best film: The Graduate from Mike Nichols is the sole 1967 film on my top 100 of all-time. I’m often asked if I have a bias against comedies (I’m lower on Chaplin, Wilder, Duck Soup relative to their positions on the TSPDT) and if it isn’t Wes Anderson- it is The Graduate that I often bring up as a counterpoint. It is simply one of the most ambitiously directed comedies of all-time. It opens on the famous long take in the airport (even Tarantino pays homage in his opening of Jackie Brown), some of the editing sequences are spectacular (the montage of the Hoffman/Bancroft affair set to Simon and Garfunkel is a standout) and telephoto lens camerawork from The Graduate is the example I use most often when talking about that stylistic choice tied to technology (whether it be used in The Wild Bunch or Tootsie- both coming later).

The Graduate opens with the famous long take in the airport (even Tarantino pays homage in his opening of Jackie Brown)

one of those justifiably famous and inventive shots

Nichols is making big stylistic choices for almost the entirety of the 106-minute running time- one of the most famous telephoto lens shots here with Hoffman just endlessly running in place
most underrated: Cool Hand Luke and In Cold Blood are both underrated. I was surprised to find out Richard Brooks’ film isn’t on the TSPDT top 1000 at all and I’ve always thought Cool Hand Luke deserves more credit (#805 on the consensus list). Sure, director Stuart Rosenberg isn’t Kubrick, but I find nearly every other element of the film to be superb and find the film, in general, closer to the greatest works of non-auteur cinema than just some above average film with excellent performances by Paul Newman and George Kennedy (who won the Oscar for supporting). The music is by Lalo Schifrin (Mission Impossible, Bullitt, Dirty Harry) and it’s shot by Conrad Hall (Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, Fat City, American Beauty, Road to Perdition)- both are absolute masters.

the tears on the window shot from In Cold Blood– a shot just about every cinephile knows or will come to know. I rarely single out cinematographers (I should probably do more) but 1967 is an amazing year for DP Conrad Hall. He’d be one of the best for the next 30+ years but here, in one year, you have breakthrough work in both In Cold Blood (his achievement here is often given more artistic credit than director Richard brooks) and Cool Hand Luke
most overrated: Mouchette from Bresson is on the TSPDT list at #178 and it didn’t make my top 500. This makes for consecutive years for Bresson “winning” this overrated category- Au Hasard Balthazar took honors in 1966. I hope with my next Bresson study I’m looking back and laughing at my ignorance—but for now- I just don’t see how you put it at #178.
gem I want to spotlight: Point Blank from John Boorman
- Point Blank is magnificent– pulpy, revenge subject matter meets high art direction like Breathless, Shoot the Piano Player, Bob le Flambeur– clearly influenced by the French New Wave and Melville (kind of,sort of, New Wave) here (in terms of high art meets crime genre)—which was of course influenced by American film noir—the spectacular use of architecture though actually is closer to Resnais and Antonioni

Los Angeles very much a character in the film—Boorman insisted on location scouting himself
- David Thomson writes about Lee Marvin’s character being a ghost—I don’t see it—but there are a few scenes that support that—there’s the constant reference it to being a dream Lee Marvin is having. He is shot, then gets up and he honestly doesn’t seem to be injured. His wife doesn’t talk directly to him – she’s almost like talking to herself with him there in the scene like Sixth Sense or something—even later Angie Dickinson’s character says “you died at Alcatraz alright”
- Nick Schager Slant Magazine- “What makes Point Blank so extraordinary is Boorman’s virtuoso use of such unconventional avant-garde stylistics to saturate the proceedings with a classical noir mood of existential torpor and romanticized fatalism.”– well said
- Background architecture as character— silent storytelling, non-linear narrative construction, the use of open space
- The entire heist is done in the opening cross-cut flashback—it’s a bit disorienting until you get on its wavelength

Walking the hallways of LAX—the use of color and lighting- -gob-smackingly beautiful. It influences Jackie Brown and Tarantino shot there as well (1967 a big year for Tarantino apparently with Jackie Brown homages here and in The Graduate). The scene is great not just because of the visuals but the audio— Boorman users the sound of Marvin walking and overlaps it non-diegetically onto the intercut scene and the following scene

Influences everything today from Refn, to Skyfall to Atomic Blonde – here Marvin beats the hell out of a guy in front of a neon light with the lights moving on Marvin’s face
- The high-rise exteriors and interiors—fabulous – using structure to block the frame
- Angie Dickinson is in yellows—her sofa, cabinets, robes—drenched in it
- Yellow and red pillars in the parking structure
- the L.A. Rain basin set piece viaduct sequence- used later in Grease, Terminator 2, Drive
- canted angles, very expressionist and flashback heavy—I see an influence here on You Were Never Really Here and Lynne Ramsay in general
- avant-garde in its use of structures and angles
trends and notables:
- 1967 is most notable for the beginning of The New Hollywood- a changing of the guard in American film. For roughly a decade leading up to 1967, the epic, the musical, the children’s film, the all-star ensemble, Stanley Kramer, the older generation of actors/directors have dominated. That changes here in 1967. The American “New Wave” if you will, or New Hollywood would run from roughly 1967 to 1979 (usually ending with Coppola’s Apocalypse Now in 1979, or Michael Cimino’s Heaven’s Gate in 1980). It is probably the apex for American cinema. In a lot of ways, it was just the US catching up to what the French and Italians were doing for nearly a decade—avant-garde, youth movement, chic, Rock and Roll, political, controversial material (nudity/violence/language/themes) . The filmmakers making the best films in 1967 here- Arthur Penn, Stuart Rosenberg, and Mike Nichols- wouldn’t necessarily be the auteurs to lead this movement- but still- it’s impossible to deny that The Graduate and Bonnie and Clyde weren’t important as far as a cultural movement and box office (The Graduate was #1, Bonnie and Clyde #5) …. let alone as stand-alone important artistic works.

Bonnie and Clyde‘s genius slow-motion finale — preceding The Wild Bunch

the ending to The Graduate is crucial… if they go off happily-ever-after so much of the subversion is lost.
- 1967 and Godard’s Weekend really marks the end of the French New Wave. French cinema is going strong (it really always has—1967 alone we have Tati, Melville, Bresson with big films)—but his famous tracking shot (such a fitting end) is the last time either he or Truffaut really shake the ground. Truffaut would go on to make good films in the 1970’s, but 1967 marks the last time Godard (or Demy) would have a top 10 of the year quality film.

you hate to see Godard’s run, or the French New Wave, come to an end… but if it had to end– I’m thrilled we have one of the great tracking shots in cinema history to mark the occasion

It isn’t just the end of Godard as one of the best directors on the planet– this is the last time Demy would be of real relevance as well (neither auteur would ever have a top 10 film again)- this shot from The Young Girls of Rochefort
- It must have felt like Mike Nichols was taking over the world in 1967 after The Graduate and Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? the year before (he’s 36 in 1967).
- Altman and Scorsese have their first archiveable films. Altman is already 42, a television veteran and his 1967 film Countdown doesn’t even really do much more than hint at what would come later in MASH in 1970 and beyond. For Scorsese, he’s just 25 and Who’s That Knocking At My Door? is a rough (pretty rough) draft for 1973’s Mean Streets
- Altman and Scorsese aren’t alone for first archiveable films for auteurs- La collectionneuse here for Eric Rohmer and Ken Russell’s first time in the archives with the end of the Harry Palmer/Michael Caine trilogy Billion Dollar Brain
- Beatty had been around for few years but 1967 would bring us the first archiveable films for Dustin Hoffman and Faye Dunaway amongst others- these two would be instant stars- I mean no waiting in line. The next year or two he’s in the best picture winner and she’s starring opposite Steve McQueen. Donald Sutherland is maybe two steps below them in terms of notoriety for The Dirty Dozen and it would take a few more years until 1969’s Best Picture winner for Jon Voight to be a household name but he does get his first archiveable film here in 1967 for Hour of the Gun. Martin Sheen is horrifying as the terrorist on the subway in The Incident and young Harvey Keitel starts his career alongside Scorsese of course in Who’s That Knocking At My Door?
best performance male I hate this. Dustin Hoffman in The Graduate and Paul Newman in Cool Hand Luke are both transcendent performances. Each would stand alone as the single best performance in many years. If forced to choose, I’d give the slight nod to Hoffman I guess here though it kills me even typing that out. These are two great actors (both in my top 20 all-time for male actors) and this is their respective best work. Newman is a massive star already and in 1967 he adds Hombre (very underrated film) in the the mix as well. You pair these two 1967 films with Hud, Harper, and The Hustler (something in marketing with the H’s—I don’t know the story there) and you have a pretty amazing actor-as-auteur, anti-hero study. Lee Marvin had a big 1967 – he leads The Dirty Dozen but he’s really here as a mention in this category for his work as Walker in Point Blank. Alain Delon is perfect as the ice-cold killer in Le Samouraï. Behind them, I’d put Warren Beatty in Bonnie and Clyde – a complex role, impotence, violence. After Beatty I’d go with Sidney Poitier for his work in In the Heat of the Night. Poor Poitier is a great actor but just wasn’t in many strong movies- and even this is a stretch here- I do not like going this far out of the top 10 films of the year. Still, Poitier’s work here is superior to the work of co-star Rod Steiger who actually won the Oscar in 1967 over all of these other performances. The last mention is for Mifune in Samurai Rebellion. Like Marcello Mastroianni in La Notte or Le notti bianche without Fellini, this is a big role to show Mifune could do it without Kurosawa.

if you want to talk Paul Newman- Cool Hand Luke is probably where you need to start

Dustin Hoffman as Ben Braddock- he’d go on to win multiple Academy Awards– but would never top his first archiveable film

Alain Delon is perfect as the steely hitman Jef Costello

a look at Melville’s meticulously designed interiors– from the slate walls to the sheets on the bed

Samurai Rebellion from Kobayashi- it is a gorgeous final showdown —the camera is active throughout the battle and we have some great angled shots. It also has a repeated shot (film form) from the very opening when the two characters (then they were friends or co-workers at least) were testing weapons (Mifune is a weapons dealer basically)—there is such reverence and respect between these two reluctant warriors. It’s an ambitious final 20 minutes- very sad—well choreographed
best performance female: Anne Bancroft doesn’t have the screen time Hoffman does in The Graduate (I’m not even sure she has as much as Katharine Ross) but she makes the most of those scenes and to me is the pretty easy choice here. Faye Dunaway is every bit Beatty’s equal- probably better- in Bonnie and Clyde. Catherine Deneuve continues to do superb work—1964, 1965, and 1967– mentions in this category as one of the year’s best. She’s very worthy here in 1967 with both Belle de Jour and The Young Girls of Rochefort. It isn’t on the level of Bancroft but I do think co-star Katharine Ross slides into the fourth and final slot here for 1967.

it is the Catherine Deneuve-era– here in Bunuel’s Belle de Jour. Deneuve is often stoic, and finds roles and auteurs that help accentuate her strengths

here again in another pairing with Demy
top 10
- The Graduate
- Cool Hand Luke
- Point Blank
- Bonnie and Clyde
- Weekend
- Le Samourai
- Playtime
- Belle De Jour
- Samurai Rebellion
- The Young Girls of Rochefort

the memorable opening of Belle de Jour

Jacques Tati’s visual design and comic genius on display Playtime…

…both a big canvas (shot on 65mm) and extremely detailed

Schlesinger’s Far from the Madding Crowd is a film that falls outside of the top 10 of the year that deserves attention and study

Julie Christie is excellent, you can’t take your eyes of Terence Stamp, and they’re supported by Peter Finch and Alan Bates as well — both doing really good work
Archives, Directors, and Grades
| 2 or 3 Things I Know About Her- Godard | R |
| Accident – Losey | R |
| Barefoot in the Park- Saks | R |
| Bedazzled – Donen | R |
| Belle De Jour- Bunuel | MS |
| Billion Dollar Brain – K. Russell | R |
| Bonnie and Clyde- Penn | MP |
| Camelot- Logan | R |
| Cool Hand Luke- Rosenberg | MP |
| Countdown – Altman | R |
| Death Rides a Horse – Petroni | R |
| Far From the Madding Crowd- Schlesinger | HR |
| Guess Who Is Coming To Dinner- Kramer | R |
| Hombre-Ritt | HR |
| Hour of the Gun- J. Sturges | R |
| In Cold Blood- R. Brooks | HR |
| In the Heat of the Night- Jewison | HR |
| La Collectionneuse – Rohmer | R |
| Le Samourai- Melville | MS |
| Mouchette- Bresson | HR |
| Oedipus Rex – Pasolini | R/HR |
| Playtime- Tati | MS |
| Point Blank – Boorman | MP |
| Samurai Rebellion – Kobayashi | MS |
| Spider Baby or, the Maddest Story Ever Told – Jack Hill | R |
| The Dirty Dozen- Aldrich | R |
| The Fireman’s Ball- Forman | R |
| The Graduate- M. Nichols | MP |
| The Hellbenders – Corbucci | R |
| The Honey Pot – Mankiewicz | R |
| The Incident – Peerce | R |
| The Jungle Book- Reitherman | R |
| The Producers- M. Brooks | HR |
| The St. Valentine’s Day Massacre- Corman | HR |
| The Taming of the Shrew- Zeffirelli | R |
| The Two of Us- Berri | R |
| The Young Girls of Rochefort- Demy | HR |
| Two For the Road- Donen | |
| Wait Until Dark- Young | R |
| Weekend- Godard | MS |
| Who’s That Knocking At My Door – Scorsese | R |
| Will Penny- Gries | R |
| You Only Life Twice – Gilbert | R |
*MP is Masterpiece- top 1-3 quality of the year film
MS is Must-See- top 5-6 quality of the year film
HR is Highly Recommend- top 10 quality of the year film
R is Recommend- outside the top 10 of the year quality film but still in the archives
It’s quite hilarious to me that James Caan is so often paired alongside louder volcanic female roles. There are so many of these. Shirley Knight in The Rain People, Sally Kellerman in Slither, Marsha Mason in Cinderella Liberty, Barbra Streisand in Funny Lady, Kathy Bates in Misery, Bette Midler in For the Boys. All of them are Oscar nominated actresses. It’s not a flex but just an observation. But I think he gives the best performance in each and every one of them. He is the one who gives the films a moral centre which is a much harder thing to do. This is why I said The Godfather is very much an against type role for him. He never gives off any strength in the earlier sections of Misery. He is totally vulnerable and hopeless in these scenes.
But throughout the film he gains inner strength and it is he who does all the planning and uses his wit to try to escape. It’s a fascinating character arc. I mean Michael Mann is good at giving insights into the personal lives of his heroes and their flaws. But almost all of them are fully formed. And there isn’t much of a character arc to speak of. Caan is a very cool actor. I don’t think he is fully formed yet in his early roles like Red Line 7000, El Dorado, Countdown but around the time of Brian’s Song he is fully there. The Rain People is of course before this and it’s quite a unique role which is perfect for his 1960’s babyface persona.
A Bridge Too Far is perhaps the best indicator of this. Both him and Redford are leviating with stardom and cool in this film but do have dramatic scenes later. I mean how about following up The Godfather with Cinderella Liberty, Slither, and The Gambler. These are very indie type films and not at all star vehicles. He did do some of these these the following year/s like Rollerball, The Killer Elite, and Harry and Walter Go to New York. It’s the 1970’s so even these action star vehicles have a lot of dramatic material earlier in the films. I think we spend like 40 minutes in The Killer Elite with him basically being injured and recuperating. I love it. This is not at all possible today with the film executives.
Some risky casting choices here with Rydell as well. Not just the likes of John Wayne, Steve McQueen, and James Caan. Marsha Mason in Cinderella Liberty. Bette Midler in The Rose. Launching both of their film careers. And Mel Gibson in The River somewhat. It’s his first role in an American film. It’s probably the best dramatic role of Gibson’s career as well but he is too stiff an actor and doesn’t really have the acting ability to pull it off. Both him and Scott Glenn actually. This film would have been in trouble if not for the wonderful Sissy Spacek. A thoroughly deserved Oscar nomination for her.
I mean it isn’t the focus like in A Clean Escape but there are other energetic one take tracking shot scenes in Rydell’s other films like Crime of the Century as well (a legendary supporting cast). About the Lindbergh kidnapping case. Which actually was the inspiration for Agatha Christie’s Murder on the Orient Express. The excellent frame and introduction of the James Dean character in James Dean with the large shadow. Slow motion use in the last section/climax. The best of which is I think in The Reivers. The stunning split diopter scene in The Reivers which I think takes that film to another level. Another great use of this is the Vietnam war raid sequence in For the Boys. Simply stunning. The eerie staredowns with animals (The Fox, The River).
The metaphors (The fox in The Fox, the congreve clock in Intersection). The rural establishing shots (The River, The Fox, The Cowboys, On Golden Pond). The neon colours in The Rose (which is sort of specific to that film). Although Cinderella Liberty also concerns the New York street scene. Which is a very different setting than the above mentioned rural settings. It’s crazy to go from The Rose to On Golden Pond. The Rose is brimming with energy both in the performance and the direction. While On Golden Pond is reflective, melancholic. Although there is a great “lost in the forest” sequence in On Golden Pond as well. Non verbal and non acting focused. Which is also the case with the stunning flood sequence in The River. Telling a story with images and visuals.
Harry and Walter Go To New York is a lighter film for sure. But it’s technically brilliant. The pacing maybe a hindrance to some. But not to me obviously. It takes like 40 minutes for the main story to even start – haha. I love it. I mean even then it’s not entirely different from his other works because his earlier films also concerned adventure and discovering a new world (The Reivers, The Cowboys). Harry and Walter Go to New York doesn’t have the coming-of-age aspect of the other two though. Children encountering adult situations. Killing off major characters or the lead is another thing with Rydell. One instance is quite famous.
It’s also fascinating the way Rydell uses Steve McQueen in The Reivers and John Wayne in The Cowboys respectively. This isn’t the good ol’ John Wayne and Steve McQueen beat the bad guys type of film. They are only an element of the film and part of the greater whole. Actually they are playing second fiddle to the child actor/s in the narrative in these films. It’s honestly refreshing. The relationship they have and develop with the child actor/s is the crux of these films. In a periodic vast natural landscape backdrop.
Rydell made films about life and death
“The film was the subject of McGrew v. City of Jackson, Mississippi, a federal case on the constitutionality of the state of Mississippi’s obscenity statute. The statute prohibited any “exhibit to public view on a screen or otherwise, any obscene, indecent, or immoral picture,” and authorizes an officer to make an arrest at any time without a warrant for a misdemeanor committed in his presence. In 1968, two police officers and the city prosecuting attorney as paid guests visited a local theater in Jackson during a showing of The Fox. At the conclusion of the showing, the police officers arrested the theater owner, Irene McGrew, and seized the entire film.”
“McGrew appealed the conviction, claiming that the Mississippi statute violated the first and fourteenth amendments of the United States Constitution which guarantees freedom of expression. In a 2-1 vote, the judges of the United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi upheld the conviction, saying the statute was constitutional. The majority said, “The dominant theme of The Fox film is sex in a raw state in a product which the producers have attempted to whitewash and clean up just sufficiently to possibly escape condemnation as utter filth.” The dissenting judge said, “I think that the applicable Mississippi obscenity statute fails to meet the constitutional requirements of the first and fourteenth amendments guaranteeing freedom of expression.”
Regarding The Fox
Rydell should have been Oscar-nominated for The Fox, not On Golden Pond. He got extremely close actually (Golden Globes nominated) but missed out to Richard Brooks for In Cold Blood who replaced him in the lineup at the Oscars. It’s a strange connection that both this film and Intersection were shot in Canada and features a love triangle. These two films also mark the period (1967-1994) where Rydell was a big name director in the industry. Some actors apparently begged him to get roles like Sharon Stone for Intersection. Which makes sense with his strong track record with actresses. I think he got actresses nominated 5 times in the lead category and once in the supporting category at the Oscars winning two of them. And that’s not including Anne Heywood, who only got as far as the Golden Globes for The Fox in the lead category. The Fox is actually the smallest film out of the lot in the 1967-1994 period and is better for it. It was a commercial success upon release and launched Rydell’s career. The Fox was also known (at the time, because it is buried now) as one of if not the key film that showed the dissolution of the Production Code and took advantage of it to show more mature themes. It’s a taboo film. Keir Dullea was also definitely a notable thing in the industry in the 1960’s before Kubrick cast him in 2001: A Space Odyssey. David and Lisa was his breakthrough role. These films are very obscure now but were big when they were released.
The film poster for The Fox (1967) has my vote as one of the top 10 film posters ever
@Malith- great call- beautiful
Favourite scene from every Mark Rydell-:
* The Fox (1967) – The Fox staredown
* The Reivers (1969) – Lucius’ grandfather questions his actions
* The Cowboys (1972) – The raid by the scavengers at night
* Cinderella Liberty (1973) – Lost among soldiers
* Harry and Walter Go to New York (1976) – The meticulous protection of the bank safe by the Charles Durning character
* The Rose (1979) – The phone booth scene in front of the stadium
* On Golden Pond (1981) – Lost in the forest
* The River (1984) – The Deer staredown
* For the Boys (1991) – The Vietnam war raid sequence
* Intersection (1994) – The phone booth scene in front of the shop
* Crime of the Century (1996) – The Electric Chair scene
* James Dean (2001) – The Epilogue
* Even Money (2006) – The Epilogue
I’d highly recommend you check out Marketa Lazarová from this year, from what I can tell you haven’t seen it yet, but its definitely a film that would fit in perfectly quite high on this list. I’m not long fresh off my first watch of it and its shot composition alone could make it fit in here.
Mark Rydell filmography ranked-:
Films:
1. The Fox (1967) – MP
2. Intersection (1994) – MS
3. The Rose (1979) – MS
4. The River (1984) – MS
5. The Reivers (1969) – HR/MS
6. The Cowboys (1972) – HR/MS
7. Even Money (2006)
8. James Dean (2001)
9. Crime of the Century (1996)
10. Harry and Walter Go to New York (1976)
11. On Golden Pond (1981)
12. Cinderella Liberty (1973)
13. For the Boys (1991) – R
Performances:
1. Bette Midler – The Rose
2. John Wayne – The Cowboys
3. Richard Gere – Intersection
4. Anne Heywood – The Fox
5. Sandy Dennis – The Fox
6. James Franco – James Dean
7. James Caan – Cinderella Liberty
8. Stephen Rea – Crime of the Century
9. Henry Fonda – On Golden Pond
10. Forest Whitaker – Even Money
11. Kim Basinger – Even Money
12. Sissy Spacek – The River
13. Frederic Forrest – The Rose
14. Marsha Mason – Cinderella Liberty
15. Keir Dullea – The Fox
16. Danny DeVito – Even Money
17. Roscoe Lee Browne – The Cowboys
18. James Caan – For the Boys
19. Isabella Rossellini – Crime of the Century
20. Michael Moriarty – James Dean
21. J.T. Walsh – Crime of the Century
22. Michael Moriarty – Crime of the Century
23. Rupert Crosse – The Reivers
24. Mitch Vogel – The Reivers
25. Jane Fonda – On Golden Pond
26. Michael Caine – Harry and Walter Go to New York
27. Charles Durning – Harry and Walter Go to New York
28. Bruce Dern – The Cowboys
29. Tim Roth – Even Money
30. Steve McQueen – The Reivers
31. Eli Wallach – Cinderella Liberty
32. Sharon Farrell – The Reivers
33. Lolita Davidovich – Intersection
34. Mel Gibson – The River
35. Sharon Stone – Intersection
36. Dabney Coleman – On Golden Pond
37. Will Geer – The Reivers
38. Bette Midler – For the Boys
39. Katharine Hepburn – On Golden Pond
40. Grant Sullivan – Even Money
The Fox (1967) feels a lot like a Roman Polanski film. It’s very similar to his psychological menage a trois trilogy (Knife in the Water, Cul-De-Sac, Death and the Maiden). Especially Knife in the Water. The deteriorating animal corpse is from Repulsion. This is based on a D.H. Lawrence novel (he also wrote Women in Love which Ken Russell adapted into a film in 1969). The Fox is unusual from the Polanski’s in that the central relationship is not that of the opposite gender. The female/s are not dependent/victims of men but rather strong hard working independent characters.
Another difference is the fascination with wildlife and nature which is a trait of Mark Rydell’s. These are not the urban apartments or tree less islands that are in the Polanski films but rather a forrest based location where the dangers from animals and natural disasters are everywhere. It’s a snow film as well. This type of rural living was also depicted in The River (1984). Where the central couple never gives up despite the heavy challenges and rejects the temptation of a supposedly better, modern living in favour of protecting and surviving in their livelihood in tough conditions.