- Promising Young Woman is one of those rare films that you immediately look forward to watching again after you’re done- there is much to unpack.
- It marks the debut film for Emerald Fennell who wrote and directed (winning an Oscar for the screenplay). She is an actress as well. It is a choice role for Carey Mulligan. I think on a per-minute basis she is better in Steve McQueen’s Shame (2011)—but it is tough to compare because she is in almost every frame here in Promising Young Woman as she plays Cassandra.
- Fennell’s film starts with some strong slow-motion photography (which she’ll call back to at the end of the film), and quickly after that we get a glimpse at her dedication to a very specific pastel dollhouse vision for her world through color and production design. Cassandra’s fingernails are loudly painted, there are colored chilis above the bed, there is hot pink lighting galore.

Emerald Fennell has a clear eye for composition- details here like the little chilis at the top of the frame
- Fennell’s screenplay fearlessly shifts tone. But it is razor sharp- she pulls it off- it is never grating or awkward. There will be some violence, or seriously offensive behavior (by any number of male characters in the film- essentially everyone except for the Alfred Molina character) and then Mulligan’s Cassandra will punctuate a scene with a “Your novel sounds terrible by the way” hilarious one-liner. The success in mixing the tones is a compliment to both Fennell’s writing, and Mulligan’s performance.

there is a lot to unpack in that first viewing, the details here of the wilted plants — perfectly flanking Mulligan’s Cassandra
- There is a subtext here throughout. Prey vs. predator (two references to Laughton’s Night of the Hunter– a scene from the film, and a lullaby sung). There is a Panique (1946, Duvivier—false accusation, group think, sort of a Kaftaesque rigged system society) poster as well.
- Fennell often frames the characters (especially in Cassandra’s home) through hallways— showing the isolation between her and her parents (marked by the preceding devastating incident that is never fully shown).
- Confectionery in design- like a Brittany Spears video (a key song in the film, a horror version/– all strings version of “Toxic”). Paris Hilton’s song in the pharmacy (as a disarmingly charming Bo Burnham sings along with Mulligan).
- Burnham’s “my parents wanted me to be a deejay” line- haha
- Pink roman numbers mark the chapters—her revenge hit list- she is righting wrongs.

A great on-a-wall-in-a-museum frame of the Blue Star lounge at the 55-minute mark

Another at the 65-minute mark with the pink sweater and blue background
- Highly Recommend rating for now- perhaps even leaning HR/MS excited to revisit
It’s fascinating how Emerald Fennell has completely lost her critical following with Saltburn and Wuthering Heights. (Promising Young Woman is at #6 for 2020 in the TSPDT 21st Century List). And not even in an Ari Aster (Beau Is Afraid, Eddington) or Maggie Gyllenhaal (The Bride!) type of way where the film gets mediocre reviews but there is a strong following from certain critical groups. Believe it or not, Saltburn is at #519 for 2023 in the TSPDT 21st Century List. Wild. And it doesn’t look like Wuthering Heights would fare any better. They do have large mainstream viewing though. So, I don’t think Fennell would have any trouble getting funding for her films. I didn’t realize she used to work as an actress (she is in Joe Wright’s Anna Karenina).
I was disappointed by Wuthering Heights. There are aspects to praise for sure. Like the photography, Costume Design, Production Design etc. Not sure the latter two are period accurate though. But it didn’t feel at all like a movie. And I giggle at these diversity casting decisions. Hollywood casting directors are not even trying anymore. This is fresh off my mind after Rob Marshall’s The Little Mermaid. This film has such a diverse cast – haha. So much so that an entire family consists of different races. Coming to Wuthering Heights, there is a Pakistani real estate owner in 18th Century England. A Chinese maid. Rather head scratching. There is a lot of this in Branagh’s Poirot movies too. I think criticizing this is valid. Because these are not contemporary settings and are based on classic period source material. The casting is so good and accurate in older films set in these time periods.
I thought Saltburn was very strong. It would be fascinating to watch it and Wuthering Heights together and compare them. For one, I like the more contemporary setting in Saltburn (based on Fennell’s own life I presume) which suits Fennell much more.
Wuthering Heights somehow only has a 59 on Rotten Tomatoes. I’m watching it today.
@Malith – what did you think?
@Harry- Didn’t like it as much as Saltburn.
@Malith – neither. The production design and use of colour was stunning for sure. But the soundtrack was a complete disaster, the overall narrative and performances all feel like a step down from Saltburn as well.
@Harry- It can’t touch the 1939 William Wyler Classic.
Yeah, the Charli xcx vocals felt out of place. Not sure about the opening scene either. Or the merging of the father/son characters.
@Drake-Do you have Saltburn as one of the best of 2023? Will you place it above Promising Young Woman? What did you think about Keoghan’s performance here?
@Malith- Thank you for the comment and question. I have been able to catch Saltburn – I’m hoping to get to the 2023 page soon-ish. I think there are maybe 5-6 movies I really to get to before putting together the 2023 page.
@Drake-Were you able to catch Napoleon? Do you think it is worthy of the archives? Very uneven film. Especially the opening half.
I was VERY impressed by Saltburn when I saw it a few weeks ago. Like PYW, it felt very intentionally put together style-wise and had a tight but very blunt/unsubtle script. However, it had a lot of its own advantages and felt like a clear evolution in many ways.
The silhouette of Oliver walking towards Venetia against crisp blue light, the very busy reflection shot of Oliver with the candles, and the shot of the devastation on the lawn were some of the exemplary compositions I remember. Not to mention, reoccurrences like the heavy use of red, the few long tracking shots, and the shot of Oliver slowly unrolling the window gave the film some much-needed coherence. All in all, the lighting choices and compositions did feel like a step up from PYW, even if that film had more eye-catching colour usage moments.
The ending being a divisive topic is definitely warranted and I do think it could have been stronger, but at the same time it’s consistent with Promising Young Woman. Fennell loves her big, grand, and elaborate commeuppances that are fully revealed in the final minutes. Even if it’s ultimately not the most interesting ending thematically, it does feature that excellent final tracking shot that pairs with the earlier “tour of the place” tracking shot to bookend Oliver’s time in Saltburn.
Overall, thought this was weaker than Promising Young Woman in narrative and pacing, but it was overall a stylistic upgrade and ultimately the more ambitious film. I’d say I preferred Saltburn even though both were great.
Please Emerald Fennell keep making movies
@ga – well said, want to give this another viewing soon, agree on the strength of the compositions. Agree with your final line, Emerald Fennel is for real, this is auteur cinema. Cannot wait to see more from her
Saltburn (2023) from Emerald Fennell is an impressive albeit flawed film. What is evident, is that Emerald Fennell is auteur and that is always encouraging. Similar to Promising Young Woman (2020) this film is not subtle but does not go into preachy territory despite its subject matter. Many similarities to The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999) only Barry Keoghan’s character does not climb into a highher social status as seamlessly as Matt Damon’s character. Speaking of climbing status, Barry Keoghan is slowly becoming one of the best actors of his generation.
@James-I am yet to see Saltburn but I don’t yet thing Keoghan deserves to be in a conversation for the best actor of his generation. It’s clearly Chalamet. Boyega is there too. The film is great. But I don’t think he was particularly good in Killing of a Sacred Deer. He comes across as very unlikable to me as well
@Malith – I agree, I am not saying that he is The best, but rather one of the best or at least on his way in that direction.
“He comes across as very unlikable to me as well” – Agree, but that works to his favor in the films I have seen him in, he can play dark, menacing characters
Plus, he is working with quality auteurs which is encouraging:
The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017) – Yorgos Lanthimos
Dunkirk (2017) – Christopher Nolan
Eternals (2021) – Chloé Zhao
The Banshees of Inisherin (2022) – Martin McDonagh
Saltburn (2023) – Emerald Fennell
Bird (upcoming film) – Andrea Arnold
I almost forgot Eternals was directed by Chloe Zhao. The much anticipated follow-up to Nomadland already happened. Haha
@James-Batman 2-Matt Reeves
@Drake – Is this on your radar?
https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/saltburn
@James Trapp- it is- I am excited for this one from what I’ve heard despite the 60 score right now on metacritic
@Drake – I was waiting for you to review this one! I thought it was amazing. You picked some great examples above of the photography and there were numerous others. I predicted you’d have it as a MS – maybe you’ll get there! Hard to believe it was Fennell’s first film.
@Matt– A very impressive film- especially for a first time filmmaker. Excited to see what Fennell does next
A lot of impressive aspects to this film
– Splendid use of color
– As stated above the changes in tone are highly effective
– I always love genre blends, here we have a comedy with melodrama and thriller elements
– normally not a big Britney Spears fan, but love the way it uses Toxic, almost feels like a music
video at times
– Carey Mulligan dominates every scene she’s in; she is simultaneously in command and
vulnerable
– While I am usually wary of “issue movies” I thought this one didn’t go overboard in terms of
becoming “preachy”, some might disagree due to its portrayal of men, none the less I
thought I think Mulligan’s character was portrayed with some nuance as the film does seem
to question many of her actions
– definitely looking forward to any future films from Fennell