- Jane Campion’s return to the archives (twelve years since 2009’s Bright Star) centers on two brothers (Phil and George Burbank played by Benedict Cumberbatch and Jesse Plemons) and a mother and son (Kirsten Dunst as Rose Gordon and Kodi Smit-McPhee as Peter Gordon). The fifth and sixth characters in the film are the breathtaking vistas of New Zealand (as a stand in for early twentieth century Montana) and Jonny Greenwood’s grand score (what a year for Greenwood with Spencer arriving just a few weeks earlier).
- The two brothers are two sides of a coin. Cumberbatch’s Phil is absolutely barbarous. This is a rich character (torturing himself along with the others)- even when he does not speak, his savagery fills the room and there is a palpable uncomfortable tension in every scene that he is in. Phil worships at the memory of Bronco Henry, represses his sexuality, and his complexities include his secret haven tucked away in the brush. Phil’s feelings towards Peter evolve as the story progresses as well. This may be Cumberbatch’s best work and The Power of the Dog serves as a reminder that Cumberbatch’s skill as a vocal actor- maybe only Tom Hardy can match him among current actors. Plemons’ quiet “Fatso” (as called by Phil) loves Rose (Campion and Greenwood help Dunst capture a heartbreaking fragility), but he does not have the power to save Rose (Phil’s prime target). This leaves Peter as the unlikely guardian of his mother.
- A stupendous shot of (praise again due to Campion and cinematographer Ari Wegner) of blood on the prairie wheat.
- Campion tells the story in chapters with an opening and closing voice over from Peter: “when my father passed, I wanted nothing more than my mother’s happiness”
- Recommend/ Highly Recommend film after one viewing
Hey Drake, got a question unrelated to this specific page. Where does your current labeling system (MP, MS, HR, R) line up on a traditional 1-10 scale?
@Blade- thanks for the comment and for visiting the site. I have never tried to line it up to a 1-10 scale.
Have you seen The Hand Of God yet?
@RK- I have not yet- I should get to it within the next week
This is looking like the favorite to win Best Picture, I gave up on the Oscars years ago but I do like when great non US directors get their due.
There was some controvery with actor Sam Elliot launching some criticism at Jane Campion’s portrayal of the Old West and the fact that it was shot in New Zealand but was set in Montana. I know this site does not normally focus on the U.S. Culture Wars but I did like the way Campion challenged Elliot. From the article:
Campion continued, “You know, like, if you think about Sergio Leone movies, where were they shot? They were shot in Spain, and they are some of the greatest explorations of the Western myth ever made. So, you know, I think it’s just a little bit of a crusty cowboy problem.”
The director also quipped that she and Elliott should meet for a shootout. “OK, Sam, let’s meet down at the Warner Brothers lot for a shootout! I’m bringing Doctor Strange [the character played in Marvel films by Benedict Cumberbatch, who also starred in The Power of the Dog] with me!”
I respect the way Campion made an argument rather than just lobbing insults his way. Also she clearly has a sense of humor.
Source:
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/jane-campion-sam-elliott-the-power-of-the-dog-1235111500/
@James Trapp- Thanks for sharing. I saw the story headline but had not looked at the full quotes.
@Drake – yeah, I normally don’t care all that much about Hollywood gossip stories but was reading about some of the Best Picture nominees. I admire the way Campion handled it. It would be great if more people responded to critics using intelligent arguments and engaging with people rather than the usual tactics of just labeling someone they disagree with a bad person.
[…] The Power of the Dog – Campion […]
Drake,
What do you think of Jesse Plemons as an actor? Not just in this film but in general?
He is so understated to the point where it may seem like underacting but I find him to
be quite compelling in this simplicity. He’s like the polar opposite of someone like Sean Penn
or Al Pacino.
He’s quietly compiled quite a resume:
The Power of the Dog (2021)
Judas and the Black Messiah (2021)
I’m Thinking About Ending Things (2020)
The Irishman (2019)
Black Mass (2015)
Bridge or Spies (2015)
The Master (2012)
Obviously some of these are minor roles but still
Not to mention his success in TV, particularly Breaking Bad and of course
the success of Breaking Bad resulted in a film El Camino (2019) of which he
had a significant role.
@James Trapp- Big admirer of Jesse Plemons’ work- like you said some minor roles, but ten archiveable films by my count so far and a standout wow of a performance in “I’m Thinking of Ending Things”
2012- The Master
2015- Black Mass
2015- Bridge of Spies
2017- The Post
2018- Vice
2019- The Irishman
2020- I’m Thinking of Ending Things
2021- Judas and the Black Messiah
2021- The Power of the Dog
2022- Windfall
@Drake – Yeah, I’m excited to revisit I’m Thinking of Ending Things. Before watching that I still liked him a lot but wasn’t sure on his ability to carry a film as the lead role. Yet he manages to be impressive without you really noticing it.
@James & Drake – fun fact about Plemmons is in the adaptation of Cormac McCarthy’s “All The Pretty Horses” he played the child version of Matt Damon’s character and he grew up to look almost like a dead ringer.
@James – if you’re doing TV I highly recommend watching the Black Mirror episode with Plemmons titled “USS Calister”, I’ve seen this like 5 times now and its great everytime. His best performance to me.
@Harry – that is funny, not familiar with Black Mirror but I’ll look into it, I think it’s on Netflix.