Polanski. I’m higher than some on Polanski because of my esteem for both of his occult films: Rosemary’s Baby and Repulsion. I think both are masterpieces, which, when paired with Chinatown, made Polanski one of the world’s best filmmakers at only age 41. However, he has not really capitalized on that amazing start to his career (4 of his best 5 films are before 1975). I read somewhere (forget now) that people had thought he would be David Cronenberg from 1977-onward and I can totally see that; making eerie, masterful films. If you combine his early work with Cronenberg’s career you have a legit rival for Scorsese as best living filmmaker.
Best film: Chinatown Chinatown. I’m tempted to say Rosemary’s Baby because I think that might be polanski’s greatest achievement as a director. Chinatown is one of the best 5 screenplays of all-time and it IS superbly directed by Polanski so I’ll keep it here. One of the greatest pure narrative films in the art-form’s history. A meditation on power, corruption—an intelligent labyrinth that updates (and improves upon) the best detective films of the studio system Hollywood era (superior to the detective films– Maltese Falcon)- it subverts and examines and redefines the genre though not on the level of Altman’s Long Goodbye from the previous year. The opening titles are gorgeous but feel a bit pastiche—but then you go right into the semi-graphic (clearly not 1930’s/40’s) still frame photos of the cheating wife with Burt Young. John Huston is not only perfect as Noah Cross- but a clear nod to Chandler, Hammett– as he’s the director of the Maltese Falcon of course. Strong retro-luminous Jerry Goldsmith score. The smirk from Jack is so good- overall he underplays the role- mostly, like F. Scott Fitzgerald says he’s a man defined by his actions, but there are moments for Jack that are undeniably Jack—we have him calling the hall of records kid a “weasel” under his breathe. Polanski and Towne (screenplay) so are patient—when looking through a desk Jack checks (and they shot) every drawer and what’s inside. It leads to nothing. Towne and Polanski are building a house here. The water- brilliant- so important for LA- mythic—a great “LA is a small town” line—perfect as maybe no actor more associated with LA either at this point than Jack- Mr. Laker court-side. The character is impeccably built from a formal standpoint—he never listens—someone tells him to wait and he goes ahead- again and again—. “Chinatown” is not only the perfect title- but a key character in the film- a largely unspoken fabled past, theme and undercurrent. The period detail and craft involved- such a high level- it’s all Polanski—he largely defers his stamp here to the screenplay and Jack and what they’re doing with the genre- but the paranoid is all him. There’s an unnatural panic and anxiety in the air that’s in Rosemary’s Baby, The Ghost Writer and all his best work—it’s a rigged game. The nose- it not only creates a memorable hallmark— but it works for the narrative- a reminder of the seriousness as we’re chasing abstracts. The scene where Nicholson and Dunaway make love is superb—we have the Goldsmith horns form the score and then, another throwback, they cut to his cigarette after—then the overhead shot of them in bed together is spectacular. Freud and narrative strength here- Dunaway is naked and then when Jack mentions he met her father she immediately covers up. The narrative- which is perfect- comes back to Burt Young at the end with bookends—similar to the funeral owner in The Godfather– favor is returned. Jack’s “your wife crossed her legs a little too quick” line. Narrative economy- the butler “bad for glass”- line would come back as well with the tide-pool. The daughter/sister scene with Dunaway is absolutely awe-inspiring. Polanski is clearly in love with the period and architecture- it shows. Love Noah Cross’ (Huston)’s line about how he wants to own the future. The epic finale is justifiably iconic as well… it’s not only the “forget it, Jake. It’s Chinatown” line but the JFK-like head-wound in Dunaway with the haunting horn from the score and then we drift into the sky above Chinatown almost like we’re Dunaway watching. A masterpiece.

total archiveable films: 12
top 100 films: 1

top 500 films: 3 (Chinatown, Rosemary’s Baby, Repulsion)

top 100 films of the decade: 4 (Chinatown, Rosemary’s Baby, Repulsion, The Ghost Writer)

most overrated: Cul-de-Sac. TSPDT has it all-time and as Polanski’s 6th. I have it as his 9th.
most underrated: Repulsion at #455 all-time on TSPDT is just flat wrong. This film is a masterpiece of horror/thriller. It’s Freudian and filled with paranoia and a wonderful performance by Deneuve. A fantastic #3 film that sets him apart from a few others on this list. I have the film at the #169 of all-time. If you need another that’s underrated it’s The Ghost Writer. The film is so much better, and closer to Chinatown than critics gave it credit for in 2010. Including the Chinatown comparisons are little things like the hired help at the house on the ocean sweeping the never-ending grass off the deck (being blown on by wind) just like the saltwater pool in the backyard of Dunaway’s house in Chinatown. There are also comparisons to both Chinatown and Rosemary’s Baby (and other Polanski’s films but those two are the pillars) with the sheer paranoia and anxiety he’s able to create. Powerful stuff. McGregor googling CIA contacts scene reminds me of Mia Farrow reading the book on witchcraft. I’ve seen the film 3 times and every time I feel like it’s a HR- Highly Recommend or essentially a top 10 film of 2010, and then they film ends with two of the better scenes in the last decade including the shot of the note being handed from McGregor to Olivia Williams. The second shot is of course that final shot- the equivalent of the “forget it, Jake, It’s Chinatown” shot of the hit and run and pages of the unpublished book sweeping away. Fantastic finish.



gem I want to spotlight: Knife in the Water. He’s done a number of films that feel small and stagy with a background in theatre (enclosed/limited sets, small ensemble). Cul-de-sac is like this– as is Death and the Maiden, Repulsion, Carnage and others. Knife in the Water is along these lines but manages to separate itself with some of the framing and uncanny sense of paranoia Polanski is able to achieve. It’s a brilliant debut, and necessary starting point for a Polanski study.


stylistic innovations/traits: Unnerving cinema. Polanski’s films have a feeling of claustrophobia, paranoia and psychology that makes him a welcomed predecessor of Hitchcock and precursor to Cronenberg in many ways. His shot choices dictate this- the angles used in the phone booth in Rosemary’s Baby- I mean this is just a woman in a phone booth and Polanski makes it art. The angles in Repulsion (again a pretty girl in a room for 90 minutes). The choices to elevate the camera at the ends of Chinatown and The Ghost Writer—dread—systematic horror.



top 10
- Chinatown
- Rosemary’s Baby
- Repulsion
- The Ghost Writer
- Knife in the Water
- The Tenant
- The Pianist
- Macbeth
- Cul-de-Sac
- Tess

By year and grades
| 1962- Knife in the Water | HR/MS |
| 1965- Repulsion | MP |
| 1966- Cul-de-Sac | R |
| 1968-Rosemary’s Baby | MP |
| 1971- Macbeth | |
| 1974- Chinatown | MP |
| 1976- The Tenant | |
| 1979- Tess | R |
| 1988- Frantic | |
| 1994- Death and the Maiden | R |
| 2002- The Pianist | R |
| 2010- The Ghost Writer | MS |
*MP is Masterpiece- top 1-3 quality of the year film
MS is Must-see- top 5-6 quality of the year film
HR is Highly Recommend- top 10 quality of the year film
R is Recommend- outside the top 10 of the year quality film but still in the archives
@ Drake- How many archive able films for him now? Do you have a grade for Macbeth?
@AP – 13 for Polanski- and no grade for Macbeth
@Drake- Doesn’t Macbeth have a Criterion release?
@Malith – it does- https://www.criterion.com/films/28020-macbeth?srsltid=AfmBOop7rGe7pwlKA4UTWf30sy5yuBcKiUW2GCv_rbmgBCFmL8AH0lbn
I think What? (1972) is one of his best looking films. It is very European avant-gardy in its look. Different for him. There is primary color usage all over the place here and large pictures/murals. And the same absurd scenarios repeat again and again. Funny. Especially with Mastroianni and Romolo Valli.
https://imgur.com/gallery/what-b7yL2os
His trio of films Tess, Oliver Twist, The Pianist make a great trilogy of tragic protagonists. Oliver Twist is the opposite of Tess but all three goes from place to place, town to town trying to survive.
@M*A*S*H – I think Kinski underacts much of the film but it works because she is playing a very passive character who has little control throughout much of the film. I cannot call it a great performance but I do think it is an effective performance. I have not seen any other films she was in except One from the Heart (1981) and I only saw it once
@James Trapp-Paris, Texas is a pretty essential film. And I think you are wrong in your assessment of the Tess character. She is a strong independent woman, not a cipher or an observer. I just bought the Tess of the D’Ubervilles book actually. It’s crazy this is the only notable adaptation of the book and only film I think.
@James Trapp and @Drake- by watching the few clips it feels like she’s passive but it gel well with the demeanor of the character but I feel there’s little to no subtext as well in her work (just judging by few clips here and there). Does it work well with another actress at the helm. Any suggestions about who in 1979?
@M*A*S*H- How about Isabelle Adjani?
@Drake- perfect casting choice!
Sissy Spacek has earthy screen presence. Julie Christie if it was in 60s. Hanna Schygulla maybe but older choice in 1979.
Adjani seems perfect in 79. I wouldn’t give second thought watching it if it was her. She would be arbiter of so much for the 3-hour runtime.
@M*A*S*H-Seems pretty inauthentic casting choices to me. Tess is a British character And the only slight problem I had with Kinski’s performance is her distinct accent is noticeable among the other actors who are all British. I’m not thinking about another non British actor for this role. Someone like Francesca Annis could be very good in this role.
@Malith- these are fun what-if scenarios right? I haven’t seen this film yet (it’s been difficult to find) so I can’t really say anything. I haven’t even read the book so I was just making comments based on what little description of the character I had. I’m not familiar with Anis’ work also but wouldn’t she be too old in 1979.
@M*A*S*H-I think Kinski is fantastic in Tess. But her English isn’t the strongest and noticeable among the British cast. Annis is the female lead in Macbeth (1971) and Lynch’s Dune (1984). Great actress but let down by poor choices over the years and that sleepwalking controversy I think.
@Malith- sadly I haven’t seen both films of Anis that you mentioned. I see she’s a thespian.
I wish I find Tess soon enough. I wanna watch it so bad.
Also if she’s fantastic then I don’t think accent will bother me at all, I don’t care about an actor’s accent adaptability at all. I find it the single most overrated thing in the entire filmmaking- an actor doing pitch perfect accent.
@Malith – I still need to get around to Paris, Texas. Tess is a strong independent woman? She has little control over her destiny for most of the film. Of course this is due mainly to the circumstances she finds herself in. Her mannerisms are definitely passive as well, she speaks in such a soft voice and has a childlike nature. She stands up for herself to a degree in some scenes but eventually gives in to other people. So maybe not completely passive, but sort of reluctantly concedes to the demands of others. She is a tragic character.
@James Trapp-After the first sending to the Lord’s house, Tess pretty much controls the narrative of her life. She dumps the lord, goes to work in a milk farm, goes to work in a wheat farm, goes to her friend’s home, tries to help her family etc., and even kills the lord at the end to go with the love of her life. She is passive in nature but has a strong determination. I actually think if you are talking about Polanski protagonists, Adrien Brody in The Pianist is the passive character who has little control over the tragic events that happen to him.
@Drake- I’m planning on watching Tess since now you it as MP-level film. I have 2 questions though:
1. Is it a signature Polanski film (as say The Age of Innocence for Scorsese)?
I’m sort of daunted by 3-hour long costume dramas and all the films of Polanski’s that I’ve seen (4 maybe- Apartment trilogy and Chinatown) are thrillers/horror and he creates tension, Paranoia in them. Is this made in a similar way?
2. I’ve heard a lot about Nastassja Kinski in this film. She’s playing titular lead in a MP- level film and was nominated for a golden globe. I’ve never been blown away by her acting so is she really giving a great acting performance here?
@M*A*S*H- Others can chime in here- but this is more about Polanski proving his talent as a craftsman and photographer – similar to Barry Lyndon or Days of Heaven
@Drake- what did you think of Nastassja Kinski’s work?
@M*A*S*H- Took quite a few notes- but not much on Kinski. Polanski captures her beauty- her stunning features. She’s not bad in the film – but she probably doesn’t give one of the best performances of 1979- and in a film and role like this – she probably should.
Oliver Twist is similar to Tess. Both in the setting and the hardships endured by the lead character. It’s also an extremely well photographed film.
Is Polanski the director with the oldest archivable film (1962-Knife in the Water) still living?
@Anderson- I believe so- someone can correct us- but the others that come to mind immediately are Woody and Eastwood and Polanski’s date further back
@Drake-Scorsese started quite early with Who’s That Knocking at My Door in 1967 I think. But it took him more than another half decade to hit his stride and get another successful project going. Roger Corman would have been the right answer earlier this year I think. Granted he hadn’t made a film in decades. Ivory is still living but was a late bloomer.
@Anderson- good call here with Scorsese. Did a quick google- Alejandro Jodorowsky is up there
Interview conducted in 2019 with Polanski about the making of The Tenant and other things like connection with Bruce Lee as well.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=de2fO17nIk4
My ranking of Polanski`s films that I`ve seen:
1. Chinatown MP
2. Rosemary’s Baby MP
3. Repulsion MP
4. The Tenant MP
5. Tess MS/MP
6. Knife in the Water MS
7. The Ghost Writer MS
8. An Officer and a Spy HR/MS
9. The Pianist HR
10. Death and the Maiden R
10 Best Performances
1. Farrow- Rosemary’s Baby 5
2. Nicholson- Chinatown 5
3. Deneuve- Repulsion 5
4. Gordon- Rosemary’s Baby 5
5. Brody- The Pianist 5
6. Dunaway- Chinatown 5
7. Kingsley- Death and the Maiden 5
8. Kinski- Tess 5
9. McGregor- The Ghost Writer 5
10. Huston- Chinatown 5
@RujK. – nice seeing Kinglsey in the top 10 performances, his monologue was excellent in Death and The Maiden
Hello, anyone have a link to Polanski’s last 3 films with English subtitles?
@Stone-Sorry for the late response. I have An Officer and a Spy with English subtitles here.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/192tn4Iiq1ir4Ba5-Zllr1ZgYtPd3ihKe/view?usp=drive_link
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZD2H6yRMsM9m_PPSerdS-fEv5T9Dv_Vq/view?usp=drive_link
It’s strange. But in half of the films he made between 1962-2010 he has a main British cast. Repulsion, Cul-de-sac, The Fearless Vampire Killers, Macbeth, Tess, Pirates, The Pianist, Oliver Twist and The Ghost Writer.
@Malith Is Marlon Brando in Last Tango in Paris an acceptable answer to the question which is the
greatest screen acting performance of all time?
Done.
1.Rosemary’s Baby
2.The Tenant
3.Repulsion
4.Chinatown
5.An Officer and a Spy
6.Tess
7.The Ghost Writer
8.Knife in the Water
9.Macbeth
10.Oliver Twist
11.Based on a True Story
12.Frantic
13.Cul-de-sac
14.Death and the Maiden
15.The Pianist
16.Bitter Moon
17.Venus in Fur
18.The Ninth Gate
19.The Fearless Vampire Killers
20.The Palace
21.What?
22.Carnage
23.Pirates
After one viewing each
1.Rosemary’s Baby(1968)-MP
2.The Tenant(1976)-MP
3.Repulsion(1965)-MP
4.Chinatown(1974)-MP
5.An Officer and a Spy(2019)-MP
6.Tess(1979)-MP
7.The Ghost Writer(2010)-MS
8.Knife in the Water(1962)-MS
9.Macbeth(1971)-HR/MS
10.Based on a True Story(2017)-HR
11.Frantic(1988)-HR
12.Cul de Sac(1966)-HR
13.Death and the Maiden(1994)-HR
14.The Pianist(2002)-HR
15.Bitter Moon(1992)-HR
16.Venus in Fur(2013)-R/HR
17.The Ninth Gate(1999)-R/HR
18.Oliver Twist(2005)-R
19.The Palace(2023)-R
20.The Fearless Vampire Killers(1967)-R
21.Carnage(2011)-R
My ranking:
1.Rosemary’s Baby(1968)-MP
2.The Tenant(1976)-MP
3.Repulsion(1965)-MP
4.Chinatown(1974)-MP
5.An Officer and a Spy(2019)-MP
6.Tess(1979)-MP
7.The Ghost Writer(2010)-MS
8.Knife in the Water(1962)-MS
9.Macbeth(1971)-HR/MS
10.Based on a True Story(2017)-HR
11.Frantic(1988)-HR
12.Cul-de-sac(1966)-HR
13.Death and the Maiden(1994)-HR
14.The Pianist(2002)-HR
15.Bitter Moon(1992)-HR
16.The Ninth Gate(1999)-R/HR
17.The Palace(2023)-R
18.The Fearless Vampire Killers(1967)-R
I am yet to see What?, Pirates, Oliver Twist, Carnage and Venus in Fur
17.Venus in Fur(2013)-R
18.The Palace(2023)-R
19.The Fearless Vampire Killers(1967)-R
Do you know Knife in the Water, Cul-de-sac and Death and the Maiden form an unofficial triology where a couple’s life is turned upside down by an outsider?
@Drake-Have you added any films of his into the archives after this page was published? Or is it still 12? Have you seen any of his recent films? They are hard to find.
@Lionel- Appreciate your interest – big updates will be coming to all of the director pages at some point. I’m going to put the updates on the director’s pages – and not in the comments for the most part.
@Lionel – I think @Malith and I have hounded @Drake on this subject lol regarding Polanski that is. All I will say is Officer and a Spy (2019) is a borderline MP, really impressive film
Chinatown (1974) Directed by Roman Polanski
Making the Case for Chinatown as a top 10 film of all time
Chinatown has been one of my favorite films for a long time. As I have learned more about evaluating film as an art my opinions of the quality of certain films have changed regardless of my personal affection for them. Chinatown is undoubtedly one of the most beloved and respected films of all time though it seems like I rank it above the consensus. When I made my first top 100 film list I ranked Chinatown at # 9 while TSPDT has it at # 71 and Cinema Archives # 144. I am working on an updated top 100 and have already made some significant changes to a number of films. After watching some of Polanski’s more recent films in the last month or so I decided to take another look at Chinatown, a film I have seen many times, but I really took my time with this recent viewing, taking detailed notes. So, I thought to write this out as an exercise in film criticism.
In this article I will not focus too much on the screenplay and acting since both are already so highly lauded. The screenplay is practically the golden standard for screenplays to the extent that it is commonly taught in film schools. The performances are unanimously praised, in particular Jack Nicholson and Faye Dunaway, but also the supporting roles. Given this there is really no need to preach to the choir. Instead, I want to focus on everything else, but mostly the visuals and direction
I have read comparisons of Chinatown to Casablanca, another film with an impeccable screenplay and numerous all-time great acting performances. In fact, the performances in Casablanca are probably even more iconic and possibly superior to those of Chinatown as both Bogart and Bergman give what could reasonably be top 10 male and top 10 female performances of all time. The screenplays are basically equally great though I am partial to Chinatown. Where the films differ is in the direction. Casablanca is certainly well directed but I just do not think Michael Curtiz is anywhere close to Roman Polanski’s level.
Thoughts
This is a perfect film that does everything great, and I mean everything. I will concede that there may not be any one aspect of the film that is particularly innovative
The above notes focus largely on the visuals and direction, but it would be an injustice to not mention the Jerry Goldsmith Score, which is composed of a trumpet, four pianos, four harps, two percussionists, and a string section. The trumpet during the opening and closing credits is particularly memorable and establishes a mournful and nostalgic mood of the film
Mise-en-scène
Dedication of color in mise en scene; cream, brown, tan is carried throughout the film, I never noticed just how thoroughly it carried out start to finish. In particular the interior shots of Jake’s office, the offices of LA’s Water and Power, and even the large house/mansion of Mulwray. Here is a stunner at 57:01 (Link # 1)
It’s not as pronounced as The Godfather but there is a noticeable contrast between the sunny bright outside and the dimly lit interiors throughout the film. The Godfather uses this right from the opening scene and there is a similar dynamic in Chinatown which also uses the idea of corruption and underhanded business dealings occurring behind closed doors in a dark environments (Link # 2)
Jake is literally in the dark in several scenes such as when he is trying to figure out who Katherine is to Evelyn (Link # 3)
Framing and Camera Angles
One of the film’s best marriages of style and narrative is evident in the way the shots are framed. Jake is always a step behind despite being intelligent as the rampant corruption is more complex than he realized. Jake, especially in the first half, rarely sees anything directly though his eyes without additional filters. The film frames many of its shots through mediums including binoculars, cameras, glass windows, car windshields, reflections off mirrors, etc. JJ see’s Evelyn’s daughter/sister Katherine in a shot that uses not only windows but curtains to create a frame in frame and of course JJ misinterprets what he is seeing
(Link # 4)
The overhead shot of JJ and Evelyn in bed after a romantic sequence has a tenderness that is rare for a noir film. It is one of the most memorable shots in my opinion, but the score is a major reason for this as well
(Link # 5)
Polanski uses the 2:35 to 1 aspect ratio but the positioning of the subjects in the frame are often not centered
(Links # 6-8)
Polanski uses profile shots frequently, especially in the first half of the film. Given that we the audience only know what Jake knows, there is a sense of mystery with all the characters that come into his world over the course of the film. Here are two of the best: (Links # 9-10)
The are numerous shots in the first half where Jake is isolated in the frame, and several of these are desolate landscapes which are fitting for Jake’s “me against the world” attitude for much of the film especially before he meets Evelyn (Link # 11)
Editing
There are some establishing shots of course but Polanski shoots several scenes including the opening of the film in a way where we the audience are unsure of what we are seeing until a zoom out or pan gives the shot additional context
There is a sequence where JJ Gites is knocked out from a punch and the screen goes black since Jake is a sort of audience stand-in so when he loses consciousness, the audience does as well so to speak
I actually wonder if Chinatown’s screenplay and acting cause people to overlook its visual achievements.
I think Chinatown is a film of breathtaking beauty (Link #12-14)
I still think Chinatown is the best work of Polanski
Verdict: MP
Sorry the links are suppose to be references to screen shots from screen grab. The point of the post was to focus specifically on Chinatown (1974) from a visual standpoint. Unfortunatley all those links can’t be posted at once. I will try to piecemeal it if possible
@James-Interesting. I am confident Chinatown is not the most visually beautiful film of Polanski. The top 3 I think is An Officer and a Spy, Tess and Macbeth. I need to watch Chinatown again but I think there is a formal accomplishment in films like The Tenant and Repulsion especially which wasn’t there in Chinatown. In Repulsion there is a relentless clock ticking noise in the background and repeated surrealism rape sequences. Also repeated cracking shots in different environments. In The Tenant it’s like a circle with repeated shots going to the cafe to buy cigarettes, going to the hospital to see the patient and then the same thing happening to him in the end, the floating shot through the courtyard which is empty at first but then repeated near the end and it is no longer empty etc. Rosemary’s Baby has a stunning rape sequence which maybe the single best scene in Polanski’s career.
@Malith – I have seen Chinatown many many times but this was the first time I watched purely for the visuals. Tess is probably Polanski’s most beautiful film but I would probably put Chinatown # 2 although An Officer and a Spy is a worthy contender.
With all that said I am not immune to accepting the idea that any or all of the “Apartment Trilogy” for the best directed since Chinatown (1974) is more of an a collaborative project than the trilogy although it is still clearly Polanski’s film. Even Robert Towne said that Polanski “won” their most significant argument which was the ending. They went with Polanski’s ending and everyone including Towne admit it was the right move.
@James – I got my fourth viewing of Chinatown in on the 11th of this month. I think this film and The Ghost Writer really get overlooked for their beauty and dedication to colour palette. One of my favourite shots is when Gittes first follows Mulray to the beach and there’s that epic wide shot on the sunset on the water.
@Harry – Ghost Writer (2010) and Chinatown (1974) make for a great double billing as Ghost Writer is probably the most similar film to Chinatown in Polanski’s filmography. I’ve watched both in the last month with Chinatown just a couple days ago.
Chinatown is obviously the stronger film in basically everyway but both feature amazing direction. The visual consistency with Chinatown is especially great and yes the shot you are talking about is museum art
Check out this series of screen shots
http://www.glamamor.com/2012/02/cinema-style-file-style-is-star-in.html
@James – people also always deservedly praise “forget it Jake, it’s Chinatown” but one of the preceding lines (about 30 seconds earlier into the final scene) “as little as possible” also is a genius part of the screenplay.
Earlier in the film I think Gittes responds this to someone who asks what he did in the police. His own words coming back to him in the finale when the police just let everyone go….
@James-I think the most similar film to Chinatown in Polanski’s filmography is Frantic or The Ninth Gate. The ending in The Ghost Writer is very similar to Chinatown however. I think it was a missed opportunity not casting Jack in Frantic. I feel like he would be so much better than what Harrison Ford is here.
@James – this is a great video focusing on the direction of Chinatown: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=951qhnArmuo
@Harry – This is a great find. Especially the breakdown of the compositions and using the 2.35 to 1 so effectively. The other points made in the video is some of what I discussed above but the analysis of the compositions was great. The performances and screenplay are so great that they overshadow the other elements to a degree
@Drake – I posted something but not showing up
Notes:
Starts with magnificent trumpet score, mournful during opening credits with blown/tan/gold colors
2:15 slow zoom out from photo to showing a man (Burt Young) looking at photos of his cheating wife in the office of JJ Gites (Jack Nicholson), the zoom out is consistent with a theme maintained throughout the film regarding information asymmetry. Cream color and brown dominate mise en scene
4:04 dead pan response “no, really” is great
5:48 split diopter shot at water and power meeting, meticulous composition, and blocking
8:08 high angle long shot of car driving car into vast desert area
8:24 clockwise pan following his POV until he get him in a profile shot with face taking up half the frame
8:34 frame through binoculars
9:46 POV shot from inside Jake’s car
10:05 POV shot using side mirror to capture Mulwray
11:15 museum quality beauty with Jake smoking cigarette during sunset, purple, yellow, orange
12:45 Jake visible in reflection off of the rims on his tires
14:05 black and white photos used in place of dialogue
16:08 reflection of Mulray and teenage girl through lens
17:07 great blocking in shot at barbershop with 5 depths of field present in this frame
19:24 nice blocking with 3 characters positioned diagonally across the frame, Evelyn Mulwray (Faye Dunaway) makes her entrance into the film
20:20 mise en scene with, photos of relevant characters
21:08 immaculate décor inside office, maintaining established color palette
22:48 the dimly lit interior of the water and power office is contrasted with the bright day scenes
24:01 triangle composition
26:20 décor inside Mulwray’s mansion is similar to Jake’s office and Water and Power offices
31:07 close up shot of Jake in profile
33:19 crescendo upon deceased Hollis Mulwray pulled from the water, his face upside down in frame
33:41 cream and brown mise en scene
34:04 frame split in half by door hinge
37:08 beige and cream color palette
39 min kid of horse returns, over the shoulder shot from Jake POV
41:12 Jake is literally walking into the dark here right before the water from the reservoir suddenly explodes into the frame sweeping Jake
42:40 Roman Polanski is not a particularly intimidating guy but for some reason I love this scene “you know what happens to nosy fellas…they lose their noses”
46 min beautiful shot inside restaurant with red
48:33 Jake’s black pinstripe suit and bandages on his nose
50:24 medium close up profile shot of Jake and Evelyn stare off
54:28 brilliant subtext
57:01 immaculate décor with JJ in foreground facing away from camera
1:00:55 great frame using windshield
1:01:21 close up on fish with the head still attached, John Huston is really great here
1:04:55 impressive frame with blocking, 3 depths of field
1:06:04 nice blocking with 3 characters positioned diagonally across the frame
1:07:05 more dedication to color, here Jake’s suit with the library of the city hall
1:09:40 another profile shot of Jake, here its near the orange groves
1:10:42 Jack attracted at orange groves
1:13:18 two shot of Evelyn and JJ in car with purple/red sky, painterly image
1:15:02 wide angle shot
1:27:47 pan across Jake’s room reveals similar décor and color palette to Jake’s office
1:30:44 wide angle shot
1:30:47 frame in frame using window and curtains
1:32:32 Jake is literally in the dark in this scene confronting Evelyn regarding the girl later revealed to be Evelyne’s daughter/sister
1:38:50 inside of house dark with sinister score, contrasted with bright and sunny day outside when Jake approached and entered the house
1:41:24 nice blocking with 3 characters positioned diagonally across the frame
1:50:00 daughter and sister scene
1:54:47 profile shot of Jake talking on phone
2:02:40 JJ and Noah Cross stare off in profile, shortly before its revealed that Cross’s hired thug Claude Mulvihill has been present in the scene the entire time
2:03:43 ending location in Chinatown in LA, upon entering shaky camera and bright neon lighting which is a noticeable contrast from everything leading up to it as the film is mainly devoid of primary colors
2:07:58 great blocking following tragic death
Apparently, Polanski and Robert Towne argued over the ending with Polanski winning out and giving the film a tragic ending which was certainly the correct choice, a happy ever after ending would simply feel out of place in this world of corruption where repulsive human beings like Noah Cross unfortunately get to go about their lives
@James-So do you still have it as Polanski’s best or below all or any of his Apartment Trilogy Films? I’m pretty confident the directing achievement for him is bigger in The Apartment Trilogy than it is here. But not overly sure when you combine the brilliant screenplay of Chinatown. Plus when going through Polanski’s filmography I noticed a trademark shot of his. The low angle object in front shot. This is used in Frantic, Death and the Maiden quite a few times actually and also in Tess.
@Malith – I have another post with far more detail, its not posting for some reason, I’ll wait till that comes out
@James Trapp- sorry, the system won’t someone include that many links in the comments
@Drake – is there a specific limit?
@James Trapp – I believe it is 1 per comment if you have a history of approved comments here (like you have of course). I won’t even see the comment if its more than that and if someone doesn’t have a history of comments I won’t see it at all if it includes a hyperlink. Sorry for the hassle
@Drake-Have you seen all of Polanski’s 23 Feature films?
@Anderson – I believe 19. I think I’m missing his three (3) most recent and then “What?” or “Che?” from 1972
@Drake-Did you archive Bitter Moon? Dissolves seems to be his main tool here.
@Harry@Malith – Polanski has enough great films that the misses only do minimal damage. Plus we gets gems like this from Roger Ebert’s review of Pirates
“There hasn’t been a pirate movie in a long time, and after Roman Polanski’s “Pirates,” there may not be another one for a very long time. This movie represents some kind of low point for the genre that gave us Captain Blood. It also gives us a new pirate image to ponder.”
@James-Apparently this film holds a Guinness World Record haha. Got an Oscar nomination too.
https://collider.com/pirates-most-expensive-movie-prop/
It’s the only film he did after Knife in the Water where sailing is involved I believe.
@Malith – Bitter Moon is set on a cruise ship if that counts
Need to see it. TSPDT have it as the the 8th best film for Polanski and in their top 2000.
@Harry
There are only 4 Polanski (feature) films I am yet to see
Oliver Twist (2005) – this I fully intend on watching just was not available when I did Polanski Study but I will watch this for sure
What? (1972) – I would watch this despite the poor reviews
His 2 worst reviewed films:
Pirates (1986) – this is suppose to be a complete mess
The Palace (2023) – even before your review @Harry I was skeptical with the brutal reviews
It could be argued that with a great auteur it is worth watching all their films no matter what. Some people call it being a “completist”. Polanski is probably one of my 5 or 6 favorite filmmakers but I am actually okay skipping a film of some of my favorite auteurs under certain circumstances
@James-What? is definitely more worstly reviewed than Pirates haha.
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/diary-of-forbidden-dreams-1976
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/pirates-1986
https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/diary_of_forbidden_dreams
https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/1016363-pirates
Also known as Diary of Forbidden Dreams apparently
@James – I agree with that rule too, some skips granted here and there. I think re-watching Officer and a Spy is my next Polanski priority.
@Harry-Given you have seen most of his lesser works you need to especially see Venus in Fur and Oliver Twist. I can’t suggest What? and Pirates to anyone with not just bad but brutal reviews. But you did see The Palace haha.
The Palace (2023) – my initial thoughts
—-
Polanski is 90 years old and recruits some talent here. Jerzy Skolimowski as co-writer, Alexandre Desplat (collaborator of Wes Anderson, composer) and his 21st century cinematographer Paweł Edelman (The Ghost Writer, The Pianist, Officer and a Spy) for a weak film.
The Palace is an ensemble set in on New Years eve of the 20th century, the Y2K crisis and promotion of Putin to president of Russia are the political backdrop.
The opening shot is certainly impressive, not unlike how An Officer and a Spy starts. Oliver Masucci (who by far does the best acting in this film) is tracked by the camera for a two-minute shot as he addresses the entire hotel staff and begins the countdown to New Years. The film doesn’t yet drop off as the scene following this in the kitchen is also decent, featuring some montage editing and a unique composition of two plates being worked on.
Early one there are some decent gags, but this film quickly degenerates a shock, childishness and disgust become more of Polanski’s focus rather than solid filmaking.
Very much influenced by Triangle of Sadness but misses everything that makes that film interesting. It’s like Polanski saw the scene in that of everyone throwing up at dinner and wanted to make a 100 minute film out of that. Every hotel guest is rude, weird, obnoxious or suspicious in someway in contrast the hard-working hotel staff.
Overall a bland looking film. The visuals go up a small level once the sunsets and all the hotel lights turn on, there is also a decent use of fireworks for the New Years celebrations, but these moments are in spades. Terrible use of CGI for the penguin, it should stand out to everyone regardless of their eye for spotting digital effects.
References to Chinatown in the text. A character breaks his nose and hotel staff try to console him by mentioning a handsome actor who had a bandage on his nose in a film (Nicholson of course).
For a director I consider to consistently end his films in satisfying, interesting and memorable ways, the ending of The Palace is awful in comparison to nearly everything else. I would hate for this to be Polanski’s film but who is going to give him money to make another film when it feels like he is going out of his way as weak as possible.
A waste of a unique setting and time period.
The film is at its best whenever the camera is following Masucci with the soundtrack beaming away.
Not recommended, it’s not a complete disaster but it’s the worst Polanski film I’ve seen so far out of 19.
@Harry-I don’t get The Triangle of Sadness comparison. I think more like Grand Budapest Hotel and a previous of his film What?. From what I read. Polanski is an admirer of Wes probably and regularly share the same composer(Alexandre Desplat) as well.
@Malith – The Grand Budapest film isn’t really about mocking the rich like this film and Triangle of Sadness is.
Fair enough. I was thinking about the concept not the tone. What? is mocking the rich or the absurdity of the wealthy people so that probably is the best comparison. I think the Palace had already been shot when Triangle of Sadness was released. So this is more like a coincidence. Really he is trying to go for a completely different tone than his more serious films(strength). It’s a tendency and not a good one. He has done it a fair few times in his career. Cul-de-sac after Repulsion, What? after Macbeth, Pirates after Tess, Oliver Twist after The Pianist, Carnage after The Ghost Writer
I bet if he makes another film it would be something more serious.
Good point with the trend, The Fearless Vampire Killers also came out in that gap between Repulsion and Rosemary’s Baby.
Polanski films I have yet to see are What?, Pirates, Oliver Twist and Venus in Fur now. I think I will give all at least one shot, there are some fans of the first two I’ve seen.
@Harry-Venus in Fur is one of his most acclaimed films when it first got released. Won a lot of awards in France. Feels like it definitely need to be prioritized over things like Fearless Vampre Killers, What?, Pirates, Oliver Twist, Carnage and The Palace.
Didn’t realise it was so acclaimed, I’ve seen other play adaptations from Polanski but he doesn’t strike me as being able to do something like what Hitchcock did with Rope
@Malith – “I bet if he makes another film it would be something more serious.” I have noticed this trend as well. I almost never laugh watching his films, he simply has no comedic chops; His attempted humor just falls flat everytime. He would be better off sticking to his strengths; his career has confirmed this again and again.
@James-Yes. You could be right. Given the reviews his more comedic films have garnered. I don’t think he is bad at comedy though. Just he is great at subtle comedy not outright comedy. There is a lot of subtle comedy in his apartment trilogy. The Oliver Masucci character in The Palace is funny though. You should watch it. It’s not bad by any means.
@Harry-Shame Masucci got wasted in the lead. He is a great actor. Mikey Rourke, Fanny Ardant and John Cleese were big stars Once Upon a Time. And it’s their first time working with Polanski. I can’t give too much to praise to hiring Edelman and Desplat because they are collaborating in every one of his films since like forever. Skolimowski and Polanski are buddies since their film school days I think
@Harry-I did see The Palace. However with some problems that isn’t related to the film. First, I couldn’t find any subtitles for the film. And I always use these when watching a film at home. But even worse, it felt like at least 20-25% of this film is spoken in foreign languages(especially the Russian parts and the Fanny Ardant parts) so I didn’t understand these parts very well. Certainly I look forward to another viewing with proper subtitles especially for these foreign parts.
The film itself was far better than I thought. Yes I would agree Masucci had the best performance in the film and the opening was the highlight. The CGI parts( especially some of the exterior shots) were hideous but only used occasionally. I noticed two very important running themes in the film though. First is the repeated shots of people going up and down a corridor(especially the hotel staff mainly through profile shot with the camera moving backwards). These are used again and again. Other thing is there is a clear dedication to red and green in the mise-en scene. The hotel switching on the lights and switching them off is done well with the repeated shots. I mean overall I liked it. Certainly one could hope Polanski would do something more serious than this. But there was always something to look at for me. I can’t really wrap my head around the ending but I didn’t hate it. It is probably really bad if someone take it out of context separate from the film. But given the tone of the film it isn’t that bad to make me hate the film though.
Shame about Rourke’s face though. But I actually thought he gave a good performance here. The woman who played Cleese’s wife was very solid here too. I don’t think it is easy to play a character like this and pull it off.
@Malith – The Russian section (I didn’t really understand all the details but I did have subtittles) – they all come to the hotel and store a lot of money, on the TV the at the time Russian president resigns which is followed by Putin becoming president of Russia. The Russians there then go to the storage room to make a deal with someone who is about to become an ambassador of Russia to somewhere else, they make the deal after some negotiating…
I don’t think you really missing anything with the Fanny Ardant parts though, not much nuance there.
I think your praises are fair too, the tracking shots through corridors (mainly paired with Masucci) were nice and the mix of New Years and Christmas decor was also good. Also agree about Rourke and Brooklyn James (Cleese’s wife), though that rigor mortis scene was pretty awful.
@Harry-Yeah I think the Fanny Ardant and Joaquim Almeida parts were the weakest in the film. Not terrible but not great. Almeida’s wife was great though. Always dressed in red. Hysterical, screaming looking at the mirror.
I think these corridor/hallway tracking shots are not in the last 40 minutes or so. Which is a shame. There is a lot in the first part of the film. There is one when Cleese gets angry and he swallows pills at 2 separate points, there is one when the stern hotel worker brings the blanket with the excrement, another one when the two women hotel workers push a trolley with blankets down the corridor, a lot with Masucci or even the one when Cleese and wife go to receive special treatment and they follow that weird guy. Although this is from behind rather than from ahead unlike the rest.
But the green and red in the mise-en scene was pretty evident throughout. It was deliberately done. When the hotel lights go off everything is green except the red lipstick of the female guests. The place where the Czech family stays is completely green. The lights in the bedroom scene with Cleese and wife is predominantly green. The mat at the front of the hotel is red. The costume of the hotel staff has red handcuffs at the end of the shirt. The shirt zippers are green. It is well done. So is the occurrence of the women with veils throughout the film.
Rourke had a lot of meat in this film. He is rude to everyone else but with the bank assistant he is very friendly and very caring.
Top 10:
1.Rosemary’s Baby(1968)-MP
2.The Tenant(1976)-MP
3.Repulsion(1965)-MP
4.Chinatown(1974)-MP
5.An Officer and a Spy(2019)-MP
6.Tess(1979)-MP
7.The Ghost Writer(2010)-MS
8.Knife in the Water(1962)-MS
9.Based on a True Story(2017)-HR
10.The Pianist(2002)-HR(The final part is spectacular)
Top 20 performances:
1.Mia Farrow-Rosemary’s Baby
2.Catherine Deneuve-Repulsion
3.Jack Nicholson-Chinatown
4.Faye Dunaway-Chinatown
5.Adrien Brody-The Pianist
6.Jean Dujardin-An Officer and a Spy
7.Natassja Kinski-Tess
8.Louis Garrel-An Officer and a Spy
9.Eva Green-Based on a True Story
10.Sidney Blackmer-Rosemary’s Baby
11.Ruth Gordon-Rosemary’s Baby
12.John Huston-Chinatown
13.Olivia Williams-The Ghost Writer
14.Leigh Lawson-Tess
15.Pierce Brosnan-The Ghost Writer
16.Ewan McGregor-The Ghost Writer
17.Peter Firth-Tess
18.John Cassavetes-Rosemary’s Baby
19.Niemczyck(Andrzej)-Knife in the Water
20.Emmanuelle Seigner-Based on a True Story
@Malith – Chinatown at # 4 is a bold claim. I have Chinatown as a top 10 film ever but to be honest I think you could argue it is not his best directed film though its direction is amazing. Chinatown (1974) screenplay is perhaps the best ever and has impeccable performances and amazing direction. It is a perfect film even if there is nothing innovative about it.
@James-I need to see it again but feels like others are going for more and more unique in a way as well.
I don’t know why but the camera placement and then lifting it in the War rubble shot in The Pianist reminded me of the shot when Jack comes to Dunaway’s home in front of the camera by car and then the camera lifts over to reveal Dunaway’s home haha
@Malith – I think I will revisit Chinatown in the next few days with notes, my recent viewings of An Officer and a Spy and Based on a True Story has peaked my interest
@James-Do you think An Officer and a Spy is the most similar film to The Pianist in Polanski’s filmography? I first noticed it when Szpilman was located right near the Enemy headquarters and he is surveiling it from his window. The same thing happens in An Officer and a Spy. Not to mention Dujardin playing the Piano in that messy room has to remind one of The Pianist.
Same with The Ghost Writer and Based on a True Story. Both films are about writing or trying to write an autobiography/novel. Then we end with the book publication ceremony in both and the similar end credits on a paper bundle. Chinatown is the one I have a hard time connecting with the rest of his work. Although Ghost Writer exists in the same genre.
@Malith – I have not seen The Pianist (2002) as many times as some of his other films so hard to say. The Pianist is horrifying at times even for a Holocasust Film.
Chinatown (1974) does feel more collaborative than his other top films because it is, as its the only one of his best films that he is not the screenwriter or co-screenwriter. I could see why someone would prefer his direction in the unofficial “apartment trilogy” films. I am excited to take another look at Chinatown and try to focus on the direction and visual style since the screenplay and acting are so highly lauded.
I don’t think Polanski did the Pianist screenplay. It is a strong film. I just wish the final part of this film was a little longer and the first two thirds shorter. There is a flat out awful scene in the film too. Which is a shame. That unfunny German general who gave a muttering speech in English. The film gets stronger and stronger once Brody gets isolated and is just surviving by himself
@James @Malith – The Palace is available now, I’m going to watch it today or this week
Updated!
1.Rosemary’s Baby(1968)-MP
2.The Tenant(1976)-MP
3.Repulsion(1965)-MP
4.Chinatown(1974)-MP
5.An Officer and a Spy(2019)-MP
6.Tess(1979)-MP
7.The Ghost Writer(2010)-MS
8.Knife in the Water(1962)-MS
9.Based on a True Story(2017)-HR
10.The Pianist(2002)-HR
11.Bitter Moon(1992)-R/HR
12.The Palace(2023)-R(yeah)
The performances:
1.Farrow-Rosemary’s Baby
2.Deneuve-Repulsion
3.Nicholson-Chinatown
4.Dunaway-Chinatown
5.Kinski-Tess
6.Blackmer-Rosemary’s Baby
7.Huston-Chinatown
8.Gordon-Rosemary’s Baby
9.Coyote-Bitter Moon
10.Dujardin-An Officer and a Spy
11.Garrel-An Officer and a Spy
12.Eva Green-Based on a True Story
13.Olivia Williams-The Ghost Writer
14.Seigner-Bitter Moon
15.Brody-The Pianist
16.Lawson-Tess
17.Brosnan-The Ghost Writer
18.McGregor-The Ghost Writer
19.Polanski-The Tenant
20.Firth-Tess
21.Cassavetes-Rosemary’s Baby
22.Rourke-The Palace
23.Masucci-The Palace
24.Andrzyj-Knife in the Water
25.Seigner-Based on a True Story
@Malith – plan on watching Based on a True Story tonight or tomorrow, will include my thoughts as usual. Yeah ,the Hitchcock Study is sort of my White Whale for film reviews. Been wanting to do it for a couple years now but think I’m ready, I will of course be watching other films as well but Hitchcock is probably my all time favorite after only Scorsese.
As for Nicolas Winding Refn, I loved Drive (2011) only saw it for the first time somewhat recently, probably within the last year or two. Only God Forgives (2013) I saw once and had some trouble with it despite some gorgeous shots but certainly will do another viewing at some point
@James-Did you watch it?
@Malith – Based on a True Story (2017)
Starts with author named Delphine, play by Polanski’s real life wife and go to actress Emmanuelle Seigner, signing books for fans
3 min mark an attraction woman in her 30s named Elle shows up and spark of interest
3:50 club music, blue and pink neon lights
11:38 internal narration after Delphine’s walk with her boyfriend/husband François
12:54 Elle calls Delphine who is alone in house and goes out to restaurant/café to meet Elle
14:06 green and red dominate mise en scene
15:50 Delphine and Elle shot in close proximity to others during on subway
17:52 POV long shot from Delphine POV
19:10 Delphine goes to dinner party at Elle’s place except no one else shows up
25 min the women meet again in same café
26:05 slow camera movements
29 min more anonymous phone calls
30:40 Delphine becoming upset in background of Frame as Elle reads criticism from online opinions
31:29 smooth transition from Elle to spinning overhead shot of Delphine in bed trying to sleep
33:49 depth of field significantly increases
37:02 another shot with significant depth between foreground and background, in room that looks like it could be a college dorm room
38:43 over shoulder POV shot of distorted image of Elle behind glass door producing multiple reflections
40 min tension ramps up between Delphine and Elle
46:14 low angle shot of Elle who just seems to appear out of nowhere at all times
46:57 both women in profile shot facing each other
49:27 close up on phone taking up most of left side of frame
57:40 Elle is again shown in low angle POV shot
1:01:00 the women drive during rainy night
1:02:15 Delphine shown speaking on phone about Elle
1:02:25 medium shot of Elle pumping gas
1:03:44 random woman at gas station just happened to be a librarian at a school Delphine thought Elle covered for her
1:07:37 dark blue with hint of green tinted frame
1:09:22 low angle shot of Elle
1:17:03 extreme low angle shot of Delphine going into cellar/basement
1:20:58 camera turning counterclockwise inside bedroom where Delphine is shown to be sick
1:24:09 slow motion violence, possibly a dream
1:25:50 beautiful shot of country house
1:30:30 Delphine walking though rainstorm using crutches, frame dark blue during night rainstorm
1:35:55 score becomes increasingly intense as Elle is seen one last time before the film ends
Thoughts:
I was not even aware of this film’s existence until recently. It is definitely Polanski using his strengths; atmosphere and slowly building unsettling feelings at a perfect pace
Hard not to think of Persona (1966) as the film revolves around the relationship between two women who becomes friends and grow increasingly dependent on each other. All About Eve (1950) is a comedy but with some commonality as well with Elle character being similar to Eve, an obsessed fan who tries to become her idol
There is a growing power imbalance as Delphine becomes increasingly sick throughout the film and spends more and more time lying in bed while Elle is often shown in low angle shot from Delphine’s POV
Polanski’s gift for creating suspense with minimal set locations and characters is on display as the film primary focuses on two characters who form friendship and professional bond but one that gets increasingly possessive and controlling with Elle as the wildcard
There are some impressive shots with deep depth of field and the two characters in opposite positions in the frame
Verdict: HR/R
@James-I didn’t notice that much depth of field here actually. There is a nice one in front of a park at one point. That whole scene is very well shot. It’s very subtle. The Green character never talks with anyone other than the Seigner character throughout the film. She clearly exists in her imagination. There was a recurring slow motion sequence when Green gets angry with the sound cut out that is well done. I think the finale brings this film up a notch. It’s brilliant. It’s not only a great bookend with the opening but is accompanied by one of Desplat’s best scores. And then the Ghost Writer like end credits. Really it’s the most similar film to Ghost Writer in Polanski’s filmography in many ways. I don’t know what critics are smoking here. This isn’t a flawed film. Did they think they were going to watch a love story? It’s much more subtle and accomplished than that.
Not to mention lots of red in this film. The two actresses where red lipstick, red fingernails, the red scarf.
@Malith – there are only a couple shots with significant depth of field but they stood out to me. Good call on the color palette, green and red dominate the mise en scene for sure. I figured the Green character probably was a split personality/imaginary character about halfway through. Polanski is really great at pacing his stories, they are patient but slowly built momentem. I think as of now I would rank his 21st Century Films
1. An Officer and a Spy and Ghost Writer are # 1 and # 2 in some order, too close to call for me without another viewing of Ghost Writer but they are both near MP level
3. The Pianist – HR
4. True Story – HR/R (I could see this moving up with additional viewings)
5. Carnage – R
6. Venue in Fur – R
I have not seen Oliver Twist
@James-If there is a small nitpick in the film it is I wanted a bit more at end before the finale. The Green character disappeared too quickly without seeing Seigner escape. I think the Seigner character certainly thinks Green is a doppleganger and/or wants to be like the Green character. Not just the matching red lipstick but also sending Green to a school to give a lecture instead of her. Ghost Writer’s ceiling feels like a MS. It is great no doubt. It is paced very well too. And a great location too. But feel like there needed to be more visually. Did you see the Palace?
An Officer and a Spy (2019)
Notes:
The film revolves around Albert Dreyfus, a Jewish French soldier falsely accused of treason, his being Jewish is a key aspect of the film as he is one of the only Jewish soldiers and prone to mistreatment
Great opening with a museum quality symmetrical shot in courtyard with France military officers in dark blue and maroon, red uniforms and under a dark blue and cloudy sky establishing a particular mood in the very first scene
6:18 series of four shots evenly spaced out over approximately 10 second showing the increasing distance between the camera and Devil’s Island which is an Island in French Guiana that is completely isolated serves as the location of Alfred Dreyfus prison cell
19 min I like the way everything is arranged in order to provoke a confession out of Dreyfus
26:46 Beautiful interior shot of Church
31:58 gorgeous interior with art made of white stone, noticeably lighter than other interiors
34:16 hazy Fincher-esque green lighting in bar/social club or sorts
36:20 intense red light beams inside photography room
51:13 great dissolve following the verdict being read in court to shot of a distraught Picquart smoking a cigarette in his office
53:45 sepia resembles opening of Tarkovsky’s Stalker (1979)
1:13:50 camera slowly pans through music hall and stops and holds on Picquart’s face showing his increasing uneasiness with the realization that Dreyfus is innocent
1:15:07 stunning shot, lighting, and mise en scene that could be out of Barry Lyndon
1:18:06 brilliant edit to a long shot of Picquart walking through quiet and empty alley surrounded by towering gray stone buildings upon failing to convince his superiors that Dreyfus case should be reexamined, an individual crushed by a bureaucratic system a la The Trial
1:21:38 another stunner in which the placements of the individual’s in the frame tell so much, the shot reverse shot shows 3 individuals representing the army and Picquart isolated in the frame sitting across from his superiors, always shown as group of 3, throughout the sequence
1:34:44 montage of J’accuse newspaper article being read throughout Paris
1:37:15 claustrophobic environment, with narrow hallways and small room
1:38:21 over the shoulder tracking shot of Picquart walking into court room, great mise en scene and composition
1:42:00 so many impressive shots during Picquart’s trial with packed court rooms filling the frames with meticulous detail
1:47:30 fencing scene following guilty verdict with Picquart facing Hubert-Joseph Henry, his friend and colleague prior to Picquart’s decision to defy his superiors
1:48:03 Picquart facing Hubert-Joseph Henry, both with blades raised in near symmetrical shot except light peeking though window on Picquart but not Henry
1:51:45 Picquart out of prison with charges dropped
1:53:06 a couple of very impressive dissolves revolving around Dreyfus sticking his head out of the window of his prison cell and the harsh waters surrounding the island he is still imprison on
2:02:13 another beautiful interior shot, so many that I can’t emphasize everyone but this one finally has Dreyfus and Picquart facing each other
2:04:44 another standout shot of the two men facing each other, here in profile
Thoughts:
Great opening with a museum quality symmetrical shot in courtyard with French military officers in dark blue and maroon, red uniforms and under a dark blue and cloudy sky establishing a particular mood in the very first scene. The icy nature of the film’s world is emphasized in other ways as well; Long walks in empty hallways, many of the shots are characters isolated in the frame, dimly lit interiors
The production design is meticulous with careful color palette enforced throughout the film along with the lighting which are appropriate for the subject matter of the story which covers darker aspects of human psychology including the treatment of society “outsiders” and human prejudices and biases
Green, brown, and gold dominate the color palette for many of the film’s interior shots taking place in offices, court rooms, social clubs, churches, and various military facilities
High angle surveillance shots and shots framed through telescopes are used to further emphasize the film’s tense atmosphere. Polanski’s work often examines power imbalances on both personal and institutional levels, and this is present in this film. The individual is not really idealistic but is uneasy by the possibility of innocence and more importantly that no one around him seems to care
At the heart of the film is a gripping narrative, the pacing is perfect and around halfway there is a notable change as the French Miliary changes from merely being uneasy to Picquart’s belief in Dreyfus innocence to a full on coverup and with that some growing paranoia from Picquart’s perspective. Paranoia is something Polanski does better than just about anyone though the film never quite goes into thriller territory
Jean Dujardin is excellent playing Georges Picquart, the lead investigator on the Dreyfus case
Louis Garrel plays Alfred Dreyfus, I did not realize it at the time, but I watched the French Film, The Innocent (2022) last week in which Louis Garrel both directs and plays the lead character.
Emmanuelle Seigner is solid as always; she is not only married to Polanski since 1989 but has roles in several of his films since then including several lead roles
I have no real complaints, this is extremely well made and impressive Cinema
Verdict: MS/MP
@James-The shot with the sculptures at the museum is the best single shot of 2019. The courtroom scenes are ridiculously well shot. Polanski sets the frame brilliantly when every courtroom scene starts. Did you notice the same shot is used brilliantly to juxtapose the difference of reaction to two different persons arriving at court? When the old general comes he is greeted with a warm round of applause. When Picquart comes he is met with boos. Brilliant.
So outside the film there is a lot to talk as well. First is it is remarkable how Polanski made this film at age 86. Second it is not a small film. It is an epic film. It frankly looks more expensive than any film Polanski ever made. So I don’t know how he got the budget given his troubles. And the other one is the cast. This is one of the best French casts ever assembled. You have everyone from Dujardin to Garrel to Seigner to Amalric to Poupaud to Vincent Perez to Gregory Gadebois. All multiple Cesar Award nominees. And it is authentic and realistic. Not like Ridley Scott casting American and British actors to play French People in Napoleon.
@Malith – I did notice the same shots regarding the court entrances. The court scenes were beautifully shot, similar to the film’s opening. This may be Polanski’s most beautifully shot film along with Tess. It works at every level; intriguing narrative, strong performances, consistently stunning visuals, and effective pacing.
Napoleon (2023) has some really impressive shots such as the battle sequence with the soldier falling below the ice. The problem with Napoleon is that the screenplay is a mess, the order of the scenes felt almost arbitrary. I think it would have been better as an Amazon series, one of those 8-10 episode series or trimmed down to a 2 hour film. An Officer and a Spy is lean, I liked that Polanski does not spend too much time on Picquart’s personal life.
This and Tess I think separates Polanski from others like De Palma, Argento etc. Can De Palma do a period film? He hasn’t shown that range.
Good take on Napoleon. Screenplay is a mess. It fails to have any strong characters outside Phoenix and Kirby(really awful given the scope this film is covering). They are solid but gets let down a lot by bad writing. Scott seems to be aiming for something similar to Phantom Thread but without non of the wit and potency. Some scenes are just added for shock value through sheer vulgarity. I don’t know how they can fix this film or make it better by making it longer or episodic given the other characters are weak. And I didn’t walk away from the film wanting to see more of them. Yes. I think the film would work better if they trimmed it especially the opening hour and fast forward to the winter battle sequence
@Malith – You’re probably right, Napoleon might be a lost cause which is unfortunate because of the expectations.
Comparing De Palma with Polanski makes sense as they are perhaps the two best Hitchcock acolytes so to speak. I actually have my next 3 studies planned out; Bong Joon-ho, Hitchcock, and then De Palma so I will have plenty more to say then.
In between these Studies I will still be watching plenty else as always. I do want to revisit Knife in the Water (1962) soon. Polanski’s case does seem to be getting stronger and stronger the more I watch. His films do seem to improve with additional viewings to an even greater degree than other great auteurs.
@James-A Hitchcock study will take a whole year. Haha.
Did you manage to watch Based on a True Story yet? Have you ever done a Nicolas Winding Refn study including his two TV series(Too Old to Die Young, Copenhagen Cowboy especially)?
@James-So I watched the Ninth Gate again. It’s been a long time since I last saw it. So I basically remembered next to nothing. I expected a worse Johnny Depp performance and a worse ending. But they were better than I expected. Especially Depp is very good here. So is Langella and Olin who is amazing in her scenes(not sure she has ever been better).
So even though many criticize the ending or final part I think the fatal flow in this film is the Emmanuelle Seigner character/role/performance. And it’s no surprise she plays a big part in the climax. I have loved her in all other Polanski films(not seen Venus in Fur) but this character doesn’t work. First there is a lot of special affects used with her character(the flying, the shifting green eyes which gets ridiculous after the first scene) and second it is very one note and she has no character arc or any sort of vulnerability. A lot has to do with the writing but she gets repetitive and gets more and more ridiculous while the film goes on. I firmly believe they should have set up a big revelation with her character rather than always portray her as a mystifying, ghost like figure. Of course with some clues planted in for the big revelation. I don’t know what actresses should land this role because it is a strange one. You have any suggestions? I think the film is strong though. There is a lot to like. There are standout sequences like the opening, the tracking shot with blue chairs at Frank Langella’s lecture, the eerie murder of the 3rd wheel chair bound book occupant(which is not seen on screen), then someone(or camera) coming from behind and thumping Depp on the head. Also literally the wheelchair running into the fire after this. There is a lot of zoom ins on the photo rather than just showing them and subtle camera movements behind Depp for most of the film. And that Indian taxi driver is creepy as hell. So liked it overall. Strong film.