- Anthony Minghella parlayed the artistic and financial success of 1996 The English Patient into this large-canvas, picturesque revenge thriller
- A meditation of infatuation and envy
- To me this is sacred text- Patricia Highsmith’s work. Ripley is such an all-time great character. He’s intelligent- a sociopath. It is hard not to bring about comparisons of another Highsmith novel adaptation – Hitchcock’s Strangers on a Train (1951) and the previous adaptation of this particular novel, 1960’s Purple Noon from René Clément
- The opening credit sequence is very inspired- piano keys and fracturing of the images of Matt Damon’s Tom Ripley

another reason to recall Hitchcock- few auteurs before or since have cared as much about the artistry of the opening titles
- Wonderful text and subtext the sexual dynamics between Damon’s Ripley and Jude Law’s Dickie Greenleaf—the bath scene, Clark Kent glasses on and off Superman scene, many mirror and reflection scenes of Ripley already visually trying to capture and possess Greenleaf’s identity

Wonderful text and subtext the sexual dynamics between Damon’s Ripley and Jude Law’s Dickie Greenleaf
- On the train profile/Agnes Varda/Bergman shot. And then the blending of the faces off the reflection in the piano

On the train profile/Agnes Varda/Bergman shot. And then the blending of the faces off the reflection in the piano (below)

visual motif- themes of identity
- It is a who’s who of young talented actors—I mean the entire ensemble is impeccable. If it weren’t for Tom Cruise in Magnolia I may give Jude Law the best supporting actor award in 1999 for this performance (far stronger than the Purple Noon Dickie Greenleaf). Law leaps off the screen—spellbinding. This may be Damon’s best as well—he’s hauntingly good. Gwyneth Paltrow —sublime and so on to the rest of the cast. PSH—haha. He’s throwing 110 miles per hour in every scene (“how’s the peeping, tommy?”). If you had asked me to pick the actor that would most dominate the 2000’s based on this film I would’ve been wrong and picked Law and Paltrow from this I think – had no idea it would be Damon/Blanchett and PSH with the stronger decade.
- Many critics lament the loss of Jude Law about an hour into the film (there’s another 80 minutes left). I see that. I just think it turns into a different movie at that point. But it is hard to say it’s as good without him. It has a gangster film Goodfellas-like arc—the rise and romance of Italy/Law/singing/jazz. It’s intoxicating— then violence and aftermath– a fall. The swoon is always going to be better.
- Quick homage to Fellini La Dolce Vita and 8 ½ with the music as Damon walks up on the beach
- On-location shooting in Italy here- masterful. Music, clothes (a sartorialist’s dream)- a feast for the senses when you include the score by Gabriel Yared and John Seale (both would work on The English Patient as well—Seale would go on to do Mad Max Fury Road in 2015)

east for the senses when you include the score by Gabriel Yared and John Seale (both would work on The English Patient as well—Seale would go on to do Mad Max Fury Road in 2015)
- The overhead boat shot after the murder

a standout shot in a film filled with them
- It is like David Lean directing Hitchcock—closest I can think of is Powell directing Peeping Tom in 1960 a little
- A wallop of an ending. Minghella brilliantly carries the audio of the Peter character over into the next scene with Damon’s Ripley sitting there alone in a little hall or mirrors gorgeous shot.

A wallop of an ending. Minghella brilliantly carries the audio of the Peter character over into the next scene with Damon’s Ripley sitting there alone in a little hall or mirrors gorgeous shot.
- A Must-See film
@James –
Purple Noon – HR/MS (leaning MS)
The American Friend – MS
The Talented Mr. Ripley – MS/MP
Ripley’s Game – R
Ripley Underground is not as strong source material as the others and I haven’t heard of the lead actor so I’m not surprised
@Harry – nice, I still need to see Ripley’s Game. Due for rewatch of The American Friend, I have only seen it once but was impressed.
I do like how Purple Noon, The American Friend, The Talented Ripley, and Ripley (which I am going to watch soon but have looked at some of the shots) each have their own visual style
@Harry, @James Trapp- Ripley actors ranked?
I would go:
1. Delon 5
2. Damon 5
3. Hopper 5
Haven`t seen Malkovich or Scott- any good?
@Drake – I’ve finished the series – here are my thoughts:
Patricia Highsmith’s’s The Talented Mr. Ripley has already been made into two excellent films – but the novels second remake, despite being directed by someone who is primary a screenwriter – towers over all the Highsmith adaptations that came before it. A total onslaught of gorgeous photography and lighting that never falters over eight hours – that’s Satantango levels of dedication (except this has a much lower shot length so counts for more), there must be over a hundred wall-art quality shots. The vibrancy of Italian beaches and cities is traded for the most exquisite noir photography possible. I have three Robert Elswit films in my personal top 100 and this is more photographically stunning (though not overall stronger) than those three, he’s a genius level DP in my eyes now.
Andrew Scott as Ripley… not the ideal casting (I’d prefer him to be a similar age to Dickie for some of the plot mechanics) but he is perfectly off. Closer to Gyllenhaal from Nightcrawler than previous takes on Tom Ripley. Scott is particularly great when the tension heats up and the character gets to really work on his schemes. Johnny Flynn is no Jude Law and Dakota Fanning is no Gwynneth Paltrow… but these are convincing performances that work for the characters. This adaptation is more faithful to the book and quite different tonally to the Minghella film. Eliot Sumner takes the Freddie Miles character in a completely different direction to Phillip Seymour Hoffman and excels in their few tense scenes. Also great seeing John Malkovich setting up a part that might get more use if Zaillian adapts the sequels.
I had high expectations for this but didn’t expect to the best photographed film of the 2020s. A masterpiece.
@Harry- wow – thanks for sharing this
@Drake – have you had a look yet?
@Harry- Hey – have not yet still- I do think I’m getting to it this month
@Drake – I must ask again, have you had a look yet? I’m dying to hear your thoughts on the cinematography and huge win from a non auteur….
@Harry- I have not, I will this summer for sure. Someone talked me into watching Succession – and there is much to admire there- it is just taking a long time to get through it.
@Drake – if you had not started yet perhaps Declan’s excellent page might expedite the process: https://scenebygreen.com/2024/09/11/ripley-2024/ the beauty of the series really speaks for itself and we all know how good the source material is.
@Harry – I was able to catch Ripley this summer – yes
@Harry – you make a strong case, I will probably watch myself soon
Just curious how would you rate the following 4 films?
Purple Noon (1960)
The American Friend (1977)
The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999)
Ripley’s Game (2002)
Apparently there is a 2005 film titled “Ripley Under Ground” but it has brutal reviews and just looks terrible so I am not including this one
There’s a new Ripley miniseries coming soon to Netflix shot in black and white by Robert Elswit (There Will Be Blood, Punch Drunk Love, Magnolia etc…) – Andrew Scott as Ripley.
@Harry- thanks- good share- this one was not on my radar. I’m a sucker for anything Ripley
@Drake – I’m planning on reading all five of Highsmith’s Ripley novels soon, I have four on my shelf at the moment – have you read any?
@Harry- I have, it’s been a decade- but I own and have read them all
@Drake – do you have any thoughts on the three that haven’t been adapted into films?
@Drake – the trailer has come out: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0ri2biYLeaI
This looks visually stunning and stands out from the other adaptations, very exciting.
@Harry- I’m in on this
@Drake – have you started this series yet?
@Harry- Not yet- on my short list here. How about you?
@Drake – Just two episodes so far – I can definitely say that is is cinema not TV…..
@Harry- thank you for the update
“If you had asked me to pick the actor that would most dominate the 2000’s based on this film I would’ve been wrong and picked Law and Paltrow from this I think”- by this do you mean that it’s Law and Paltrow who give the best performance in the movie?
@M*A*S*H- Nope- just saying I thought their star trajectory was such- sort of a combination of how good they are in this movie (both superb), good looks, star potential.
[…] The Talented Mr. Ripley – Minghella […]