow motion depiction of chaotic fight include close ups and fragmented movements
29:26 red neon light with green lighting in background of shallow focus image
32:50 red neon lighting diffused throughout the frame
42:49 nice blocking with 4 characters in the frame smoking cigarettes
44:31 Fly selling fish balls on the side of the street
48:34 “take my breath away” playing as Wah makes his way to see Ngor
51:36 “I found that glass” quirky romance infused subplot
53:15 slow motion with fragmented movements
58:00 local gangsters mock Fly for selling fish balls
59:33 fly vandalizes the car of local gangster
1:09:24 neon red lighting throughout frame as street alley fight breaks out with Wah and Fly getting beaten by Tony’s crew
1:16:08 Shot similar to image during the opening credits as you have the lit up city at night shown via reflection
1:23:57 medium close upheld on Ngor who is saddened upon Wah leaving on the bus
1:27:02 Fly trying to bait Tony in gambling room
1:28:23 Fly holding gun on Tony with alternating of low angle and high angle shots
1:31:20 Fly and Wah meet up
1:35:18 slow motion, shaky camera, close up on Fly’s face as he fires away
The film ends the way you would expect it to end
Thoughts:
I actually did a Wong Kar Wai Study a few years ago, it was my 2nd study. However, my first few studies were just me watching the films of directors in chronological order and giving grades, so I wanted to do a proper Study with Notes and Thoughts Sections
While this certainly has some elements of the famous WKW style it also resembles many of the other Hong Kong action/crime films of the 1980s with the fighting scenes involving numerous characters and the setting of mid to low level criminals
This film is compared to Scorsese’s Mean Streets (1973), although certainly not of the same quality I can see the narrative connections. Fly is the equivalent to De Niro’s Johnny Boy although he is probably only 10 percent obnoxious and Fly is even sympathetic to a certain degree. And similar to Mean Streets the characters here are relatively low level gangsters who are motivated less by money and more by proving their toughness by not backing down from any challenges to their egos
I love the entire “take my breath away” scene, the “I found that glass” (cue to the music) is so WKW, quirky romance
There are some beautiful shots starting with the one during the opening credits where the neon lit city at night is visible via reflection. There is a beautiful shot between 32 and 33 min mark with neon red diffused throughout the frame
The step-printing chase sequences are present in the film, he would get better at this in his future films
WKW uses fragmented slow motion that he is famous for several times, he would get even better at this but already is able to effectively do this. He uses shaky camera in some of the chase sequences
Verdict: HR
Does anyone know how to watch Blossoms Shanghai (2023)?
@James – I heard there’s recently a version floating around with AI generated Eng subs. Probably best to wait for this one more.
My ranking of Wong`s films that I`ve seen:
1. In the Mood for Love MP
2. Chungking Express MP
3. 2046 MP
4. Days of Being Wild MP
5. Happy Together MS
6. The Grandmaster MS
7. Ashes of Time MS
8. Fallen Angels HR/MS
10 Best Performances
1. M. Cheung- In the Mood for Love 5
2. Leung- In the Mood for Love 5
3. Wong- Chungking Express 5
4. Leung- 2046 5
5. Leung- Happy Together 5
6. Leung- Chungking Express 5
7. Ziyi- 2046 5
8. Ziyi- The Grandmaster 4.5
9. Leung- The Grandmaster 4.5
10. M. Cheung- Days of Being Wild 4
If one only has access to the 108min (Weinstein mangled) version of Grandmaster, is it worth watching or rather skip and wait for 130min original version when available?
Has anyone seen his new tv-series Blossoms Shanghai yet?
@Oliver – not yet, this is going to be a 25 hour series I believe so not sure I want to commit even though WKW is one of my favourite directors, time is a issue.
I discovered that WKW has a 2004 film called “The Hand”. It is part of a 2004 anthology film “Eros” which consists of 3 short films; one directed by Wong Kar Wai, one directed by Steven Soderbergh, and the third by Michelangelo Antonioni.
I have not watched yet but noticed on Criterion, curious as to if anyone has watched? Its 56 minutes so kind of a strange duration as not really a feature film but not sure I would call it a “Short” either
@James – saw it earlier this year. It’s a minor effort and closer in quality to Blueberry Nights than 2046. It’s on the WKW criterion boxset too
It’s not too bad, and from what I’ve heard it’s the only really worthwhile part of the anthology film. It’s very much a Wong movie and has enough of what makes him a great filmmaker that I still liked it, but it doesn’t have the attention to detail and superior visual beauty that elevate all of his best work.
@Drake do you think HR/MS (from your top 1000) is the ceiling for Fallen Angels and The Grandmaster? Or could you see a ceiling of MS? I finished my Wong Kar-wai study recently and I find myself changing those two back and forth from HR/MS to MS, ha.
Have you heard of/seen the alternate cut of Days Of Being Wild? I believe it is included on the criterion DVD.
David Bordwell analyzed it here:
http://www.davidbordwell.net/blog/2008/06/24/years-of-being-obscure/
@MovierJoker- Love this thanks for sending – any excuse to read Bordwell and/or learn more about WKW. I have heard of the alternative cut- but haven’t seen it.
Days of Being Wild MS
Ashes of Time HR
Chungking Express MP
Fallen Angels HR
Happy Together MS
In the Mood For Love MP
2046 MS
The Grandmaster R
Top 10 performances in Wong Kar Wai films
1. Maggie Cheung – in the mood for love
2. Tony Leung – in the mood for love
3. Faye Wong – Chungking express
4. Zhang Ziyi – 2046
5. Tony Leung- Chungking express
6. Maggie Cheung- days of being wild
7. Tony Leung- 2046
8. Tony Leung- happy together
9. Zhang ziyi – the grandmaster
10. Maggie Cheung- as tears go by
@M*A*S*H – solid list but where is Leslie Cheung as Yuddy in Days of Being Wild? It’s a complex role, initially he just comes off as an immature playboy, but he’s a deeply wounded character due to rejection from his biological mother and a love/hate relationship with his adopted mother.
I really love Takeshi Kaneshiro in Chungking, obviously he isn’t the caliber of actor that Tony Leung is (few are) but I really love the performance; he takes that wacky character to even further extremes in Fallen Angel but I think his performance in Chungking is clearly supeior.
[…] 22. Kar-Wai Wong […]