Borzage. Out of Frank Borzage’s ninety (90) or so feature films (like many during the silent era, many are lost) I’ve able to catch with eighty or nine. Five are worthy of the archives certainly all possess share a genre (romantic melodrama) and superior craftsmanship. His strengths are those four films that land in the top 100 of the respective decade. Now, none of them made the top 500 of all-time (a weakness for sure) but there’s a real consistency in his work even if it’s obvious he never made a Sunrise or anything like that.
Best film: Seventh Heaven. I don’t think there’s a massive distinction here between one and two, two and three, and three and four.

total archiveable films: 5
top 100 films: 0
top 500 films: 0
top 100 films of the decade: 4 (Seventh Heaven, Street Angel, A Farewell To Arms, Man’s Castle)

most overrated: Borzage doesn’t really have one. I think Mortal Storm is like #2000 on the TSPDT consensus list and – that’s fine with me. It’s not a fantastic film. Borzage only has one film in the TSPDT top 1000 and that’s Seventh Heaven at #867. That’s a good spot I think. I may be slightly higher. Man’s Castle is at #1523. It’s definitely not overrated there.
most underrated : Street Angel. The visuals and superior lighting (even for a film that doesn’t have a lot of love on the internet from 1928) here speak for themselves. It can’t find a spot in the TSPDT top 2000 and that’s just flat wrong. It’s close to Seventh Heaven in quality.


gem I want to spotlight : Man’s Castle
- Features Borzage’s trademark heart-warming well-earned melodrama
- Stunning romantic tale of an extraordinarily sweet Loretta Young and a streetwise tough-on-the-outside but all heart inside Spencer Tracy in a great early role for him
- Harsh poverty depression era romance
- Hard to find because of the hays code- there’s a pregnant girl here out of wedlock and even a first date skinny-dipping scene
- Tracy is a streetwise tour-guide man of the world who responds to repeated sounds of a train (his way of saying “I’m a rambler”) and an open blue sky (saying “no one woman can hold me down”),etc
- He’s gregarious, large and charming
- Graceful tracking shot of Young looking longingly at a stove in a window to buy
- Clearly Borzage is his own artist (has much in common with Seventh Heaven, Street Angel and even A Farewell to Arms but he’s also influenced by Murnau’s Sunrise—clearly the narrative is influenced by the film but also a superimposed sliding background during a tracking shot is as well
- Great scene of Tracy on stilts showing his character by getting an autograph for a kid
- With love in his eyes he repeatedly calls her skinny
- Devastating ending as the rambling man who is so tough breaks down—well earned
- Final crane shot tracking out on the two together is a great conclusion
- Highly Recommend – top 10 of the year quality

stylistic innovations/traits:
- Worked in romance and melodrama (which may speak to why he’s not as well regarded today as Whale, Browning or some others that worked in genre)- with often a sort of magical realism touch. I see some influence on Powell and Pressburger’s work in the 1940’s (specifically A Matter of Life and Death)
- Won the best director Academy award twice in the first five years
- Borzage’s use of lighting is certainly a trademark and highlight
- Known for some really nice fluid camerawork and crane shots- some tracking, some just elevating the camera giving certain scenes that almost mystical god’s eye view approach
- Like Cukor he’s known for his worked with actresses- Janet Gaynor, Helen Hayes
- I mention it above but Murnau is an influence- Sunrise specifically even if they were contemporaries
top 10
- Seventh Heaven
- Street Angle
- Man’s Castle
- A Farewell To Arms
- The Mortal Storm

By year and grades
1927- Seventh Heaven | HR |
1928- Street Angel | HR |
1932- A Farewell To Arms | HR |
1933- Man’s Castle | HR |
1940- The Mortal Storm | R |
*MP is Masterpiece- top 1-3 quality of the year film
MS is Must-see- top 5-6 quality of the year film
HR is Highly Recommend- top 10 quality of the year film
R is Recommend- outside the top 10 of the year quality film but still in the archives
[…] 174. Frank Borzage […]
My ranking of Borzage`s films that I`ve seen:
1. 7th Heaven HR/MS
2. Street Angel R/HR
3. Man`s Castle R/HR