Woo. Woo’s case is his unabashed style and depth of filmography—there aren’t too many style-plus auteurs left this far down the list with a fourth best film as good as Hard Boiled or fifth as strong as A Bullet in the Head. If great auteurs can often be parodied (think Wes Anderson’s SNL skit) then how about John Woo? One of my major problems with Woo (and the reason I probably have a hard time finding room for the films in their respective top 100 of the decade) is how close they walk the line to camp. Leone could be both violent and funny without walking that line—and I’m not sure Woo always does. It has been far too long since I’ve seen many of them so I’m excited to revisit.
Best film: Face/Off
total archiveable films: 7

top 100 films: 0
top 500 films: 0
top 100 films of the decade: 1 (Face/Off)

most overrated: A Better Tomorrow is the film that really lifted Woo—but it lands at #928 in the TSPDT consensus top 1000 and though I’m not far off—I’m not sure I have a spot for it in my top 1000.
most underrated: It has to be Face/Off right? It is ranked on TSPDT as his 4th best (both A Better Tomorrow and The Killer are in the top 1000 and Hard Boiled is ahead of Face/Off on the list of 1001-2000).
gem I want to spotlight : Hard Boiled. Often regarded as one of the best action “oners” or one-shot action sequences.

stylistic innovations/traits:
- Woo makes urban westerns, balletic violence—bullets flying. This certainly sounds like Peckinpah (who worshiped Kurosawa). Leone is no doubt an influence, I’d consider Tony Scott’s a peer of Woo with his montage/coverage choices
- As far as narrative—we’re often dealing with good and evil, the thin line between cops/criminals and bonding between partners (and or) enemies. Haws’ work in masculinity in cinema is one to cite here
- Slow-motion work, dissolves, jumps, freezes and dissolves—all part of the arsenal for Woo- it is fair to say that Woo is a master editor


top 10
- Face/Off
- The Killer
- A Better Tomorrow
- Hard Boiled
- A Bullet in the Head
- Red Cliff I
- Red Cliff II
By year and grades
| 1986- A Better Tomorrow | HR |
| 1989- The Killer | HR |
| 1990- A Bullet In the Head | |
| 1992- Hard Boiled | R |
| 1997- Face/Off | HR |
| 2008- Red Cliff I | R |
| 2009- Red Cliff II | R |
*MP is Masterpiece- top 1-3 quality of the year film
MS is Must-see- top 5-6 quality of the year film
HR is Highly Recommend- top 10 quality of the year film
R is Recommend- outside the top 10 of the year quality film but still in the archives
PTU (2003)
Cast:
Simon Yam as Police Tactical Unit Sergeant Mike Ho
Maggie Shiu as Police Tactical Unit Sergeant Kat
Lam Suet as District Anti-Triad Squad Sergeant Lo Sa
Ruby Wong as District Crime Squad Inspector Leigh Cheng
Raymond Wong Ho-yin as Constable Wong
Notes:
Opens with shot of City at night with neon lit signs from POV out of police van and a shot of police inside the van with nice character blocking
5 min group of young adults inside restaurant
9:15 after building up of tension some of the young adults key the vehicle of Sergeant Lo Sa
10:20 slow motion as low level gangster is stabbed in the back with a knife
11:34 shaky camera used during chase sequence
16:01 missing gun needs to be found
20:40 nice character blocking in shot inside casino
22:11 low angle two-shot with officer standing over Triad member
27:13 Sergeant wakes up without gun
34:42 streetlights serve as spotlights
36:03 neon lit signs in shot of city at night
36:45 slow push in on shocked faces of law enforcement officers
41:38 silhouette image of officers walking toward camera
53:35 streetlights serve as spotlight
57:44 dimly lit underground lair
58:37 Crime boss emerges from the shadows literally and makes request of the Sergeant in exchange for getting his gun back
1:05:08 nice blocking with characters spread throughout the frame
1:06:44 officers are unhappy about risking their jobs for the Sergeant but do so anyways
1:13:44 shaky camera from POV on boat to shore
1:16:38 tension building as all the relevant characters are meeting in a single location
1:18:34 close up on face of character in foreground with shallow focus on 4 officers in background
1:18:51 bullets start flying in climatic shootout
1:22:18 POV of gun in the Sergeants hand
1:22:35 camera floating above all the killed officers lying in the streets
1:24:40 montage of characters practicing their lines in the cover up for all the violence that occurred as a result of the Sergeants selfish decision
Thoughts:
A cops and criminals film set in Hong Kong and focusing on an anti-gang unit and the Triads they are up against. The film is fairly straight forward narratively as it examines relationship between law enforcement and criminals
Evolving power dynamics between police and criminals are a theme throughout the film. The frequent use of low angle and high angle medium shots fits this
Even at just 85 minutes this feels like a slow burn. The opening 10 minutes builds tension effectively and sets up the film’s themes
Some odd music choices where the score does not seem to match the atmosphere, I actually preferred the frequent use of no score or other music that is prevalent throughout the film
Impressive character blocking as numerous compositions have characters filling out the frame in multiple depths of field
Extremely cynical, it is actually hard to imagine an American film ending this way
Verdict: R
Executioners (1993)
Cast:
Michelle Yeoh as Ching/San/Carol
Anita Mui as Tung/Wonder Woman/Dorothy
Maggie Cheung as Chat/Thief Catcher/Chelsea
Damian Lau as Inspector Lau
Anthony Wong as Mr. Kim/Kau
Notes:
Opens with voice over narration as Wonder Woman driving a truck
3:03 crash sets off fire and series of action sequences
5:06 slow motion as the fight starts during a gloomy day with blue/gray color palette
7:50 Wonder Woman at home with her young daughter
11:37 camera floating through heavy fog laden streets
13:06 camera push in rapidly in an intense scene ending with a dramatic death
14:59 anti-government protests in the blue lit streets
17:24 red lighting illuminates over blue frame as protesters are shot
19:03 silhouette imagery in streets
22:34 religious imagery inside Church as the Trio reunites leading to a spontaneous fight
24:20 desaturated color in Church flashback
31:09 slow motion briefly used as Chat beats up man in the streets
33:00 camera slowly rotating around Wonder Woman listening to message from husband
38:21 slow motion
44:36 group talks about their successful strike which has caused people to lose faith in their government
46:02 frame in frame using prison door
46:27 handheld camera and rapid cuts capturing raw emotion
48:40 Tung is locked up by the government
54:04 canted angle with slow motion shootout
56:09 muted color palette inside a religious building
57:08 high angle shot of Tung still inside a prison cell
1:00:36 shaky camera movements as they drive through military zones
1:05:54 slow motion hand to hand combat
1:08:02 a clean water supply indicated by a clear inverted reflection of characters
1:09:30 extended underwater sequence as the family of three jumps into the clean water
1:13:40 creative use of framing combined with slow motion fight sequence
1:15:51 push in reaction shot
1:16:52 hand to hand combat sequence with quick cuts along with a variety of camera angles and rapid dolly movements
1:22:14 a masked Wonder Woman walks the streets with opaque gray/blue hazy light
1:24:12 extreme close up on bullets/arrows flying through the air
1:26:38 red lighting throughout the frame after primary colors being largely absent throughout the film signifying a change in the formerly repressive environment
Thoughts:
This is a sequel to The Heroic Trio (1993) which was released the same year. Executioners is noticeably darker in mood and atmosphere and far less playful
The Executioners is set in a post-apocalyptic world. The cityscape consists of military zones, industrials areas, polluted water sources. The Hectic Trio focused on the 3 female leads joining forces to take down a baby stealing villain who was appropriately named “Evil Master”. This film focuses on the Trio fighting back against a repressive government. There is an evil master character who controls the city’s water supply and is able to exert pressure and influence via political puppets
The majority of the film uses desaturated tones of gray and blue. There are muted browns and green as well. There are much less primary colors and saturated colors in comparison to The Heroic Trio which is fitting to the darker subject matter and bleak atmosphere. The score is fittingly less whimsical than the Heroic Trio
The film uses rapid edits during hand to hand combat sequences with frequent dolly ins which are often used as reaction shots of characters during high stress situations
There are great action moments but also moments that offer a reprieve from the chaos including a sequence where the family of 3 takes an extended swim when they finally locate an area with clean drinking water
Similar to Heroic Trio there are terrible sequences that combine slow motion, canted angles, and rapid edits. The pacing is considerably slower much of the film so the high action sequences are crucial when they do occur
Verdict: HR
*Similar to Heroic Trio there are terrific* sequences that combine…
Johnnie To Study
There is no page for Johnnie To so posting on page of fellow Hong Kong auteur
The Heroic Trio (1993)
Cast:
Michelle Yeoh – Ching/San/Invisible Woman
Anita Mui – Tung/Wonder Woman
Maggie Cheung – Chat/Thief Catcher
Damian Lau – Inspector Lau
Anthony Wong – Kau
Notes:
The film starts with a real estate agent taking a couple to a house in a secluded location
2:58 extreme low angle shot of house
3:28 hazy sunlight peeking through the windows to interior
4:37 cut to POV to close up on wire as would be thieve attempts to hotwire the car of the man who is revealed to be a police officer
8:02 shot of hospital room full of babies in cribs, they are taken by a supernatural force, following the showing of a ransom note
8:58 caped crusader saves the falling babies, another crusader arrives shortly after
10:32 close up on a caped crusader wearing a mask
11:33 shot of landscape during sunrise
12:25 surprise attack followed by hand to hand combat in slow motion
13:18 low canted angle shot as the kidnapped baby is hand delivered to Villain “Evil Master” shown with bright orange/yellow light
17:43 slow motion with pink umbrella standing out compared to the gray/blue tinted frame
18:39 canted angle shot after young children fall out of apartment building in slow motion
20:17 gray/blue frame as law enforcement arrives at building
21:51 Maggie Cheung as Chat/Thief Catcher makes her dramatic arrival on a motorcycle and impressing some of the officers, all of whom are male
22:44 great combat scene with silhouette imagery, fast cuts, and various camera angles
24:17 Michelle Yeoh as Ching/San/Invisible Woman
26:43 close up on face of man wanting revenge as he locks them inside storage facility
30:40 low angle shot followed by high angle shot emphasizing superheroes power
32:12 Chat/Thief Catcher vs Tung/Wonder Woman in sequence featuring change of speeds including a close up slow motion shot of a bullet traveling and being neutralized by a dagger
36:12 camera holds on masked face of Tung/Wonder Woman
37:10 nice use of silhouette and use of extreme foreground/background positioning of characters
38:52 beautiful use of dark blue in this extreme low angle shot with a suspension tower
39:21 cut to shot of Evil Master which green fog and orange light throughout the frame
43:06 red lighting over stolen baby inside crib
44:35 low angle shot with 3 characters positioned across frame in triangular composition
45:48 Anthony Wong as Kau crawls out from sewer in downtown area
46:51 slow motion shot of Chat/Thief Catcher riding motorcycle
50:50 slow motion explosion in the middle of the street
52:57 handheld camera captures the chaos and destruction
1:01:24 blue and red lighting throughout the sequence
1:02:49 extreme low angle shot of villain
1:07:59 slow motion shot of trio riding on horseback except for Chat who rides her motorcycle
1:11:47 hazy substance with multi-colors throughout the frame inside underground lair
1:14:10 another shot with blue and red lighting split in frame
1:14:55 final battle set in motion as the trio arrives to fight Evil Master and the crew
1:15:08 nice use of blocking and framing in this composition which includes characters evenly space across the frame in back of frame and Evil Master in the center of the midground
1:17:51 series of explosions detonate with rapid cuts
1:19:09 slow motion followed by rapid camera movements and cuts during battle with Evil Master
1:20:33 skeleton of Evil Master emerges from bright orange fire in the street
1:25:13 slow motion as the trio walks the neon lit city street at night
Thoughts:
After Wong Kar Wai I wanted to check out another Hong Kong auteur and I got some luck on my side as Criterion Channel added a collection of Johnnie To films. I am familiar with his name but had never watched or even read about his films prior to this
This is a combination of action, fantasy, adventure, with some superhero mythology. The basic premise revolves around 3 females with superpowers. Michelle Yeoh’s character is referred to as Ching or Invisible Woman who is kidnapping newborn babies and bringing them to the film’s supervillain appropriately named “Evil Master”. Anita Mui’s character named Tung or Wonder Woman who is a masked crime fighter like a Spider Man. Last but certainly not least is Maggie Cheung’s character named Chat or Thief Catcher, she is a bounty hunter who drives a motorcycle and walks around with sunglasses, a leather jacket, and a shotgun
The 3 main characters each have their own specialties in terms of weapons used. Wonder Woman throws knives or shurikens which are essentially star shaped daggers that can deflect bullets. Invisible Woman uses a Chain whip and Invisibility suit. Thief Catcher uses her shotgun but also boomerang-like swords. The leading females Michelle Yeoh, Anita Mui, and Maggie Cheung are all excellent. The Maggie Cheung character is very different from any of the roles she had in any of Wong Kar Wai’s films. Here she plays a fearless character who as noted above, rides motorcycles, wears leather jackets, and walks around with a shotgun
There is plenty to praise here; you have the raw kinetic energy from camera movement, slow motion to enhance the drama, expressionistic color, and a fast paced narrative
There are frequent uses of extreme high and low angle shots which are effectively in showing the changing power dynamics throughout a particular fight scene. The films involves characters with various superpowers, including flying. The film also uses canted angle shot at times which are effective in capturing the chaos and confusion during several of the battle sequences
The use of saturated colors, especially red, yellow, and orange enhance the fight scenes. The quieter moments use darker colors, particularly blue to create melancholy during the night scenes. Smoke and wind effects are also used to add to the hazy setting. Red is used as a sign of danger, for example, red lighting is used right before a shot of empty baby cribs at the hospital
The film has a couple of impressive set pieces including the train and the final battle in the streets which includes the Villain’s skeleton emerging in city streets. The choreography is particularly impressive in the film which includes battles in mid air and with characters saving people thrown out of windows in one scene
Great start to the Study, this was the first time I had seen any Johnnie To films, so I really did not know what to expect. There is definitely some degree of “camp” as there is some comedy that is probably unintentional which makes 88 minutes an ideal length for a film like this
Verdict: MS/HR
@Drake – How many Johnnie To films do you have in archives? Criterion Channel added a number of his films this month
@James Trapp- You know what- I’m not sure- not the easiest last name to quickly look up in my files. I think just one (1) maybe? Breaking News 2004 https://thecinemaarchives.com/2021/11/21/breaking-news-2004-to/
happy to see somebody come to see to’s film,I personally recommend you ptu,exiled,mad detective and Vengeance.These films are just amazing,if you like these,I will recommend you more similar film,hope you enjoy,waiting for your thoughts
@wp101983511 – happy to see someone familiar with his work. I wanted to check out another Hong Kong auteur and Criterion Channel made my decision quite easy. I have planning on watching the following 10 films though the list is not set in stone
The Heroic Trio (1993)
Executioners (1993)
PTU (2003)
Throw Down (2004)
Election (2005)
Exiled (2006)
Mad Detective (2007)
Life Without Principle (2011)
Drug War (2012)
Three (2016)
@James Trapp- You are not watching Breaking News?
https://thecinemaarchives.com/2021/11/21/breaking-news-2004-to/
https://bleedingcool.com/movies/shout-studios-gets-worldwide-rights-to-156-classic-hong-kong-films/
This is exciting! Hong Kong films outside of Woo and WKW have been hard to find. And even when I did my John Woo Study most of the films were not 4K
@James Trapp- Great share, James – thank you!
Broken Arrow (1996) is probably a R but I did not take notes, it was similar in quality to Silent Night (2023) although if I added it to the list above I would probably put it at # 11
Reign of Assassins (2010) is solid, again no notes but at least a R
I think I hit all the relevant John Woo for now
John Woo Study Summary:
John Woo is probably the most respected Hong Kong auteur aside from Wong Kar Wai. This study exceeded my expectations, Woo’s films are so much fun and are technically brilliant, but his narratives are also engaging, and his films have more emotional depth than I expected.
John Woo is Hollywood personified; when someone refers to a film, particularly an action film as “Hollywood” they are often referring to crazy unrealistic things like over the top gun shootouts, characters shooting at each other from motorcycles or on speed boats, ridiculous explosions, characters jumping off buildings, etc. John Woo has all this and more, but he does not take himself too seriously and instead fully embraces this highly entertaining style. This is not to say that Woo’s films have no substance because while his films are famous for gun fights, chases, and other action staples, Woo’s work has emotional depth as well. I was surprised by Bullet in the Head (1990) the title alone sounds like pure action but it’s actually an emotionally taxing film about the impact of Vietnam War on a trio of friends similar to Deer Hunter, there is even a prisoner of war escape scene. The relationship between the brothers on the opposite sides of the law in A Better Tomorrow (1986) is well acted and captures the anger and resentment of their relationship effectively.
His work is amongst the most purely entertaining.
Definitely similarities to Jean Pierre Melville in the crime worlds he creates in his films. Apparently, Le Samurai (1967) is one of Woo’s 3 favorite films along with Seven Samurai (1954), and Lawrence of Arabia (1962). John Woo refers to Jean-Pierre Melville as “my idol” in a recent interview I read leading up to Silent Night (2023). Woo wrote an essay in the booklet for the Criterion release of Le Samurai (1967) titled “The Melville Style” and another essay for the Criterion release of Le Cercle Rouge (1970) titled “Honor, Loyalty, and Friendship” And his ludicrously over the top violence definitely makes me think of Tarantino
Woo has style in spades; slow motion sequences, spectacular shootouts with amazing editing, constantly moving camera, dissolves, etc. Woo has a trademark shot that consists of two characters playing weapons, usually guns, at each other with their arms crossed. Despite the action and shootouts that play a huge part in his films, they are usually spread out leaving room for building the narrative and characters so the viewer will be invested in the story
Woo does use the freeze frame in a couple of his films, The 400 Blows is one of his favorite films according to one Woo interview I read in which he compared his life to the Truffaut created character Antoine Doinel and by extension Francois Truffaut himself
One minor criticism and it is not a huge issue, but Woo occasionally struggles with changes in mood during some of his films. For instance, Bong Joon-ho and Park Chan-wook are both masters of moving back and forth or even infusing different moods in a way that is almost imperceptible at times yet still feels cohesive, no easy task. Some of Woo’s intended humor or mood changes are sort of clumsy and it sticks out at times along with questionable musical choices. These issues rarely do significant damage however, so not a huge problem
Woo’s peak is certainly the late 80s and early 90s, but he had a solid run in Hollywood as well. Face/off, Hard Target, and his most recent film, Silent Night are 3 of his 8 Hollywood films. I also am going to watch Broken Arrow (1996) in the next couple weeks since I rented it for month but did not include in the study.
Final Ranking and Grades:
MPs
# 1 The Killer (1989)
# 2 A Better Tomorrow (1986)
MS
# 3 Face/Off (1997)
# 4 Hard Boiled (1992)
MS/HR
# 5 Bullet in the Head (1990)
HR
# 6 Red Cliff (2009)
# 7 Manhunt (2017)
# 8 Last Hurrah for Chivalry (1979)
R
# 9 Hard Target (1993)
# 10 Silent Night (2023)
@James Trapp- There is a page for Broken Arrow.
https://thecinemaarchives.com/2020/05/04/broken-arrow-1996-woo/
Interesting that you think so highly of Silent Night with Joel Kinnaman. Did you watch his new The Killer remake?
@Malith – “Interesting that you think so highly of Silent Night with Joel Kinnaman”
I would not say that. It is closer to a fringe R. There is a strong opening but some issues after that. I also noted that Joel Kinnaman’s performance is rather one note
“Did you watch his new The Killer remake?”
I did not
@James Trapp- Still much higher than where Silent Night was rated. Just slightly above Straight to Streaming.
@Malith – Which ratings are you referring to? Silent Night is a 60 on RT and 53 on MC which is not great obviously but I don’t think calling it a R or probably closer to a Fringe R is unreasonable. There is a great opening, they overdo the melodrama in the middle part
@James Trapp- Commercial performance and Production Budget . His next film was straight to streaming after all.
Manhunt (2017)
Notes:
2 min man revealed to be a Chinese pharmaceutical lawyer walks into bar
4:34 blocking with man standing in middle of two women at bar
5 min two women, one wearing blue and one wearing pink start shooting group of gangsters in bar
6:30 gorgeous series of aerial shots of City at night
7:09 blue, pink, and other neon colors in downtown night life
14:24 lawyer wakes up with a dead woman in the bed next to him, it’s an attractive younger woman he slept with
16:30 lawyer runs from police
19:26 low angle shot as reporter walks toward 2 men with machine guns
21:46 overhead shot of series of highways as lawyer makes his way through a tunnel
25:50 lawyer kidnaps the detective working his case
26:40 great fight sequence inside of car; Woo uses low ASL, shaky camera, rapidly changing camera angles, and a POV shot during the crash to capture hectic scene
30:40 shallow focus
35:35 detective and his female assistant walk through crime scene from murder a couple years prior, images from timeline going back and forth using dissolves and a blue tint for the scenes from an earlier time
41:41 seemingly adverse drug reaction as we see the two women from the opening scene in the bar; they are actually assassins who use their good looks to lure in their targets
43:20 POV from sniper, similar to the water assassination from The Killer
44:14 extreme close up on eyes during tense sequence with montage leading up to female assassin firing a golden bullet
47 min the lawyer and detective engage in more cat and mouse chases in crowded area
55:00 frame in frame, great symmetry at wedding
55:35 overhead shot
59:25 slow motion shot with 3 characters diving from car explosion
1:00:05 the detective handcuffs himself to lawyer similar to The Killer
1:06:08 brilliant fight sequence
1:09:50 corruption exposed
1:10:50 flashback of the frame
1:12:08 nice use of foreground/background and slight pan following headshot
1:13:44 flashback scene
1:17:20 the detective, recovering in the hospital, is visited by his superior who takes him off the case since he let the lawyer go 3 times without arresting him due to him realizing he is innocent
1:20:48 camera pans from surveillance angle across prison and hospital facility
1:24:27 great camera work and editing in this prison death scene
1:25:30 holographic image on right side of frame used as method for depicting character’s thoughts
1:27:42 intricate framing in this impressive composition with 3 depths of field
1:29:23 the films MacGuffin
1:30:34 great slow motion camera work throughout this sequence
1:35:55 not quite a freeze frame but a character shooting temporarily suspended in mid air
1:38:45 start of impressive sequence that blurs past and present regarding the murder and framing that sets the film into action
1:40:25 pink and blue color palette again
1:42:24 overhead shot with body in center of frame
1:43:24 bright day following all the chaos with picturesque shot near train station that could be a postcard image
1:44:06 “for a better tomorrow” Woo with some rare self-referential
1:44:12 film ends on a bright note with Detective and exonerated Lawyer saying their goodbyes
Thoughts:
John Woo returns to a style more in tune with his pre-Hollywood films, it’s fast paced with great action sequences throughout. A fun movie for sure although not of the same quality as his best work but still a worthy film in its own right. The film finds a good balance of action, narrative, and character building; enough to make you invested in the story
There are elements of The Fugitive (1993) complete with a man framed for a murder and the connection to a diabolical corporate crime related to pharmaceuticals. There is also police corruption which was not present in The Fugitive
Definitely some Hitchcock in this film with the “wrong man on the run” trope as well as a MacGuffin that is revealed near the end. You also have two characters handcuffed to one another similar to one of his best British Films; The 39 Steps (1935)
Woo uses blue and pink more than I have seen in his other films, overall, the color palette is varied throughout the film
Woo has a penchant for aerial shots that I’ve noticed more and more, same with overhead shots. The aerial shots are often of city night life similar to Michael Mann
Verdict: HR
Red Cliff (2009)
Notes:
Starts with beautiful ariel shot and dissolve of large empire in ancient China in 208 A.D. near end of Eastern Hang Dynasty
2:48 series of close up shots with quick zoom in
3:34 aftermath of brutal battle
4:52 ariel shot as soldiers on horses prepare for battle
Takeshi Kaneshiro (from Chungking Express) and Tony Leung (from Chungking Express and countless other great films)
8 min great editing during battle sequence, Woo’s slow motion and disorienting style works perfectly
15 triangle composition
18:20 great foreground/background work followed by rapid zoom out and high angle shot
23:03 shallow focus
23:36 dissolve with fog obscuring top of mountains
32:42 overhead shot
33:13 nice high angle shot and lighting
33:43 slow zoom out
40:28 active camera
41:14 nice blocking
42:58 soldiers filling frame to the max
43:40 arrows start to fly
45:20 ariel shot, epic filmmaking
52 min disorienting battle sequence with handheld camera
54:28 pan with low angle shots
59:30 nice blocking and framing
1:11:18 montage of battle rally
1:34:56 green lighting throughout most of frame
1:37:34 excellent series of dissolves and string instruments
2:03:10 another epic battle with great parallel editing as army’s march toward each other
2:05:47 high angle shot of massive fire
2:06:09 nice frame in frame
2:08:20 disorienting montage of battle, with low ASL and frequent changes in camera angles and distances
2:15:42 extreme close up followed by great dissolve with focus on eyes
2:20:04 low angle shot of the aftermath of the chaos
2:20:46 overhead shot
2:21:00 nice framing of faces in profile
Thoughts:
In China this was released in two parts in 2008 and 2009 totaling over 4 hours but outside of China a 148 minute version was released in 2009 so that is version I will cover
John Woo continues to impress me with his genre versatility with this epic war film
Woo has stated that his 3 favorite films of all time are:
Seven Samurai (1954)
Lawrence of Arabia (1962)
Le Samurai (1967)
This is his most Kurosawa-esque film, with some elements of Ran (1985) even if this is not as great as Ran (few films are)
This may be Woo’s best film in terms of compositions and mise en scene, Woo fills frames to the brim with extras while using symmetry in many of the most impressive compositions
The editing is top notch as well reminding me of The Wild Bunch (1969), some of the battle sequences are disorienting which is achieved using low ASL and frequent changes in camera angles and distances
Verdict: HR
Face/Off (1997)
Notes:
Starts with slow motion during opening credits and contrasts sentimental music when showing FBI Agent Sean Acher played John Travolta spending time with his son and ominous music when showing Castor Troy played by Nic Cage
7:18 supervillain Castor Troy in slow motion
8:25 gold money clip
8:38 Castor Troy evil villain laugh
13:40 slow motion show of Castor Troy horizontal double barreling two gold guns
16:25 Woo’s famous shot with 2 characters pointing guns at each other his arms crossed
29:17 “I’ll do it” classic line
33:47 overhead shot operation about to start
33:58 camera pans during operation
35 min Woo uses low ASL (average shot length) during operation
36:42 mirror motif
40 min blue/gray tint throughout frame
41:03 overhead shot with some nice lighting
42:18 gray/blue/green color palette in prison
48:27 slow zoom in on glasses with superimposed images
51:30 high angle surveillance shot
52:30 great sequence with face to face after the surgery
53:13 slow motion flashback
58:33 low angle shot
1:05:56 candle lit dinner, orange tint throughout frame
1:13:45 great jump sequence with slow motion and multiple takes
1:19:25 great use of orange lighting
1:20:00 POV shot looking into suitcase
1:21:38 evil laughing bad guys
1:22:18 “take his face off”
1:31:31 another shootout begins, again with low ASL, great montage completes with glass shattering, slow motion jumping and shooting of guns, and a combination of extreme angles befitting of the chaotic sequences
1:37:34 Travolta and Cage standing back to back, symmetrical frame, this is a classic Woo shot in several of his films
1:39:36 Scorsese triple take during death of Pollux Troy from falling through glass ceiling
1:49:00 the wild premise explained to characters as “Sean Archer” proofs to his wife he is Sean Archer despite appearing like Castor Troy
1:51:40 handheld camera movement
2:04:52 shootout on the water, explosions, slow motion jumps, and speed boats
2:07:48 amazing slow motion shot of Travolta and Cage jumping off boat right before potential fatality and seemingly freezing midair before the fall
Thoughts:
John Woo was born to direct this film; Woo is known for being over the top and this might be his single most ridiculously over the top film not just from the fight scenes but the characters as well, it is also non-stop fun
This film does not work if Woo goes halfway with the ludicrous action and storyline
I fully admit I am not the biggest Nicolas Cage fan, but this is a bit of an exception as his performance here absolutely works as Nic Cage tends to be ludicrously over the top, making him a perfect match with John Woo. Castor Troy is a glorious supervillain with double gold guns and unhinged laugh. Troy is like The Joker; he wants to create chaos for the sake of chaos. Travolta I basically always love, and this is no exception
Its hard to go 2 minutes without laughing, I think Woo definitely has his share of unintentional comedy but this is clearly meant to be ridiculous and that is a big factor in its effectiveness, it never takes itself too seriously
Overhead shots used throughout film as well as extreme low angle and high angle shots matching the rollercoaster action
The rewatchability of this film is top notch due to the humor, action, and fast moving narrative
The iconic Woo shot is present here a couple of times, that is the shot with 2 characters crossing arms and pointing guns at each other and the other iconic Woo shot with 2 characters standing back to back with thin layer separating them from each other
138 minute roller coast ride that does not let up or disappoint
Verdict: MS
Hard Target (1993)
Notes:
Starts with man being pursued by several motorcycles at night
2:30 neon lights super imposed over car window
4:47 shaky camera
Several close up shots of arrows spinning while traveling at target
8:30 some nice camera work through restaurant and extreme close up
10:43 unusual frame
11 min fight sequence featuring slow motion shots
14 min an attractive young woman is looking for her estranged father
28:44 dissolve to neo lit bar
31:10 dissolve
36:08 camera moving around interior of the house, with diegetic piano playing
38:40 red dominates mise en scene
40:26 nice background/foreground work
42:18 nice Polanski-esque peep hole shot ending with “The Moe Green Special” aka bullet though eye
45:20 high angle of men preparing for the same game that was shown in the opening scene
50:20 slow motion shooting
52:01 low angle shot of area resembling a ghost town
54 min great shootout sequence with slow motion, characters diving horizontally across the frame, and great choreography
59 min great stunts with motorcycle and shootout complete with multiple explosions
1:03:20 snake scene
1:10:03 another explosion
1:19:00 another great shootout sequel with explosions
1:21:06 slow motion kick to the head
1:24:04 great composition with the “good guy” and “bad guy” separated in symmetrical frame with their backs to one another holding guns
1:29:06 close up shots of faces while building tension
1:30:58 montage of all the victims of the villain
Thoughts:
John Woo’s Hollywood debut is quite fun, although the first half starts off slow (aside from the opening 10 minutes) but it does pick up after that
The basic premise resembles “The Most Dangerous Game” which is a short story about a man who hunts human beings for the challenge, here a group of criminals sets up situations where they offer people $10,000 if they can get across town alive
Jean-Claude Van Damme is not much of an actor, but he certainly has serious fighting skills. Before John Woo started making the high octane action films, he made Martial Arts films
The acting is brutal much of the time, which does not actually really matter all that much especially as the movie moves along.
I admire that Woo does not go halfway with this film, he sticks to his strengths by focusing on the wild shootouts complete with explosions and various stunts
Verdict: R
Hard Boiled (1992)
Notes:
A couple of Woo’s go to actors/actresses here. Chow Yun-fat as Inspector “Tequila” Yuen Ho-yan Tony Leung as Alan
Starts with club sequence, nice use of neon lights; here green and blue followed by montage of city lit up at night
6:24 great shootout scene starts, and a couple of the the Woo trademarks are present; slow motion and double fisted guns
12:13 dissolve edit to police funeral
14 min John Woo makes a cameo
15:18 trumpet/Jazz score
16:24 blood splattered after headshot in library murder in the middle of the day
18:18 freeze frame and dissolve
23:57 nice composition with characters in 3 depths of field
26:32 nice camera movement
27 min Anthony Wong plays the Triad Boss and Tony Leung as Alan, an undercover cop infiltrating Triad
28:50 camera panning over newspapers on car
34:30 crosscut, low angle shots as Triad picks up Leung’s character
37 slow motion shootout
41 min Leung in center of frame is only one not in motion
43:05 the classic John Woo shot with two men pointing their guns at the other with the arms crossed
50:43 silhouette image in thick layers of gas from the shootout
51:23 again we get the iconic John Woo crossed gun shot
51:40 freeze frame and dissolve
55:24 John Woo again! Playing a bar tender here
1:03:00 some nice camera movement as Leung’s character is taken to hospital following a shooting
1:12:42 shallow focus
1:13:01 nice background/foreground work
1:13:20 Leung’s character and Inspector speak now knowing one another
1:20:50 blue tint shot with the Inspector and Leung’s character in far background of frame
1:27:01 frame in frame with heavy layer of gray smoke in frame
1:27:53 solid camera work with the slow pan building up the suspense
1:29:09 great blocking with Triad boss facing camera in foreground, he’s clearly the leader of this group
1:36:50 nice crossing cutting
1:39:00 brief scene with lead characters bonding similar to a scene from The Killer (1989)
1:41:24 great composition using surveillance angle, nice framing
1:42:42 slow motion during fight in hospital with civilians huddled together
1:46:36 hallways shoot out, green/blue color palette
1:47:35 slow motion following Leung’s character killing man who might have been cop
1:56:20 close up on faces of Leung’s character and Triad member
1:57:31 great slow motion shooting death
1:59:37 great shot of Inspector running out of hospital carrying baby, orange frame from fire, Inspector throwing gun over his shoulders in slow motion
2:03:20 close ups alternated with medium shot as tension builds
2:04:56 the “Moe Green Special”
2:05:25 spinner overhead shot over Alan’s dead body
2:06:14 Alan’s voice “beyond the grave” in the Inspector’s mind followed by flashback on boat
Thoughts:
Another excellent action film from John Woo, his last Hong Kong film for a while as he would go to Hollywood around 1992/1993 so this is considered to be his last film from the “Hong Kong Golden Era” as one critic labeled it.
The cast is phenomenal with Woo’s go to lead man Chow Yun-fat as well the great Tony Leung. Anthony Wong plays the Triad Boss; he is excellent in the Infernal Affairs Trilogy. John Woo makes a cameo as a bar tender in several scenes; it’s pretty low key stuff but cool none the less.
This is “cops vs robbers” so to speak. The shootouts are expertly done of course, in fact they might be the best I have seen yet from John in that regard. The action never really lets up. The death count here has to be well over a 100. The narrative does not have quite the same level of appeal as The Killer which had the appeal of the lone wolf type Alain Delon character from Melville’s Le Samurai (1967) or the complicated dynamics created by loyalty to ones family from A Better Tomorrow
The editing is amazing with crosscuts, non-stop shootouts, and tension building montages usually proceeding outburst of violence.
The final scene with The Triad boss shot to death right through the eye, what the Sopranos refers to as “The Moe Green Special” which of course is a Godfather reference.
Amazing choreography, editing, and compositions. The entire film is
Jazz music in the score and jazz club was a go to move from Woo’s idol Jean Pierre Melville
Verdict: MS
@James – planning on seeing Silent Night tomorrow while I still can in theaters.
@Harry – let me know what you think, I posted my thoughts above. There is nothing really new aside from the lack of dialogue but some great action, Woo still is a technical master even if the creativity is not really there. The opening 10/15 min is really great stuff
@Drake – Curious about the following…
“One of my major problems with Woo (and the reason I probably have a hard time finding room for the films in their respective top 100 of the decade) is how close they walk the line to camp. Leone could be both violent and funny without walking that line—and I’m not sure Woo always does”
Are you saying that there is an inconsistent tone in Woo films where the narrative does not match the tone/mood? Or is it a matter of unintentional comedy? Woo’s films are absurb of course but this feels intentional to me. In this respect he is similar to other auteurs I have covered. Seijun Suzuki, Quentin Tarantino, Dario Argento, and Park Chan-wook could all could be described in a similar manner.
I am about half way done my Woo Study so I will continue to ponder these questions.
@James-I haven’t seen Drake around here in a while
@Malith – Okay, yeah I noticed that as well but was not sure if he was still monitoring discussion. I just figured that maybe he only responds if someone addresses him directly as opposed to him just responding to posts whenever he reads something he wants to repond to. Hope all is well.
Bullet In the Head (1990)
Notes:
Starts with fighting at frenetic pace set to jazz, film set in 1967
4:30 shot of 3 tower structures in desert like surrounding
5:50 cast consists of Tony Leung, Jacky Cheung, Waise Lee
8:02 active camera moving 360
8:30 slow motion close up
9:38 glowing red backdrop at Wedding
15:07 freeze frame
15:17 strong blue lighting throughout frame
18 min wild fight sequence involving about a dozen young men
19:56 nice foreground/background use
24:34 several quick zooms
24:56 great dissolve edit almost seems like a superimposed image watching horrors of war in the street
29:02 overhead shot capturing the madness including children running for their lives
31:27 violent confrontation built up during scene
32:27 red, pink, and green lighting inside nightclub
37 min slow zooms following shooting
46:44 slow motion overhead shot
50:44 attractive woman singing in night club
53:30 another impressive fight sequence
57:47 Leone-esque close up shots in isolation between shoot out
1:02:26 spectacular battle sequence with bright orange from fire flares over blue lighting and thick layers of smoke after bombings, chaos really
1:08:34 slow motion as men run with guns
1:12:21 Mexican standoff
1:14:17 explosions over the river
1:19:58 low angle shot of men holding the trio prisoners in Vietcong Prisoner Camp
1:25:00 brutality of war
1:29:14 great slow motion sequence as they make their escape Deer Hunter (1978) style in lulling the guards by playing along with their perverse torture games and taking advantage when they let their guards down a little too long
1:31:41 camera set low with wide angle shot of village
1:32:40 rapid editing creates chaos
1:38:38 canoe moving through water post battle followed by a long shot of water
1:39:44 great montage following the violence including several picturesque shots including flock of birds
1:41:58 profile shot with green and blue lighting throughout the frame
1:48:58 close up on faces during emotional scene
1:51:51 freeze frame
1:56:50 nice composition with frame in frames and multiple depths of field
1:58:20 strange sequence with Ben confronting Paul who is now a successful businessman
2:02:30 slow motion mixed with super imposed image from past
Thoughts:
Opening scene with some similarities to WKW As Tears Go By (1988) with gangs of young men running around recklessly
Strong primary colors, particularly blue and red, throughout the film including a couple of beautiful shots inside nightclub
The brutality of War is on display, especially when captured in Vietcong Prisoner Camp where the men are forced at gun point to kill other prisoners for the amusement of the Camp
Woo uses slow motion frequent and effectively, there is also a Mexican Standoff or two
The film is set around war but its also a film about friendship that was impacted by Vietnam so similarities to Deer Hunter (1978) and like Deer Hunter there is a character who loses himself to drugs and gambling like the Walken character
There is a really impressive battle sequence around the 1 hour 30 min that includes a Deer Hunter (1978) type escape from a Prisoner Camp. The rapid editing is effective in producing chaos
I thought about Brian De Palma ‘s 1989 Vietnam film Casualties of War while watching this film, which came out the following years, both surprised me with their emotional depth as Woo similar to De Palma is known for being highly stylized auteurs not known for subtlety
One minor complaint is the score at times seems off and out of synch with the scene’s mood/tone, there are a couple examples, but it is not a huge problem, I also thought the last scene was superfluous and frankly ridiculous
Verdict: HR
The Killer (1989)
Notes:
Chow Yun-fat playing professional killer named Ah Jong while Danny Lee plays Detective Li Ying, and Sally Yeh plays Jennie
Starts with blue tinted shot overlooking the city
2:12 dissolve edits with splendid opening set piece inside Church lit entirely by candlelight
2:23 camera moving 360
3:30 close up on faces
3:52 pop music plays with young attractive woman named Jennie singing at local club
4:45 slow motion and shallow focus
5:15 crazy gun fight with Jong firing with two guns, Woo’s trademark, at the same time and using slow and several great close ups; Jennie shot in the eye from a stray bullet resulting in Jong feeling guilty
8:27 red and blue lighting flooding street with camera moving into lounge where Jennie plays
8:44 close up on Jong with red tint, this sequence has dream like vibe
10:30 Jong saves Jennie from street thugs
14 min weapon buy with undercover police goes bad
16:24 neon lit downtown area at night
17:04 close up on face
19:30 another assassin with injured right hand shows up to offer a job to Jong, they appear to be friends
22 min elliptical editing as Jong has fallen in love with Jennie
23:01 rowing montage taking up most of frame
24:35 low angle shot of Jong taking aim, as music builds with rapid montage
25:45 headshot with sniper rifle circular camera framing the shot
28 min boat chase sequences are pretty amazing to watch
29:56 use of glasses to frame shot a la Strangers on a Train
30:20 another crazy shootout
34:20 symmetry with Jong and Ying on opposite sides of frame in hospital
36:48 slow zoom in on Jong’s face after Ying sings his praises
37:23 interesting framing of the house
38:50 more zooms
40:00 dissolve to inside lounge where Jennie sings
41:10 neon colors in club
44:06 another shootout sequence with remarkable editing and choreography
48:38 free frame
48:50 silhouette image against melancholy blue reminds me of a shot from Michael Mann’s Heat (1995) with the De Niro character standing alone in his expensive house
50:46 classic John Woo shot with the two lead characters, the assassin and the detective, finally face to face with their guns drawn and pointed at each other
51:44 Jennie interrupts the two before they return to having guns against each other
54:18 high angle shot
56:06 hilariously over the top assassin showing up with his entourage and demanding $100,000 to do the hit on Jong
1:02:42 theme music starting up again
1:04:08 shallow focus as Jennie calls out for Jong distracting the police from the Sting
1:12:01 guns in background of frame
1:15:27 POV shot from Jennie’s perspective
1:16:28 close up on faces
1:16:56 Jong and Detective with guns at each other again, Jennie is in the middle of it
1:19:00 another wild shootout
1:22:00 this the equivalent of the Diner scene from Heat (1995) where De Niro and Pacino’s characters make small talk about their lives and work
1:23:10 back to the Church from the opening of the film, filled with candles
1:25:08 symmetry in framing with low angle shot
1:26:12 parallel editing back and forth between Church and Triad hangout
1:33:20 final shootout sequence begins
1:35:05 great slow motion shooting sequence
1:36:00 religious statue in foreground with candles in background throughout the rest of the frame
1:36:06 slow motion statue blown into pieces from gunshots
1:44:14 dissolve
1:44:52 Ying delivers the final bullets to kill the Triad leader as theme music plays in background followed by ending credits
Thoughts:
Arguably John Woo’s best and most iconic film, will have to think about this vs A Better Tomorrow (assuming another film in the study surpasses both)
The bookend use of Church is magnificent with all the candles arranged in patterns, apparently John Woo wanted to be a Priest before discovering his love of movies, perhaps that has nothing to do with why he chooses to use a Church for this scene but it’s one possible explanation. Also, Jong asks Ying to bring him to a hospital if he is killed in the climatic shootout so his eyes can be used by Jennie (I don’t know if this is a real thing or not but doesn’t really matter for the purpose of this film). This gives a sacrificial subtext that can feel religious in nature
I listened to a lot of 90s/early 2000 rap when I was a kid, I still listen to some of those albums here and there but am more into rock and other genres. Raekwon from Wu Tang Clan loosely based his debut solo album “Only Built 4 Cuban Linx” off this film and even incorporates samples from the film into the album. This is actually what got me into John Woo films in the first place
John Woo is known for being ridiculously over the top and you really cannot get more ridiculously over the top than this film and it is glorious. The choreography is amazing, Woo seems to get better and better in this regard with each additional film. The shootout scenes are incredible, some remind me of Westerns but more the shootouts in The Wild Bunch (1969) than say Leone
The two fisted gun shooting is seen in other Woo films like the hilariously over the top Face-Off (1997)
Chow Yun-fat has an effortless cool to him, he plays a lone wolf type here like Alain Delon’s character from Le Samurai (1967) but he is not as icy as Delon’s character
The pacing is perfect setting up the many action/shootout sequences while infusing the perfect amount of narrative, the film never grows stagnant nor does it move along so quickly that you lose interest, yes there are many deaths from the shootouts, but the film has a certain rhythm that maintains interest
Speaking generally this is a “cops vs criminals” film but the main criminal who is really an “anti-hero” is likable and risks his life to protect innocent people who by chance are swept into his violent world. Similar to Heat (1995) the 2 lead characters actually like and respect each other
Woo uses shallow focus in several scenes, he does this in other films as well, he always likes using neon lighting in clubs/bars. There are some nice Michael Mann like shots of the City at night
The narrative and pacing work perfectly with just the right mix of drama and action
Verdict: MP
A Better Tomorrow (1986)
Notes:
Starts with a dream sequence
3 lead performances here are Ti Lung playing a high level Triad member named “Sung Tse Ho”; Leslie Cheung playing his strait laced younger brother “Sung Tse Kit”; and Chow Yun-fat playing Ho’s close friend and business partner “Mark Lee”
1:20 monochrome dream
1:28 Scorsese like triple edit
1:36 extreme close up on eye closing
3:18 counterfeit money montage during opening credits
4:06 iconic image of Chow Yun-fat’s character using a burning a US $100 Bill to light his cigarette
5:50 great blocking and framing in this low angle shot capturing 3 characters in different depths of field
8:25 min playful “buddy, buddy” friendship with Ho and Mark
9:25 Ho visits his brother Kit who is graduating
12:25 nice foreground/background work
12:44 shallow focus with neon colors in background
13:07 Al Pacino reference
16:36 slow zoom out followed by nice dissolve
18 min great editing with montage to build up tension during the meet leading to a shoot out with multiple deaths including police
23:17 Ho and Kit’s father dies after attack
23:47 impressive use of lighting peeking into cave
25:56 another Scorsese triple edit
27:28 slow motion as Mark prepares to carry out the hit
28 min the entire shootout sequence is phenomenal with Chow Yun-fat using the Woo trademark double fisted shooting
30 min nice parallel editing showing the contrast between Ho and his brother Kit; one a criminal the other a police officer
33:16 another impressive use of images over words
34:04 blue lit frame during fight in rain
40 min Kit unfairly punished
44 min a bitter mark with his injury in club and Ho
45:25 close ups of the bother’s faces during emotion sequence where Kit confronts Ho
54:38 beautiful shot of back alley, almost noir like only with color and blue lighting in background where illegal exchange is going on
56:54 Antonioni like shot of Kit and his girlfriend Jackie (played by Emily Chu) both in frame with Kit in background on right and Jackie foreground on left; these characters are physically in frame together but seem isolated showing the disconnect using position to visual show relationship
1:01:45 shaky camera during chase scene
1:03:41 amazing ariel shot and splitting of frame
1:04:32 Raging Bull like image with blood gushing out of nose in slow motion
1:08:05 beautiful ariel shot of city lit up at night
1:12:20 the trademark double fisted guns
1:13:54 nice foreground/background work
1:18:27 shallow focus
1:19:35 great composition and frame in frames
1:20:00 close ups used in back and forth talk
1:22:00 great camera movement and tracking shots
1:26:08 great use of explosions and slow motion images during shootout
1:28:14 blue lighting in background during shootout
1:30:07 close up during Mark’s death
1:32:54 another Scorsese triple edit, and this is the best one which also uses slow motion, it’s a spectacular final death in many ways but the editing is the most impressive aspect of it
1:33:24 low angle shot of the brothers following the final shootout
1:34:26 ends on freeze frame
Thoughts:
This is one of John Woo’s best known films for a reason and it actually even exceeded my expectations as I was impressed by the visual storytelling in many scenes such as the parallel editing of Kit in police force and his criminal brother Ho in prison following a botched business deal. There is a scene with an Antonioni like shot where the positioning of the bodies in the frame speaks volumes about the characters relationship at that moment. There are several sequences with little to no dialogue, there is not really anyone that stands out like a 10 minute sequence but there are several 2 or 3 minute sequences with limited dialogue including the opening scene including the credits
Woo’s use of close up during highly emotionally charged sequences is an effective choice
The editing of the shootouts is the most impressive aspect of the film. I love the tension building montage straight out of Peckinpah’s The Wild Bunch (1969) leading up to for the shootout at the 18 min And as great as that one is I think the one at 28 min mark is even better, as is the final one around 1:28:00 Woo uses Scorsese triple edit more than once
Woo’s trademark double fisted gun shootouts are present here as is his penchant for slow motion in these types of scenes. Chow Yun-fat lighting his cigarette with a burning hundred dollar bill is an iconic image
The mix of drama and action is perfect, and it is this mix is necessary as too little character drama and character development makes it more difficult to become invested in the narrative. The brothers on the opposite side of the law is a trope but one Woo handles well, with strong overall performances from the 3 leads and several emotion scenes are great drama to go with the incredible shootouts that are spaced out over the films 95 min run time
There are not really any cinematically quiet stretches, the camera is movement is impressive along with the editing and choreography of the shootouts
Verdict: MP
Silent Night (2023)
Thoughts:
John Woo’s Hollywood comeback. I watched this in theatres without the benefit of taking notes so this will be a short one. This was basically what I expected, not amazing but worthy of a viewing. It starts with a phenomenon action sequence with the camera low putting you (the viewer) in the middle of the action and the action here being gang warfare. The camera placement along with the sound effects and shaky camera creates an enthralling start to the film. Joel Kinnaman plays Brian, a grieving father whose 7 year old son was murdered by a stray bullet in a gang heavy neighborhood in Los Angeles. The anti-gang unit are not getting results, so he feels compelled to handle things himself. It is all pretty standard revenge thriller components
Unfortunately, after that strong start the film focuses on the grief of the child’s parents, which is obviously necessary for the story but just goes on for too long. It is repetitive with Brian walking around in constant anger regardless of his wife’s attempts to help him. It does pick up again in the middle and definitely at the end with some more thrilling sequences
It’s a 104 minute film that would have worked better as an 85 or 90 minute film
The lack of dialogue is a bit of a gimmick, I do wonder if a different actor would have helped, I am not familiar with Kinnaman, but his performance is rather one note
Woo proves he still has his technical skills intact even if the creativity is not really there
Verdict: R
@James-Have you seen The Informer(2019). Looks similar to this film but has better reviews.
@Malith – I have not, impressive cast
Last Hurrah for Chivalry (1979)
Notes:
Starts with cartoon figures of kung-fu warriors appearing superimposed onto book pages flipping along with song during opening credits
3:15 starts in elegant restaurant for wedding of a wealthy scholar named Kao Pang played by actor Lau Kong
4 min kung-fu master, Pak played by Hoi Sang Lee shows up at wedding and kills numerous people
Kao ultimately hires two mercenaries, Chang San (Wai Pak) and Tsing Yi (Damian Lau)
5:38 two rows of fighters in foreground
5:52 nice frame in frame
5:48 series of
6:04 surveillance angle shot
6:33 pigs head covered in blood is thrown onto the floor
7:10 “I’ve always loved you and trusted you” “But Pak Chung-tong gave me even more money” hilarious
7:20 fighting for several minutes with impressive choreography
14:16 rapid zooms used a couple of times so far
14:48 vibrant use of primary colors
16:51 great framing using flowers in foreground, followed by zoom
18:26 frame in frame
18:58 purple and blue dominate mise en scene
19:39 quick zoom in with melodic music
27:20 start of another strong sequence of combat
34:24 POV shot through window
35 min Woo holds a two-shot with Kao and his girlfriend
36:48 two-shot showing Kao and girlfriend in same frame with Kao blurred out and then in the next frame Kao is visible with his girlfriend blurred out in the background of the frame
38:28 wipe edit
38:42 another wipe edit
40:25 dead bodies scattered throughout scene
42:50 zoom in frame in frame as men on opposite sides of frame as begin sword fight, a Western standoff vibe here
46:26 slow motion
47:47 slow motion
50:28 row of five men drinking in unison
54:06 two man team fighting in unison during rainfall
58:44 high angle shot upon saving a man from hanging himself
1:00:47 waterfall to close up on hands of woman playing a string instrument
1:01:10 frame in frame
1:02:30 perfect symmetry
1:03:37 Pak training dominating two men in foreground of frame and moving to middle ground
1:04:40 nice composition with two-shot and waterfall in background of frame
1:05:12 slow motion set to diegetic instrument
1:07:17 more masterful sword play
1:08:16 masterful editing and slow motion
10:12 great framing, use of symmetry
1:13:13 trapped door style cage just falls into place
1:13:53 nice overhead shot of fighting inside the cage, amazing camera work
1:15:55 brown and white décor
1:16:55 superhuman speed
1:17:40 incredible swordplay
1:20:50 great mise en scene with candles on top of red tables
1:27:57 shallow focus
1:30:58 nice two shot, foreground/background
1:34:24 death by spear
1:36:00 standoff approaches
1:37:09 over the shoulder POV flying dagger that is avoided with crazy and unrealistic flip
1:39:16 zoom out reveals great two-shot
1:41:56 another POV from flying dagger
1:44:42 great editing during final fight, a little like The Good The Bad And The Ugly (1966)
Thoughts:
John Woo with a Wuxia film, a staple for Hong Kong Cinema. Woo pays homage to one of his mentors Chang Cheh, known himself for Wuxia and Kung-Fu. Admittingly I am a relative novice regarding this, I looked up the difference between the two and learned that Kung-Fu is the actual fighting itself while Wuxia films have the fighting elements but with additional components such as fantasy, or the use of historical settings. Personally, I have seen the following: The Assassin (2015) directed by Hou Hsiao-Hsien, and Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon (2000) directed by Ang Lee. Additionally, during my Wong Kar Wai Study, I watched Ashes of Time (1994) and The Grandmaster (2013); I am not sure if they are regarded as Wuxia or perhaps more of a genre blend
Woo would later move to more action/crime films with contemporary as opposed to historical settings
Woo uses 2:35:1 which I liked with the impressive choreography, the entire film is basically an extended sword high with occasional time spend on story/narrative
The frequent zooms create a chaotic atmosphere matching with the films breakneck speed, not a single quiet moment, the mood is consistent throughout the film
Sound effects are comically bad at times but don’t really do much damage especially given the over the top nature of these films
Verdict: HR
@James – You need to watch Hero (2002) ASAP!
@Harry – thanks for the recommendation, yeah I have had that one on my to watch list for a while now
John Woo 1st American film in 20 Years is coming out this December
https://www.polygon.com/23900521/silent-night-john-woo-trailer-hell-yeah
John Woo on upcoming film named “Silent Night”
“Very interesting movie. The whole movie is without dialogue. It allowed me to use visuals to tell the story, to tell how the character feels. We are using music instead of language. And the movie is all about sight and sound. The budget was a little tight, and the schedule was tight, but it made me change my working style. Usually, for a big movie, a studio movie, we shoot a lot of coverage, then leave it to the cutting room. But in this movie, I tried to combine things without doing any coverage shots. I had to force myself to use a new kind of technique. Some scenes were about two or three pages, but I did it all in one shot.”
@James Trapp- Sounds promising- it has been a minute for John Woo… maybe this is his Fury Road. Wouldn’t that be amazing?
@Drake – Yeah, I want to do a John Woo Study. The poblem is I have not been able to get The Killer 1989) and A Better Tomorrow (1986). I can get the majority of his best films, but those 2 are essential so hopefully I can track them down soon. I would basically want to do all the Woo films you have in the archives plus I would add Last Hurrah for Chivalry (1979) and A Better Tomorrow 2
Why do you count Red Cliff 1 and Red Cliff 2 as two films?
@Malith- fair question, perhaps a change when I update some of the Red Cliff pages. Thanks
I just watched A better tomorrow for the first time and I gotta say, I’m pleasantly surprised by this film. I think its style and the vulnerability that Woo allows his action heroes to display onscreen (which heavily contrasts what American action directors were doing in the 80s) more than make up for a screenplay that could’ve definitely been more polished. I can certainly understand why Chow Yun-fat’s character became so iconic, he does a great job here. I’m probably leaning R/HR for now, but HR doesn’t sound like a stretch to me at all.
I’m gonna have to keep digging in his filmography, because, if I’m being honest, I didn’t expect to like this film. I watched The killer and Face/off over a decade ago and didn’t enjoy them that much at that time, so I’m very excited to revisit them now and see if I’ve changed my mind.
@DavidO. – I love The Killer (1989) I listen to many music genres including rap (although much less now than in High School and College) Raekwon and Ghostface from Wu Tang Clan are huge fans of John Woo films and loosely based the 1995 album Only Build 4 Cuban Linx off of The Killer (1989). The album basically is a concept album telling crime stories based around the plot of The Killer (1989) and incorporates some of the dialogue into the tracks.
https://nostalgiaking.com/2017/08/02/raekwon-meets-the-killer/
I know, they were the reason why I gave Hong Kong action movies a chance XD. Same thing happened to me with Bruce Lee films, I watched a couple of them when I became obsessed with Enter the Wu Tang (this was around 2011-2012) and I didn’t enjoy them all that much. I don’t know, maybe I would appreciate them more if I gave them another chance.
@DavidO. – I have tried a few of the Martial Arts films as well and was not all that into them. I do like some of the Wuxia films such as Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2000) and The Assassin (2015)
However, The Killer (1989) is not really martial arts and definitely not Wuxia but rather an action crime thriller closer to a Michael Mann film with some Tarantino over the top violence. Face Off (1997) I have been meaning to revisit for a while. A Better Tomorrow (1986) I’ve only seen once but was very impressed, also want to revisit that one as well.
I just watched The killer and it pains me to say that my opinion hasn’t changed dramatically. I mean, I liked it more than I did in the past, but I still have some major issues with it. I appreciate Woo’s voice and it obviously cements his status as an auteur. He brings a lot of interesting things to the table, but his mannerisms are so excessive and so silly at points that it becomes hard for me to take the film seriously. It has style to spare, obviously. The doves. The religious symbolism. And the freeze frames. And the dissolves. And the slow motion. And the aggressive editing. It’s bold filmmaking. It’s also way too much. It kind of reminded me of those singers that tend to oversing every single note. I also think that the relationship between the two protagonists could have been mapped out better. Like I said, I appreciate the fact that he’s unapologetically being himself and I enjoyed quite a few things about the film, but I don’t necessarily equate more with better. I found A better tomorrow to be a more balanced and satisfying work as a whole, even if (or maybe due to the fact that) it is more stylistically restrained.
I’m still very interested in checking out his other Hong Kong films, especially given the fact that Tony Leung stars in two of them. I mean, that’s always a plus for me.
@DavidO. – Just saw this now, where did you watch? I am curious as I have had trouble finding The Killer (1989)
@Drake – Have you seen Woo’s film, Last Hurrah for Chivalry (1979)?
It has an upcoming Criterion release and only 5 reviews on RT, with a 100 rating but again just 5 reviews.
@James Trapp- I have not, was not on my radar at all actually
@Drake – from what I have read it is more of a straight up Wuxia film than the Hong Kong action/gangster movies he became known for later on.
@James Trapp- Sounds interesting- keep me posted if/when you get to it
Drake,
Excited for Criterion releasing Infernal Affairs Triogy this upcoming Tuesday. The series is directed by Andrew Lau and Alan Mak. I was wondering who are some of the great Hong Kong directors aside from WKW and John Woo?
@James Trapp- Those would be the big two. Pretty big gap after those two as far as my knowledge goes at least. I think maybe Johnnie To next- maybe Stephen Chow next.
I think The Killer is his best work, and the most influential
So I clicked on this link probably about 30 minutes ago then had to put my phone away for a while, and when I came back I confused “The Killer” with “The Killing” from Stanley Kubrick, and thought “The Killing as Kubrick’s best film? And his most influential? What the hell?” I was very glad to see that was not the case when I found out this was Woo’s page.
will noah baumbach be soon on this list? He’s no visual master but he is one heck of a writer.
@m — yes indeed– Baumbach is coming up soon. I do think Marriage Story is his best work (certainly strongest visually) and I put more of an emphasis on non-recent work for this list. I’d rather let recent films sit a little and soak in…. so Baumbach’s greatest achievement for the purposes of this list is Squid and the Whale.