best film: The Revenant from Alejandro González Iñárritu
The Revenant gives Inarritu back to back best films of the year which is close to unfathomable. However, 2015 is not a year with a clear winner in this category- George Miller’s Mad Max: Fury Road feels like a virtual tie. But still, there is no harm in celebrating and appreciating The Revenant.
- A masterpiece of staggering beauty and cinematic awe
- Opens with a dream montage – incredible imagery, and then the cinematic gauntlet is thrown down with the hunting scene starting with the camera aimed down at the stream and capturing a complex tracking shot. Iñárritu brings back a variation on the drum score from Birdman, the framing of character faces from I Am Cuba, and low angle work from Welles
- The very next sequence is a complex battle tracking shot at magic hour—it is Saving Private Ryan (visceral) meets The Thin Red Line (beautiful) and the best of both- muscular filmmaking- sumptuous photography and complex blocking/choreography.
- The camera tilts up to the sky following the smoke
- I sometimes talk about rolling tracking shots- bracketed or controlled like Wes Anderson, Kubrick in the trenches in Paths of Glory or hotel in The Shining but these here in The Revenant are floating—more like Tarkovsky or Gaspar Noe.
- The bear sequence is impeccably crafted – a comment on the inevitability of nature, death, sadness for the cubs- shot in long take- true to Iñárritu’s style
- Tom Hardy as Tom Berenger in Platoon (Hardy costarred with Berenger in Inception actually). He is half-scalped, has southern drawl, “All you have to do is blink” horrifying scene. It is a comment on the yin and yang nature of he and DiCaprio’s character. Berenger and Willem Dafoe in Platoon were the devil and Christ figure—and here Hardy and DiCaprio are opposites on how they treat man and nature.
- Like all of Iñárritu’s work- especially Amores Perros, Babel, 21 Grams – he is piecing together separate strands of narrative and making a comment on how they intersect (often to hurt each other) – in one film these strands are misconnecting because of language (Babel). That is happening here. This is auteur cinema in content as well as visual style even if it is a small flaw that Iñárritu takes too long between the strands of the Chief looking for his daughter.
- Albeit brief, the bond between DiCaprio’s Glass and his son Hawk is earned. Repetition in their laying their heads on each other chests, the surrealism sequences of past tragedy.
- Those surrealism sequences are gorgeous. The pile of skulls set pieces, Iñárritu matches the breathing on the camera to the mist in the mountains in an edit.
- In step with Iñárritu’s view on humanity- dog-eat-dog nihilism. Iñárritu’s debut—people slaughtering others, cruelty, the man who befriend’ s DiCaprio’s Glass is hung by the French, the Pawnee, Arikara Indians, often called Ree, wolves eating Bison.
- Long takes in natural lighting, no dialogue, the shot of DiCaprio getting fish, up against nature, up a ridge then overlooking the splendor of nature—brutality and loveliness mixed (Malick)– certainly a powerfully repeated motif.
- striking sequence of the church in ruins—belongs in Tarkovsky’s world—enchanting
- The juxtaposition of how Hardy’s character and DiCaprio’s treat nature is shown again and again comes full circle in the end- DiCaprio saves the daughter of the Chief and it saves him. Instead of attacking the man eating the bison liver DiCaprio is kind to him and he saves him in return.
- At the 131 minute mark- the avalanche on the mountain after DiCaprio sees Gleeson scalped—set piece genius. This is Herzog carrying a boat over a mountain stuff. Awe.
- The last twenty minutes turn into a fantastic western revenge showdown between the two foes
most underrated: There are some ugly misses here by the TSPDT consensus. It is hard to look past The Revenant at #27 from 2015. The consensus made a little progress on The Revenant since 2016 when it debuted on the TSPDT 21st century list which is good. Films this spectacular do not go overlooked for long and it should continue to rise above more artistically modest films. Sicario from Denis Villeneuve is at #34- yuck. Perhaps even worse than that are Sunset Song from Terence Davies, Tale of Tales from Matteo Garrone and Victoria from Sebastian Schipper getting left off the 21st century TSPDT top 1000 entirely (meaning they are not among the top 42 films from 2015 listed). To miss this badly on five of the ten best films of 2015 is a problem.
most overrated: If one compares Spotlight (still sitting way too high at #11 of 2015 on the TSPDT), Inside Out (#4 of 2015), or Cemetery of Splendor (#7 of 2015) to the films listed under the “underrated” heading- well- there really is no comparison. Cemetery of Splendor does not hold the beauty of Weerasethakul’s previous works. Spotlight is a fine film led by a compelling story and capable actors but it is at least a dozen slots too high and Inside Out is great- it just needs to move out of the way on the top ten to make way for superior films.
trends and notables:
- More dominance from the Nuevo Cine Mexicano trio but with a special emphasis on Iñárritu of course. Iñárritu is far too often overlooked as one of the great filmmakers of his generation.
- There is no other auteur in cinema history to rewrite his story at the age 70 like George Miller has with Mad Max: Fury Road. For years—really decades, Miller’s best work stood as The Road Warrior (or Mad Max 2) from 1981. There was not much of note from Miller since (a few archiveable films, none of them landing in their respective years top 10). It certainly felt like he was done as a cinematic artist of consequence. Mad Max : Fury Road destroys that notion—or rather, sets it on fire.
- Star Wars came back (with The Force Awakens) and blew up the box office but still, the two biggest stories as far as film art is concerned remains the back to back consecutive year dominance of Iñárritu and the comeback of the year award to George Miller. Both of these films changed the artistic historical narrative on these two auteurs.
- World cinema remains in a very good place in 2015. Nine different countries are represented by the top ten films. These ten films came from filmmakers born in Mexico, Australia, Hungary, the US, the UK, Canada, China, Germany and Italy.
- one-take cinema has another worthy entry- Sebastian Schipper’s Victoria picks off where Birdman left off
- Todd Haynes’ Carol is the third leg of the housewife trilogy (my term- but I think it fits) which includes Safe in 1995 and Far From Heaven in 2002– Haynes has made other fine films- but it is this trilogy for which he will be remembered.
- As far as firsts go, 2015 marks the true debut of László Nemes (Son of Saul) and Robert Eggers (The Witch)- they would both have time before the decade was up to prove themselves yet again (Nemes in 2018 with Sunset and Eggers in 2019 with The Lighthouse).
- Star Wars is a smash- but the Jurassic Park reboot is not far behind as far as big moneymakers in 2015 and in fact, within the calendar year, it is a bit bigger. This gives Chris Pratt the #1 film in back to back years with Guardians of the Galaxy in 2014 and clearly makes him one of the biggest movie stars on the planet.
- Daniel Kaluuya seems destined to be one of the great actors of this generation and he got his start in the archives in 2015’s Sicario.
- Noah Baumbach is sort of quietly firing away- Mistress America is here in 2014 and that gives Baumbach four archiveable films in six years after taking sixteen years (16) for his first four archiveable films
gems I want to spotlight: The obvious choice here seems to be Bone Tomahawk and I am not going to try to outthink it. S. Craig Zahler has a unique voice and here is where it begins. The Witch does feel like the start of two promising careers: Robert Eggers and actor Anya Taylor-Joy. Yorgos Lanthimos’ The Lobster is his first English-language and it is an inarguable artistic success as well.
best performance male: It is Leo’s year. He is clearly one of the best actors of his generation (probably the single best) and has already been in several films throughout the 90s, 00s and 10s that were amongst the best of the year or decade. In The Revenant he gives a great physical performance in the year’s best film- it is indeed DiCaprio‘s finest work. It is different than most of his work- it is physical vs. verbal, but his weathered face is a brilliant canvas— pained, resolute— DiCaprio is aided by Iñárritu’s camera- actor friendly close-ups of those glassy blue eyes, lines like “I ain’t afraid to die, I’ve done it already”. DiCaprio’s dedication to the role is admirable but always in service of character and story and the brutality of the world of the film. Behind Leo, Tom Hardy has to be next. Hardy is an integral part to both of 2015’s big, hairy, masterpieces. Hardy’s achievements in 2015 do not come all that close to DiCaprio (or Charlize Theron) but that is more of a compliment to DiCaprio/Theron and it would be wrong to overlook Hardy just because he is standing next to the best overall male and female actors of the year. Géza Röhrig‘s in Son of Saul runs a similar endurance test marathon of a physical performance to DiCaprio (though Röhrig does not get the benefit of how Iñárritu frames DiCaprio)- worthy of the third slot. Benecio Del Toro levitates in Sicario – adding another acting coup to his strong career. Scottish veteran actor Peter Mullan does the best work of his career (and he is standout in just about everything he has been in) in Davies’ Sunset Song. Colin Farrell made two excellent films in the 2010s with Lanthimos- The Lobster here in 2015 and The Killing of a Sacred Deer in 2017- so he is getting a combined mention here as this is where he is slightly better. I am also right on the edge with Nicolas Hoult’s work in Mad Mad: Fury Road. He gives the second best performance in the film (Theron of course) but Hardy is here for both Fury Road and The Revenant.
best performance female: Charlize Theron may have won an Oscar for Monster in 2003 but she will be remembered forever for her work in Mad Max: Fury Road. Theron’s performance is physical with her nearly six-foot tall frame swinging her hips like John Wayne in the desert. Cate Blanchett has to be next for Carol with Rooney Mara, her costar, not far behind. Blanchett looks like a towering figure next to Mara- big presence- she feels larger than life- regal, elegant. But Mara certainly holds her own. Laia Costa is next for her work in Victoria and Qi Shu collaborates for the third time with Hou Hsiao-Hsien resulting in their best work of the three: The Assassin.
- The Revenant
- Mad Max: Fury Road
- Son on Saul
- Sunset Song
- The Assassin
- Tale of Tales
Archives, Directors, and Grades
|45 Years- Haigh||R|
|A Bigger Splash- Guadagnino||R|
|Anomalisa – C. Kaufman||R|
|Beasts of No Nation- Fukunaga||HR|
|Black Mass- S. Cooper||R|
|Bone Tomahawk- Zahler||R/HR|
|Bridge of Spies- Spielberg||R|
|Carol – Haynes, Blacnhett||HR/MS|
|Cemetery of Splendor -Weerasethakul||R|
|Creed – Coogler||HR/MS|
|Crimson Peak – del toro||HR|
|Embrace of the Serpent – Guerra||R/HR|
|Inside Out– Docter||R|
|James White – Mond||R|
|Kalil Blues – Gan Bi||R|
|Knight of Cups – Malick||R|
|Land of Mine – Zandvliet||R|
|Louder Than Bombs- Trier||R|
|Mad Max: Fury Road – G. Miller||MP|
|Maggie’s Plan- R. Miller||R|
|Me and Earl and the Dying Girl- Gomez-Rejon||R|
|Mississippi Grind- Fleck, Boden||R|
|Mistress America- Baumbach||HR|
|Mountains May Depart– Zhangke Jia||R|
|Mustang – Ergüven||R|
|Queen of Earth- Ross Perry||R|
|Son of Saul – Nemes||MS|
|Spotlight – McCarthy||R|
|Star Wars: The Force Awakens – Abrams||R|
|Steve Jobs- Boyle||R/HR|
|Sunset Song– Davies||HR/MS|
|Tale of Tales – Garrone||HR/MS|
|Tangerine – Baker||HR|
|The Assassin – Hsiao-Hsien Hou||HR/MS|
|The Big Short- McKay||HR|
|The Danish Girl- Hooper||R/HR|
|The Devil’s Candy – Byrne||R|
|The Diary of a Teenage Girl – Heller||R|
|The End of the Tour- Ponsoldt||R|
|The Hateful Eight – Tarantino||R|
|The Invitation– Kusama||R|
|The Lobster – Lanthimos||HR|
|The Martian- R. Scott||R|
|The Revenant– Iñárritu||MP|
|The Witch – Eggers||R/HR|
|Victoria – Schipper||HR/MS|
|Youth – Sorrentino||R|
*MP is Masterpiece- top 1-3 quality of the year film
MS is Must-See- top 5-6 quality of the year film
HR is Highly Recommend- top 10 quality of the year film
R is Recommend- outside the top 10 of the year quality film but still in the archives
“Saving Private Ryan (visceral) meets The Thin Red Line (beautiful) and the best of both”
I like this
Better opening battle scene: The Revenant vs Saving Private Ryan?
I actually think the opening battle in The Revenant between the Trappers and Arikara Tribe is even more shocking and brutal, I don’t know if this necessarily makes it superior but I can say that it was one of the craziest and quickest escalations of violence in just about any film I’ve ever seen. With Saving Private Ryan you at least have an idea about what is going to happen as the Americans are shown on a boat on the way to the assault on Omaha Beach. The actual violence for both is horrific but feels even more intense in The Revenant as the attacks seem to be coming from every direction.
Other similarities include the switch to subject POV using sound, for both the Tom Hanks and DiCaprio character the volume decreases significantly to demonstrate the deafening impact of the violence which sends them into a temporary trance like state.
Both amazing but I actually prefer The Revenant
The Revenant at #27 for 2015 lol
There are not 26 films better over the course of the entire decade let alone a single year
Regarding DiCaprio’s performance I am curious what are some of the great performances that involve little spoken dialogue (not including silent films) ?
@James Trapp- Harry Dean Stanton in Paris, Texas and Ethan Hawke in First Reformed.
@James Ralph Fienes in Spider
Liv Ullmann in Persona is a good choice here as well as Charlize Theron in Mad Max: Fury Road fighting for that top spot of 2015.
I realize the film itself isn’t nearly strong enough for a mention, but what do you think of Depp’s performance as Whitey Bulger? I loved it, very over the top. The material itself and acting talent involved could have made for a strong film with a better director in my opinion.
@James Trapp – Agreed here. Scott Cooper keeps getting these really good actors in his films. He’s getting Christian Bale to work with him in the third time in The Pale Blue eyes coming out soon.
@Drake – not sure he would do Boston crime but Michael Mann might have been an interesting choice even if he was past his prime, plus he worked with Depp 6 years earlier in Public Enemy with Depp playing a similar type of psychopath although Whitey Bulger is even more vicious. Taylor Sheridan seems to prefer westerns to urban crime thrillers but he may have been an interesting choice. I still enjoyed revisiting this none the less but definitely felt like it was somewhat of a missed opportunity with the acting talent and intriguing material.
@James Trapp – right exactly. And I like Scott Cooper, appreciate his films, and do not mean to bad mouth his work. It just sort of limits the ceiling on how good the film is going to be knowing he’s going to be at the helm.
@Drake – was Sicario (2015) downgraded with HR/MS ? On the Villeneuve page its listed as MS.
I realized its a minor drop off but just curious. I watched it again recently and then again the next day which is something I don’t do often.
It’s got some phenomenal establishing shots
A forboding score and especially in the drive to Juárez scene
And speaking of that scene, the way Villeneuve uses Juárez almost feels like land as character like
the opening scene to There Will Be Blood (obviously Sicario is not same level)
The narrative propels forward and even at 2 hours flat there are no uncessary scenes, it just moves along
If I have a complaint I would say its the character Kate Macer and to be clear I’m not critiquing the performance more the way the character was written, she comes off as excessively idealistic. Overall Emily Blunt is solid but its Benicio del Toro and Josh Brolin who are the real standouts. Daniel Kaluuya is a great actor, the script just didn’t give him much to do, not really his fault.
And of course you can’t praise this film without mentioning the brutal scene where Del Toro enacts his revenge, shocking even to the top Drug Lord.
I didn’t pick it up on my prior viewings but the films colors become increasingly desaturated as Kate’s idealism gets so casualty stripped away
cont…I forgot to mention but here is a great video analysis on Kate Macer and why this critic believe Kate is actually the films villain.
@James Trapp- I did judge nudge it down a half grade when I updated the year by year archives. Funny you say that Blunt’s character. I have a few other cinephile buddies (who do not comment on the site) who had the same issue.
@Drake – yeah, check out the above video if you get the time (its about 5 min) Like the guy in the video as much as I liked Sicario the 1st couple times there was something that put me off about the Blunt character and the way she tried to impose her beliefs on the rest of the team. Also, have you seen the 2nd film?
@James Trapp- I have seen the second film- a good, gritty little film
@Drake – caught the 2nd one last night, I think I saw part of it when it first came out but didn’t remember much. It was what I expected quality wise. It doesn’t have the same level of suspense as the 1st since we already know the world the film takes place in. Still Del Toro is a more complex character in the 2nd since he isn’t solely driven by revenge. Read that a 3rd is a likely possibility.